Host and Pathogen Factors Controlling the Rice-Xanthomonas oryzae Interaction
Year: 2009
Type: review
Abstract: Bacterial blight and bacterial streak of rice. Left, Bacterial blight in an experimental field plot in Korea, 2006. Right, Bacterial streak from a test inoculation (courtesy of Dr. A. Bogdanove). Bacterial blight is subject to control by genetic resistance, and rice has representatives of the two major classes of resistance genes (R genes) against the disease, which are given the prefix Xa for Xanthomonas (Table I Cloned R genes of rice Cloned R genes of rice RLK receptors, as a class, respond to a variety of molecules, both exogenous elicitors and endogenous signaling factors. With regard to innate immunity in rice, the molecules produced by Xoo and recognized by XA21 or XA26 have not been fully characterized. However, genetic analyses indicated that the elicitor is likely to be a sulfunated peptide that is secreted through a type I system (da Silva et al., 2004). In Arabidopsis, RLK receptors that signal innate immunity have been shown to respond to bacterial flagellin (FLS2) and elongation factor Tu (EFR; Gomez-Gomez and Boller, 2000; Zipfel et al., 2006). FLS2 and EFR were not formally identified as R genes but as components of the pathogen-associated molecular pattern-triggered immunity (PTI) response (Gomez-Gomez and Boller, 2002; Zipfel et al., 2004). Thus, Xa21, Xa26, and other RLKs are likely to represent genetic components of the PTI surveillance pathway of rice and related species. Xa1 represents the second major class of R genes, the nucleotide-binding site (NBS)-LRR group (Yoshimura et al., 1998). Xa1 expression is elevated upon bacterial infection and, as such, represents one of the cases in which R gene regulation is coordinated with other pathways for defense responses (Yoshimura et al., 1998; Zhang and Gassmann, 2007). Rxo1 from maize (Zea mays) is a member of the NBS-LRR gene family and confers broad resistance to Xoc isolates upon transfer to rice (Zhao et al., 2005). Rxo1-mediated resistance is triggered by strains containing the type III effector gene avrRxo1 from Xoc (Zhao et al., 2004). Although rice has relatively large numbers of NBS-LRR genes, Xa1 remains the only endogenous NBS-LRR gene identified for bacterial resistance (Monosi et al., 2004). Xa1 is effective against some Xoo isolates in Japan but is not effective against most strains from the Philippines. The gene for the elicitor signal from the pathogen has also not been identified for Xa1. Localization of XA27∷GFP. XA27 fused to GFP is found associated with cell plasmalemma and cell wall when cells are plasmolyzed (top). A GFP control is shown at bottom. A complete description of the approach is provided by Wu et al. (2008). P, Plasmolyzed plant cell. Arrows indicate adjoining plant cell wall. Photographs are courtesy of Z. Yin. Two recessive R genes have been characterized from rice. The R gene xa5 confers broad resistance and, oddly, is an allele of the gene for the γ or small subunit of the transcription factor TFIIA (Iyer and McCouch, 2004; Jiang et al., 2006). The recessive allele is not a null allele but differs from the susceptible form by a single codon substitution of Val at position 39 to Glu. TFIIA, consisting of α-, β-, and γ-subunits, is involved in stabilizing the binding of the TATA box-binding protein complex (TFIID) to the TATA box of gene promoters (Hieb et al., 2007). The TFIIA components are highly conserved across the eukaryotes but are not required for transcription of all genes. Rice is unusual in comparison with human and yeast in having two loci for TFIIAγ (Iyer and McCouch, 2004). One gene is on chromosome 5 (TFIIAγ5, xa5) and the other is on chromosome 1 (TFIIAγ1). The proteins are closely related but not identical. The fact that the TFIIAγ5 message is present at greater levels based on hybridization analyses of leaf tissue indicates that TFIIAγ5 is likely the predominant form of the proteins in rice (Iyer and McCouch, 2004; Jiang et al., 2006; Sugio et al., 2007). The presence of two genes raises the question of whether or not rice or an ancestral relative adapted to bacterial infection by duplication of an ancestral gene for TFIIAγ. xa5 may provide effective resistance to bacterial infection while maintaining the necessary functionality for normal rice gene expression under most circumstances. TFIIAγ1 may be needed under some other, as yet unknown, conditions or developmental state, and maintenance of a second gene may have a fitness advantage. However, no evidence has been reported that indicates that xa5 has a detrimental effect under any field or experimental conditions. Additional recessive rice R genes await characterization and may prove as equally fascinating as xa5 (Iyer-Pascuzzi and McCouch, 2007). Another recessive resistance gene, xa13, has been identified by map-based cloning (Chu et al., 2005, 2006). Like xa5, the recessive allele is not a null mutant and encodes a protein related to MtN3, encoding nodulin 3 (N3) protein of Medicago truncatula. The MtN3 gene was first identified in EST libraries of M. truncatula root nodules (Gamas et al., 1996). The dominant allele Xa13 was also named Os8N3 due to the location on rice chromosome 8 and the similarity to MtN3, and that name is used throughout this review (Yang et al., 2006). Os8N3 is a member of a moderately large gene family consisting of 17 to 20 members in rice. Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) also has an 18-member MtN3 family, and the family is also conserved across kingdom boundaries, with related genes in mammals, insects, nematodes, and filamentous fungi, although not to the same degree as TFIIAγ (Chu et al., 2006; Yang et al., 2006; Guan et al., 2008; B. Yang and F.F. White, unpublished data). The critical difference between resistant (xa13/xa13) and susceptible plants is the elevated expression of Os8N3 during bacterial infection in susceptible plant genotypes and the absence of Os8N3 induction during bacterial infection in the resistant genotypes (Yang et al., 2006; Yuan et al., 2009). Knockdown of Os8N3 expression by inhibitory RNA also results in resistance to some bacterial strains, but, unlike xa13 genotypes, silenced plants have low pollen viability and reduced numbers of viable seeds (Chu et al., 2006; Yang et al., 2006). Thus, xa13 confers resistance due to a lack of elevated Os8N3 expression during bacterial infection. Os8N3, therefore, is a susceptibility (S) gene that is exploited by Xoo, and the xa13 resistance is a naturally occurring allele, actually a series of alleles that “fix” a genetic disease vulnerability in the plant developmental pathways (Yang et al., 2006). Bacterial strains that induce Os8N3 expression are virulent, and those strains that normally induce Os8N3 but not the xa13 allele are incompatible. The xa13 gene appears to have been a valuable allele in rice cultivation, as the resistance has occurred in various forms in a variety of cultivars (Chu et al., 2005). The simplest variant is present in ‘BJ1’, where the difference between the resistant and susceptible alleles is a single nucleotide change in the promoter region of the gene. Other variants have more apparent complex alterations, including multiple base changes and/or insertions in the Os8N3 promoter region (Chu et al., 2006). Further expression analysis of Os8N3 and the various xa13 alleles will provide important insights into the intricacy of host genes that have adapted for disease resistance while maintaining normal developmental processes. Despite the number of alleles, xa13 is not as broad as the resistance provided by Xa21, Xa27, and xa5, and many strains from China, the Philippines, Japan, and Korea are compatible on xa13 lines (Yang et al., 2006). The number of strains that are compatible on plants containing xa13 illustrates that Xoo can and has adapted to xa13 alleles as well as other R genes in the host. Studies of the basis of compatibility and incompatibility between rice genotypes and strains of the pathogen have been conducted in the hope that insight may be gained into the factors that affect R gene breadth and durability, which here is defined loosely as the time the R gene is effective against extant populations of pathogens. Type III effectors of Xoo and Xoc with phenotypic effects in rice Virulence activity indicates contribution to virulence based on lesion length and bacterial population on the host plant. Avirulence activity indicates ability to elicit a resistance reaction on appropriate genotype of the host. Major TAL effectors are defined by their loss due to mutation. Loss of major TAL effector gene, if the only one present in a strain, results in more than 80% virulence as measured by lesion length when compared with the wild type. Type III effectors of Xoo and Xoc with phenotypic effects in rice Virulence activity indicates contribution to virulence based on lesion length and bacterial population on the host plant. Avirulence activity indicates ability to elicit a resistance reaction on appropriate genotype of the host. Major TAL effectors are defined by their loss due to mutation. Loss of major TAL effector gene, if the only one present in a strain, results in more than 80% virulence as measured by lesion length when compared with the wild type. Prototypic TAL effector. Each TAL effector contains a central repetitive region of varying numbers of 34 amino acid repeat units (white boxes). The C-terminal region contains three nuclear localization signal motifs (NLS [A, B, and C]) and an acidic activation domain (AD). The AvrRxo1, on the other hand, is a novel protein of 421 amino acids with a variety of reported motifs, including a eukaryotic thiol protease active site, an ATP/GTP-binding site motif, nine N-myristoylation site motifs, and a putative nuclear localization sequence motif (Zhao et al., 2004). The functionality of the motifs has not yet been experimentally verified. Genes related to avrRxo1 are fairly limited in distribution and present in Acidovorax, Burkholdaria, and X. campestris pv vesicatoria (Zhao et al., 2004; Thieme et al., 2005). However, related genes have not been detected in Xoo. Mutants of avrRxo1 have not been generated; therefore, any virulence contribution to Xoc by avrRxo1 is unknown. Xa27 and xa13 have provided insight into the diversity of resistance mechanisms in rice. The apparent reason for the broad activity of Xa27 is the presence of avrXa27 in a large number of strains from southeast Asia, including many strains from Korea, China, Japan, and the Philippines (Gu et al., 2004). At the same time, two lines of evidence indicate that strains of Xoo could defeat