Racial Disparities in the Allocation of Wiretap Applications across Federal Judges
Year: 2009
Type: article
Abstract: The degree to which discrimination causes the large racial disparities in the criminal justice system is difficult to measure.This paper studies a process where the influence of race on prosecutors' decisions can be directly identified: the process of obtaining judicial approval to conduct wiretap surveillance.The Department of Justice's strict internal review of wiretap applications implies that federal judges approve all wiretap applications they receive.In this setting, a judge's race should not influence the number of wiretap application she receives, unless prosecutors are biased.The paper tests this prediction using all wiretaps in federal criminal investigations during the years 1997-2007.The results show that African-American judges receive substantially fewer wiretap applications than other judges, even after controlling for other judicial and district characteristics.Consistent with the absence of an incentive to "shop" for favorable judges, other judicial characteristics such as ideology and prior professional experience do not influence the number of wiretap applications received.Nor does statistical discrimination explain the racial gap in wiretap applications; the wiretaps approved by African-American and other judges do not differ in the rates at which they produce incriminating evidence, arrests, or motions to suppress evidence.The results suggest that racial attitudes may influence even sophisticated and closely monitored actors in the criminal justice system, such as federal prosecutors.
Author: Thomas J. Miles
Institution: University of Chicago
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2105900926
