Work

Discussing Prognosis: “How Much Do You Want to Know?” Talking to Patients Who Are Prepared for Explicit Information

Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: HERE'S THE CASEMrs D, a 57-year-old woman with metastatic pancreatic cancer, is discussing treatment options with Dr B. How much should I tell her about prognosis? he wonders.She already seems nervous.Do I hand her the death sentence?Or sugarcoat the statistics?Maybe I'll wait to see if she asks.For the first time Mrs D looks up and says, "What should I expect?"Dr B balks, not having decided what to say."Umm, I can't really predict," he mumbles."Every patient is different."Perhaps I am mumbling, thinks Dr B, because I'm not telling her the whole truth.Mrs D nods vaguely without meeting his gaze and picks up her purse to leave.Is she dissatisfied also?Dr B finds himself in a familiar dilemma: how much information should an oncologist give about a bad prognosis?One of his colleagues prides himself on being a realist, "I tell patients the truth because they need to know, whether they want to hear it or not."Another colleague feels he must give hope, "I go into cheerleader mode."Neither alternative seems optimal to Dr B-the nurses tell him that the realist tone is a little brutal, and that the cheerleader is more than a little clueless.Privately, Dr B feels his own practice-avoiding prognosis by emphasizing individual differences-borders on disingenuous.He knows a lot more about what will happen to Mrs D than he is letting on.Realism, optimism, and avoidance are the most common strategies physicians use in discussing prognosis.1 Although these strategies are well intended and commonly used, they also create unintended consequences.In this article, a patient-centered method for disclosing prognosis is proposed and illustrated.The method builds on existing empirical evidence about discussing prognosis 2,3 by drawing on principles of negotiation and patient-centered approaches.This approach enables an oncologist to figure out what kind of prognostic information to disclose with a particular patient at a particular time and how to individualize the discussion.This article describes how the approach works with a patient who is ready for an explicit discussion.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
Award: G619170547
OpenAlex ID: W2108529422
FWCI: 7.519
Cites: 29
Cited by: 178
Related to: 9