Xa27. First, avrXa27 is present in a single copy, at least in the two strains that have been examined; therefore, simple loss or mutation of the gene converts incompatible strains to compatible strains on plants with Xa27 (Gu et al., 2005; Ochiai et al., 2005). Second, mutation of avrXa27 in the strain PXO99A converts PXO99A to compatibility on plants containing Xa27 and does not lead to any detectible loss of virulence. Thus, the loss of avrXa27 does not appear to have a fitness cost to the pathogen, and populations of Xoo without avrXa27 could be expected to appear relatively rapidly should Xa27 be deployed. avrXa7, unlike avrXa27, is an important virulence factor for some strains of Xoo, and loss of avrXa7 can result in strains that are only weakly virulent (Bai et al., 2000; Yang et al., 2000). Several factors mitigate the argument that Xa7, by itself, would provide durable resistance due to the fitness cost for loss of avrXa7 in the pathogen. One factor is that a variety of other TAL T3 effector genes are present in Xoo populations that do not have Xa7-mediated elicitor activity but can restore full virulence to strains missing avrXa7 (Yang and White, 2004). We refer to interchangeable TAL effectors with regard to virulence activity as major TAL effectors. In addition to avrXa7, the major TAL effector genes in Xoo are pthXo1, pthXo2, and pthXo3 (Yang and White, 2004). Loss of Xa7-dependent elicitor activity from avrXa7 and concomitant retention of virulence activity has also been observed (Yang et al., 2005). Thus, evasion of Xa7-mediated resistance should, at least theoretically, be possible by deletion of the central repeats, as observed for pthXo4, by recombination among different TAL effector genes, as observed with pthXo5, or by horizontal transfer of alternate virulence factors (Yang et al., 2005). At the same time, field studies in the Philippines indicated that deployment of Xa7 was durable in test plots for more than 10 years (Vera Cruz et al., 2000). Regardless of the possibility of race changes in the pathogen population, pyramiding R genes with cognate T3 effectors that are widespread in the pathogen populations should provide a degree of broad durable resistance. Diverse host responses to Xoo challenge in rice. Leaves were inoculated with water or Xoo by needleless syringe. Leaf 1, Mock inoculation; leaf 2, response to T3SS nonpathogenic mutant of PXO99A; leaf 3, recessive R gene response (note the lack of streaking up and down the leaf blade); leaf 4, fully susceptible response (wild-type strain); leaf 5, PXO99A (avrXa7; response to dominant R gene Xa7). Photographs were taken with back lighting, and yellow zones are indicative of water soaking. PthXo1, AvrXa7, PthXo2, and PthXo3 are major virulence T3 effectors in the bacterial blight system, and the targeted host genes are major S genes. Strains lacking at least one of the major T3 effectors are severely debilitated for virulence, as measured by the standard leaf-clipping assays, display similar phenotypes, and, as noted above, compare favorably to results with dominant resistance genes. At present, the reason for resistance or lack of virulence is unclear and undoubtedly related to the benefit to the pathogen that is provided by the expression of the N3 gene in rice. T3 effectors, in general, are hypothesized to interfere with host defense and defense signaling mechanisms. Of course, in the broadest definition, any factor that promotes virulence can be interpreted as an interference with host defense. The question remains whether the major TAL T3 effectors of Xoo are “wrecking balls” and interfere with many normal host functions by expropriating normal developmental pathways or “guided missiles” designed to interfere with a specific host function related to immunity or, alternatively, beneficial functions unrelated specifically to immunity. One model for TAL effectors has proposed that the effectors enhance the spread of the bacteria from local infection sites (Yang et al., 1994; Iyer-Pascuzzi et al., 2008). Os8N3 protein, which is membrane localized, may, for example, result in loss of tissue integrity, allowing release of the bacteria into uninfected tissue (Chu et al., 2006). Alternatively, Os8N3 may promote greater bacterial growth due to leakage of nutrients into extracellular spaces, and consequently, the bacteria may grow to higher titers within the host. Future experimentation regarding bacterial physiology within the host as well as studies involving ectopic expression of S genes will provide insight into these models or provide new hypotheses to test. Xoo strains lacking the major TAL effectors are not nonpathogenic and are still capable of causing water-soaked symptoms if syringe inoculated. The ability to cause water soaking is in contrast to T3SS mutants, which are incapable of secretion of any T3SS effectors. T3SS-deficient mutants are virtually symptomless (Fig. 4). Utilization of the N3 family, based on existing evidence, is unique to the bacterial blight system. Xoc also contains multiple TAL effector genes, but infection does not lead to Os8N3 expression, indicating that, if the effectors play similar roles in heterologous systems, the targets of the effectors are likely to be different (A. Bogdanove, B. Yang, and F.F. White, unpublished data). Genomic positions of TAL effector