Work

The nature of training and motivation to train in small firms

Year: 2002
Type: other
Abstract: Context and Research Objectives• There is considerable evidence that smaller employers provide less formal training than larger companies and are less likely to participate in government training initiatives.Policymakers and others often regard this as evidence that small employers provide insufficient training.Increasing employers' training efforts is seen as a key means of raising levels of productivity and national economic performance• Small employers are perceived as facing particularly difficult barriers to providing training.Examples include lost working time arising out of releasing staff to undertake training and the financial costs of attending external training courses.The important role that small business plays in the UK economy, as job creators, leads policymakers to have an interest in reducing any barriers to training.• The study has a number of objectives: to understand the issues small employers face in making decisions about training; to examine training provision for owner-managers, new recruits and established employees; to gauge the importance of formal and informal training; to identify employers' motives to provide training; and to assess whether small businesses' informal training can be assessed more formally than at present.Implications for policy are also suggested.• This report is based on a two-stage study of small businesses, defined for the purposes of the study as those with 2-49 employees.The first stage aimed to provide quantitative data on a sufficiently large sample to be able to generalise the findings to the broader business population.Results have been weighted to reflect the structure of the industry and size structure of the small business population.The second stage entailed face-to-face interviews with 50 employers.The purpose of this phase was to provide qualitative data on employers' definitions of training, their motivations for undertaking training and the barriers to providing training. Defining Training• Previous research has shown that employers often define 'training' in very narrow terms, to refer to formal courses or events.Yet research has also shown that small employers particularly tend to rely heavily on informal types of learning and training.• The issue of definition was tackled in different ways in the two stages of the study.In the telephone survey, respondents were invited to think of training "to include any activities at all through which managers and workers improve their work-related skills and knowledge".This phrase was repeated periodically throughout the interview to encourage respondents to think in broad terms about training.In the face-to-face interviews, respondents were initially allowed to define training as they wished, although where a narrow definition was adopted, interviewers were instructed to subsequently encourage respondents to think of training in broad terms. ix• Initially, respondents often claimed they provided no training or were apologetic about the training they did provide because of its informal, on-the-job character.Such practices were often not defined initially as training as they were an integral part of customary working routines.These practices contrast sharply with more formal practices which were felt to be 'proper training'.Once encouraged by interviewers, respondents were often able to discuss their informal training practices and their motives for engaging in them. The Provision of Training for New Recruits, Established Staff and Owner-Managers• The incidence of training provision in the year prior to interview varied with the recipient: 82% provided initial training for new recruits, 59% provided training for established staff, and 40% of owner-manager respondents undertook training.• A training index value was calculated for each enterprise which provides an approximate measure of the proportion of the established workforce receiving training during the previous 12 months i.e. the 'intensity' of training.The weighted index value of 0.27 suggests that slightly more than a quarter of the workforce in small firms received training in the year before the survey.Amongst those employers reporting any training provision in the previous year, the index value is 0.47.Higher than average figures were found in particular sectors ('business and professional services', 'other services); where businesses employed 'professional and technical' staff and 'employed managers'; and in businesses introducing new products or services, major pieces of equipment and major changes in working methods or workforce organisation.• The typical format of training provision, particularly initial training, included on-the-job demonstrations by others of the tasks the new recruit would be required to perform, meeting with other members of the workforce and provision of information concerning the firm's internal administrative procedures.This training was usually provided at the workplace by other members of the workforce; very little involved external organisations.Training for established staff, and particularly that for owner-managers, was more likely to involve formal training episodes with external providers.• The period of initial training was highly variable, depending on both the characteristics of the job and the recruit.Where jobs made relatively few demands of new recruits, initial training was of a few minutes duration.Conversely, where the skills required were complex, the training took place over a number of years in what might best be seen as a period of 'informal apprenticeship'.• For some employers, initial training for new recruits was the only form of workforce training provided.This was especially likely in 'distribution, hotels and catering' where there are a higher proportion of semi-skilled jobs.Another possible reason may be the relatively high rates of labour turnover in this sector.For many such workers, employers may regard continuing training as unnecessary.x• Larger employers were more likely to report the provision of training for all three types of recipient.However, examining trainers only, larger employers were no more likely, on average, to train a higher proportion of their workforces than smaller employers.• The incidence of training provision varied between sector groups.For all three types of recipient (new recruits, established staff, owner-managers), employers in 'other services', 'business and professional services' and 'primary and construction' were most likely to provide training.Conversely, employers in 'manufacturing', 'distribution, hotels and catering' and 'transport and communications' were the least likely. Employer Motivations To Train• Workforce training had two purposes: technical, to equip new recruits with sufficient knowledge and skills to enable them to perform their new work roles to some minimum standard; and social, to secure new recruits' co-operation with the employer's aims and the working relations into which they enter.This latter objective was particularly important for new recruits.• Specifically, employers provided workforce training to provide workers with skills required in their current jobs and to improve business performance.Together, these two motives accounted for 71% of the most important reasons for training.Goals such as training in order to introduce new equipment or software, or to meet legal obligations such as health and safety regulations, were also perceived as important.Other objectives such as providing workers with skills required in future jobs or to provide qualifications were much less important.About one in ten employers felt that training offered no benefits.• The qualitative data, suggested that the 'default position' for the provision of training was inhouse training, primarily for reasons of relevance (because training could be tailored to employers' specific needs) and convenience (training could be undertaken at times chosen by the employer and not to suit an external provider's schedule).Employers provided external training where they lacked adequate knowledge and skills in-house or because there was no option.Many employers attempted to combine the advantages of both methods by bringing external providers in-house to deliver tailored training.In contrast, the quantitative telephone survey data suggested that the sample was evenly divided between those preferring to provide training in-house and those preferring to provide training externally.Again, the reason for the difference might relate to respondents, despite the prompts and exhortations of the interviewer, reverting to a narrower definition of training in the quantitative survey, associating it with formal, external training and excluding in-house or informal types of training. Correlates of Training Provision• The incidence of training provision is associated with businesses which are larger, are in 'business and professional' and 'other' services.The composition of the labour force was also important.Those employers with workforces comprising higher proportions of professional and technical workers were most likely to provide some training in the previous xi 12 months.Those providing training were also more likely to report changes in the workplace in the past year, either as a result of new products and services and/or organisational changes.• Data was inconclusive regarding the links between the provision of training and employment growth (actual and anticipated), sales turnover growth (actual and anticipated) or profit performance.The relationship between each of these factors and each type of training provision is complex; there is no simple positive association between them.• An exploratory multivariate analysis helped 'unpack' the relationships between the incidence and intensity of training provision and business characteristics.Overall, this confirmed the relationship between the incidence and intensity of training provision for established employees and organisational change
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2111595961
Cites: 29
Cited by: 150
Related to: 10