Year: 2001
Type: article
Abstract: The advent of the new millennium prompted various discussions of the future of academic disciplines, including epidemiology and other public health sciences.1–5 We missed this opportunity to make prognostications, but have chosen this first issue of 2001 for our initial editorial comment since, having succeeded Professor Peter Pharoah as editors of the International Journal of Epidemiology, this is the first issue which exclusively contains material which we have processed from the Bristol, UK, office. Of course Peter's remarkable record as editor of the IJE is difficult to follow, a fact reflected in the need for two of us to attempt to complete the tasks so admirably carried out by Peter alone. Although millennia are clear socio-cultural constructs, their expiry provides an excuse for making sweeping statements about the past and future which natural reticence would (and probably should) constrain at other times. However because such phenomena can be considered as socio-cultural constructs does not mean that they do not have real effects: the symbolic power of centennial or millennial transitions allow for changes in the way the world is viewed which have concrete effects. In the case of the latest millennial transition the coincidence of the calendar shift with the announcement of the sequencing of the human genome6,7 provides what we believe will be seen as a more than symbolic change in the way (wo)man views wo(man). There is much discussion in the lay and academic press which is clearly based on the notion that since 26 June 2000—the date sequencing of the human genome was announced—the world really has changed: new cures for cancer are coming soon; the selection of drugs and medical treatments will be tailored to the genome of the client; the development of chronic disease can be postponed by gene therapy; and the cause of all diseases will ultimately be revealed as genetic. Viewed through DNA-tinted spectacles, is epidemiology a discipline with a glorious past, but decreasing relevance as description (epidemiological) is replaced by explanation (gene expression)? In 2001 would we be justified in advising a potential researcher committed to making a contribution to population health to enter epidemiology training rather than head straight for the nearest polymerase chain reaction console? As the official journal of the International Epidemiological Association the IJE cannot afford to skip this question—to which others would be keen to answer yes. The progenitor of one of the more remarkable (and influential) branches of late 20th century epidemiological research—the fetal origins of adult disease,8 which features as a theme subject in this issue of the IJE—thinks that improved understanding of the cause of coronary heart disease will come from animal experimentation, not epidemiology.9 What does that say to the rest of us who have made more modest contributions to our field? Taking stock of the past triumphs and tragedies of epidemiology may go some way to help provide an answer to our enthusiastic potential colleague considering a future in epidemiology. The successes of epidemiology can be considered with respect to particular health problems, or to its broader influence on the methodology of understanding and dealing with health problems. Here we consider five cases which we have selected because of their iconic status, because of the lessons they have for the future development of epidemiology, or both. It is traditional to start considerations of the successes of epidemiology either with cholera or smoking, although the framework for thinking about the determinants of population-level phenomena such as death rates, fertility and population change was clearly in place by the early 19th century.10 The term epidemiologist was apparently not used until the 1860s11 and the profession only emerged in the early part of the 20th Century;12 however, the foundation of the London Epidemiological Society in 1850 indicated that a notion of what epidemiology was existed by the mid-19th century.11 Initially proposed as a society to direct anti-cholera activities—to be named the Epidemic Medical Society—in the event it was instigated as a society concerned with the cause and prevention of many diseases, and also with issues which today would be considered to be health services research.11 Certainly the work of Thomas Proudfoot13 and Henry Gaulter14 during the 1832 British cholera epidemic and of John Sutherland,15 John Snow16 and William Budd17 during the mid-century epidemic was of a type that we would now recognize as epidemiological, even though their contemporaries and more recent commentators pointed out the limitations of their methods.18,19 Snow's work had considerable influence, which in the long term reaped public health benefits (although the actual influence of the famous removal of the Broad Street pump handle may have been less than has been generally supposed, see Figure 1).20 Interestingly, bodies of empirical and theoretical work which reached conclusions we would now consider to be epidemiologically ‘wrong’ also had positive public health effects; those that thought cholera was caused by air-born miasma were as likely to demand appropriate sanitary reform as those who saw it as a contagious disease.21 John Snow recognized this, accepting that anti-contagionist theories of cholera causation were ‘in a hygienic sense … as useful as what I believe to be the real truth’.22 While ‘correct’ epidemiology does not guarantee the implementation of effective public health policy (and vice versa) it lays the ground for continuing advances in understanding which do yield benefits. Thus miasma (as opposed to simple contagionist) theories of cholera prompted interventions which lessened the severity of future cholera outbreaks, but continued reliance on an unmodified miasma paradigm would have constrained the development of later thinking regarding the control of infectious disease (for example, the development of vaccinations or specific chemotherapeutic interventions). Being right for the wrong reasons can be fine as far as short-term public health outcomes is concerned, but can be a severe impediment in the long term. That John Snow and others were right for the right reason was an important advance for both epidemiology and public health. The widespread adoption of cigarette smoking did not reflect a huge increase in tobacco consumption, rather it occurred through a shift in the mode of production and marketing of tobacco. Each Bonsack cigarette rolling machine—introduced in the early 1880s—could produce more than 100 000 cigarettes a day, greatly increasing the ability of cigarette companies to make profits through selling huge numbers of cheap cigarettes (the per cigarette rate of profit fell, and this technology could only be introduced if consumption was drastically increased). Snuff, tobacco chewing and pipe smoking decreased during this shift in the way tobacco was used, rather than there being a big increase