genes in two strains of Xoo. Genes are labeled and identified by biological function and name, where assigned (adapted from Salzberg et al. [2008] and Ochiai et al. [2005]). The dashed line indicates the location of the PXO99A TAL effector gene 9e in MAFF3113018. Apostrophes after gene letters indicate truncated genes. Colored boxes indicate gene clusters. [See online article for color version of this figure.] While many may serve as recombination substrates, the TAL effector genes of PXO99A are not simply substrates for new major TAL effectors. Three TAL effector genes, in addition to pthXo1, are known to have contributions to virulence (Table II), and two are known to be associated with the elevated expression of two host genes distinct from Os8N3. The gene pthXo6 is responsible for the elevated expression of a gene named OsTFX1 (AK108319) and located on chromosome 9 of rice. A mutant of PXO99A in pthXo6 suffered a loss of approximately 35% in the lengths of leaf lesions and a 50% reduction in bacterial population per leaf (Sugio et al., 2007). Ectopic expression of OsTFX1 in rice abrogated the need for pthXo6 in the pathogen but did not make the plants more susceptible to PXO99A (Sugio et al., 2007). OsTFX1 is a member of the large bZip family of transcription factors, and the function of OsTFX1 in a normal plant is unknown. Ectopic expression of the gene, other than compensating for the presence of pthXo6 in the pathogen, did not cause any phenotypic abnormalities in the transgenic plants (Sugio et al., 2007). Elevated expression of OsTFX1 may provide a good diagnostic tool for Xoo, as all strains examined were capable of inducing the gene. Xoc, at least on the basis of a single strain, was unable to induce OsTFX1. pthXo7 is associated with the elevation of OsTFIIAγ1 and has only been found in Xoo strain PXO99A (Sugio et al., 2007). Loss of pthXo7 in PXO99A has no measurable effect on strain virulence in susceptible rice plants. In addition to compatibility on plants with the recessive xa13, PXO99A is also one of the few strains known to be compatible with the other recessive resistance gene One model for the resistance provided by xa5 is that the alternate TFIIAγ xa5 may not function with the TAL effectors and interfere with TAL effector In PXO99A may have in to xa5 by the of A small effect on virulence was found upon transfer to a strain that is incompatible on plants with xa5, that pthXo7 may be an to host genotypes containing the xa5 allele of TFIIAγ5 (Sugio et al., 2007). However, pthXo7 does not on the same of growth on xa5 plants in comparison with PXO99A; therefore, does not appear to be the or the reason for the ability of PXO99A to cause disease in the presence of xa5 (Sugio et al., 2007). should also be noted that the growth of PXO99A is reduced in plants with the xa5 gene for resistance, which to the of the xa5 for resistance. One also at this the possibility of virulence factors and R genes in rice that are adapted specifically to the TFIIAγ xa5 In the xa5 may be not only as an R gene, also has of a and a resistance gene. into the molecular basis of Xoo and Xoc with the host to provide new insights in the into the between pathogen and host. The full of host effects due to the T3 TAL effectors to be as more genes, strains, and host genotypes are the characterization of strains from has new genotypes of both Xoo and Xoc and indicates that an ability to cause bacterial blight of rice may have in at least three of related bacteria et al., 2007). The has also a variety of novel R genes, and a of their function in host susceptibility and resistance will be in other bacterial systems, the of a host to the of the virulence factors against the pathogen are to in the rice system, the pathogen by expropriating the developmental control of host genes and induction of a membrane protein, in the of Os8N3. The on the other hand, can the by of a membrane protein that a defense The effects of the proteins and the components of the two on host cell physiology await on the basis of sequence is unique to rice and, some (Gu et al., and is one of a number of genes that may have been through the for specific et al., 2009). of Xoo and Xoc virulence is from example, a TAL effector gene, named has been identified in PXO99A with effects similar to and the host gene expression associated with is under evidence indicates that the effector is involved in of the small RNA pathways of the host. The and novel of the TAL T3 effectors from the presence of multiple other T3 effectors in Xoo and Xoc characterization of the from indicates that at least T3 effector genes, in addition to the 17 TAL effector genes, are present in the et al., III type III effectors of Xoo from et al. in the same are related by sequence similar sequence not identified effectors are in identified effector and conserved in other unique to Xoo. type III effectors of Xoo from et al. in the same are related by sequence similar sequence not identified effectors are in identified effector and conserved in other unique to Xoo. We Dr. for unpublished
Source: PLANT PHYSIOLOGY
Authors: Frank F. White, Bing Yang
Institutions: Iowa State University, Kansas State University
Language: English
Subfield: Plant Science
Domain: Life Sciences
SDG: Zero hunger
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2113093511
