Turning understanding into clinical practice An intervention in continuing professional development based on readiness to change
Year: 2008
Type: dissertation
Study designs: Randomized Controlled Trial, Clinical Trial
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Current continuing medical education (CME) programmes are \noften insufficient in changing doctors performance, and there is a need \nto improve CME and shift toward a more comprehensive continuing \nprofessional development (CPD).The aim of this study was to develop and \nassess the effects of an educational intervention, based on a modified \nstages-of-change model, on general physicians stages of readiness to \nchange, knowledge, attitudes and performance regarding management of \ndepressive disorders in Iran. \n \n \n \nMETHOD: A randomized controlled trial with 192 general physicians in \nprimary care (GPs), who were equally distributed to an intervention and \ncontrol arm, following stratification related to stage of change, sex, \nage and work experience. The intervention comprised an interactive \nworkshop for a small group at a higher stage of readiness-to-change \n( intention ) and an interactive large group meeting for those \ndemonstrating a lower propensity to change ( attitudes ) at the \npre-assessment stage. \n \n \n \nMEASURES: All the measures were validated in the Iranian context. The \nGPs stages-of-change were assessed based on the Modified Prochaska \nQuestionnaire (MPQ), their knowledge and attitudes were assessed using \nwritten questionnaires and their performance was assessed by standardized \npatients (SPs), who filled in checklists regarding the encounter, and \ncollected prescriptions if any. Five different scenarios for depression \ndisorders were compiled by an expert group. The validity and reliability \nof checklists, SPs portrayals and SPs ways of completing checklists \nwere documented. The pre-assessment of GPs performance was done two \nmonths before and the post-assessment two months after the intervention. \n \n \n \nRESULTS: GPs in the intervention arm significantly shifted to a higher \nstage with an intervention effect of 47 percentage units. Their overall \nmean scores on the knowledge test also improved, with an intervention \neffect of 12 percentage units. Although their attitudes changed in the \npost-test in comparison with the pre-test, the difference between the \nintervention and control arms was not significant. The performance of the \nGPs in the intervention arm also improved for mean scores regarding \ndiagnosis, with an intervention effect of 14 percentage units, and for \nappropriate management regarding treatment and referral, with an \nintervention effect of 20 percentage units. The largest changes appeared \nin the small intervention group with intervention effects of 28 and 38 \npercentage units, respectively. \n \n \n \nCONCLUSIONS: The model was successful in improving both knowledge and \npractice according to the theoretical assumptions. It can be used in \neducational interventions within a CPD context.
Source: Figshare
Author: Mandana Shirazi
Institution: Karolinska Institutet
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: continuing professional development, readiness to change, stages of change, depression treatment, general practitioners, primary care, continuing medical education, educational intervention, standardized patients, physician knowledge and attitudes, psychiatric referral, Iranian physicians, interactive workshops, clinical performance assessment
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2109252260
