Work

Expecting the unexpected : beyond teleological information systems development

Year: 2008
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Information systems have become a standard and essential feature of contemporary organisations as they are applied to enable the management of information as an organisational asset in the unstable business world of the knowledge economy.The academic field, though extremely young, is a dynamic permutation of various professional domains and scientific research areas, making information systems a complex and often confusing subject.Traditional information systems development methodologies, like the Systems Development Life Cycle, approach systems development with a teleological paradigm.This implies that information systems should be developed to adhere to a certain set of predefined system requirements.Although organisations have widely accepted this paradigm, some experts argue that it is insufficient when organisations are subject to frequent change as a result of turbulent business sectors.They suggest that information systems will operate in a changing context that will render any predefined set of system requirements futile.In contrast to the teleological paradigm, these experts proclaim the ateleological paradigm as a more suitable approach to information systems development in organisations that require the inherent ability to adapt to a changing environment.The ateleological paradigm approaches an information system as a living system that should have the ability to adapt continuously to emerging or changing system requirements.Instead of being driven by system requirements that were fixed at a specific point in time, these information systems are developed over time continuum to ensure that the system remains relevant with the changing context in which it operates.Tailorable Information Systems (TIS) is an information systems development approach that embodies the ateleological paradigm.As a central principle, TIS operates around the notion that information systems development should be done by the end-users of the system as opposed to the traditional system analysts and developers.By empowering the end-users of an information system with adequate technology and relying on their technical sophistication, organisations can implement truly flexible systems that are particularly responsive to contextual changes.iv In the light of the ateleological paradigm, this thesis critically evaluates traditional information systems development approaches and compares these two approaches that support the notion of an information system as a living system.v Opsomming Inligtingstelsels het ʼn standaard en essensiële element van kontemporêre organisasies geword.Dit speel ʼn integrale rol ter ondersteuning van hulle pogings om inligting as ʼn organisatoriese bate te bestuur in die onstabiele besigheidswêreld van die kennisekonomie.Die akademiese veld, jonk soos dit is, is ʼn dinamiese samekoms van verskeie professionele gebiede en wetenskaplike navorsingsareas.Dit veroorsaak dat inligtingstelsels ʼn komplekse en dikwels verwarrende onderwerp is.Tradisionele stelselontwikkelingsmetodologieë, soos die "Systems Development Life Cycle", benader stelselontwikkeling met ʼn teleologiese paradigma.Dit impliseer dat inligtingstelsels ontwikkel word volgens ʼn stel voorafbepaalde vereistes.Alhoewel hierdie paradigma algemeen deur organisasies aanvaar is, bevraagteken sekere kundiges die nuttigheid daarvan in organisasies wat onderworpe is aan gedurige verandering as gevolg van turbulente besigheidsomgewings.Hulle is van mening dat die veranderende konteks waarin die inligtingstelsel moet funksioneer enige voorafbepaalde stel verseistes nutteloos sal maak.In kontras met die teleologiese paradigma, stel hierdie kundiges voor dat die ateleologiese paradigma ʼn meer gepaste benadering tot stelselontwikkeling is indien organisasies staatmaak op hul vermoë om by ʼn veranderende omgewing aan te pas.Die ateleologiese paradigma benader ʼn inligtingstelsel as 'n lewendige sisteem wat instaat moet wees om aanhoudend aan te pas by nuwe of veranderende vereistes.Instede daarvan dat stelselontwikkeling gedryf word deur vasgestelde vereistes moet hierdie inligtingstelsels oor die verloop van tyd ontwikkel word om te verseker dat dit in pas bly met die veranderende konteks waarbinne dit moet funksioneer."Tailorable Information Systems" (TIS) is ʼn inligtingstelsel-benadering wat die ateleologiese paradigma inkorporeer.As sentrale beginsel, word TIS ontwikkel rondom die idee dat stelselontwikkeling deur die gebruikers van die stelsel gedoen moet word instede van deur die tradisionale stelselanaliste en -ontwikkelaars.Deur gebruikers toe te rus met die toepaslike tegnologie en deur staat te maak op hulle tegniese vaardigheid kan organisasies buigsame inligtingstelsels ontwikkel wat dinamies reageer op kontekstuele veranderinge.Information Systems to manage every aspect of business operations.1 Fruhling and De Vreede accurately state that "information systems that are designed and developed efficiently, accurately, reliably, and meet the intended needs and expectations of the stakeholders are important goals of organisations today". 2 Modern information systems are integrated with organisational procedures to allow the seamless communication of business data among departments and support managers in the decision making process with real-time in-depth business information.Some organisations, often referred to as E-Businesses, extend their internal information systems to connect them with suppliers and consumers through the internet.3 Transaction data is dynamically captured and fed back into financial systems to allow real-time performance analysis.These automated processes are no longer at the cutting edge of business technology, but have become the standard in the knowledge economy. Research ProblemThe birth of the internet and, subsequently, the World Wide Web have played central roles in increasing the turbulence of the modern business world in which all organisations have one thing in common.Change.Like living organisms, organisations are expected to continuously adapt themselves to changing environments to ensure their survival.This constant organisational change leads to challenges for the information systems that operate within such organisations.The knowledge economy, much more than its predecessors 4 , requires information systems to cope with frequently changing or emerging information requirements as the organisational contexts in which they operate become increasingly unstable.1 Pearlson and Saunders state that information systems are integrated with almost every aspect of business in contemporary organisations.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2109833254
Cites: 80
Cited by: 3
Related to: 10