in total tobacco-use. Widespread uptake of cigarette smoking was followed years later by increases, from initially low levels, in lung cancer mortality. By 1935 Fritz Lickint discussed time-trend, ecological and clinical data which strongly implicated cigarette smoking as a cause of lung cancer,23 and two ground breaking case-control were in in and The of is for the first in this issue of the The case-control from the and in of the The of had to the origins of adult chronic diseases long had been as a cause of cancer in and pipe smoking was a cause of cancer by the 19th the of the low and of a of population was of for the of chronic disease were and both in epidemiology and public The but of the smoking and lung later smoking and other in particular coronary heart disease and disease from which had been in the control of some of the in smoking rates, followed by lung cancer in some However the the of cigarette smoking also the production and of that smoking and companies are now marketing cigarettes in the and less of future of diseases in The of as of the and health of a society has a long in that and place more other being in as the is more and and and during and in other the which the at which complete is reached and adult was considered both an of an population and as of a of in the event of was seen as a of population as one at the of the 19th century the of from the of the increase of the from the of the of the it is it is that the public to the during the of and the during the of its The potential health of and early development long been In in to as an of of and the of the new as of the the influence of development on later health was considered in epidemiological in the first of the 20th in the of a in that the of this the views by many that disease in is about by the a long of of many many some of which place and are even in was at a much of was concerned with the influence of the on the health and of as one of its John of with in respect of the clinical of the and of and have much to The of the in health much today as a that be their first in of there was a way of thinking about human which saw the of a population as the of from the world the adult and other continued to produce in the for those that or in were with of coronary heart the work of and from the that development is to chronic a new development in chronic disease epidemiology. is a in the of from their While there was some on fetal development and later health in animal the epidemiological work this now of The issue of the IJE contains a of and to the fetal origins of adult with the in the specific of fetal and later there has been of and The of in epidemiology, and in this the of which could be seen in other in particular that of understanding and influence the health of and The of and the of have been triumphs of public the of the successes have been the widespread of sanitary and In the of health in the however, the has on those of the that are on the The of and its various disease and It is in this of health policy by and of in the of that the determinants of the of with the of the of the world to the on and it cannot to what we are as a because we in a we to our for the of our data by the of the which our us to The of the century was population more with than policy were that population control was the to in and and of in to in in have been in their with the real of of health and development to has been the of the of the in are in being are now in some this of the years and more now in the world and this will to by By and will have of than the does those and that to development are it to the of their are to on the new and by in In to particular successes of epidemiology, the of be The widespread of the the of medical and to the of effective medical and the of the or have also the of seen in epidemiological for the of the of and with coronary heart However the development of methodology was not followed by its and a of were to have the power to of real public health The and of the of of the and numbers of to has been of considerable in this The from and the that some considered to be effective because of clinical or were either or the development of clinical and its as the successes of clinical epidemiology the of a population to disease control has its As are in population of or to the … could benefits on and the on services out of all in IJE and on to out that the determinants of the of disease could be to the determinants of the in disease In a population of cigarettes per the which influence who lung cancer would probably to to or However the in lung cancer a population in which of and one of would be to The of disease at the population rather than is by a of the outcomes of to coronary heart disease through health and the in coronary heart disease in many that change can have a discipline advances and and epidemiology is not an to this Here we two one in which epidemiology to make the positive contribution which at one it was thought it could and a the of epidemiology have been and to population health. We provide lessons on epidemiology may a more useful The of in the first of the 20th century in and other with the initial in coronary heart disease and lung public health The first of of in was much concerned with this on important epidemiological by various By the to and by the of a was and work was carried out by and which clear in the (and of disease in with years in of the with the disease of data from in all with some in the and but a being seen with respect to the and The of phenomena in disease or important as to disease early in Thus in in one of the first and that in and in a way for those Thus for to in for in for in and so The clear is that some occurred in early which to being less to disease and death at all and considered that in a and the of of the to a they considered the they saw reflected the of being but they this out because an of of the the only which to the not to until a later and that a in would not be seen until who more early their early that in a which as that death at was during the work of and others the initial of the in was strongly by the that chronic disease was of and was on the mode of in As we have seen this was a for the cause of the in lung cancer which also of the uptake of cigarette smoking by of Thus the by and were as the particular of the British disease the first world as the of the and the world in The of phenomena in many other on this The notion that important determinants of disease early in was In that the of contributions from cigarette smoking, and did not the that a In was generally in is strongly implicated in and the of is in a in with of the and and the adoption of this health The of a advance in understanding and an important advance was made by a and a with from the of epidemiological on this important public health Epidemiological had on the and and prevention for a disease which an epidemic in during the the epidemiological transition from infectious to (and in other cases of thinking about the of chronic disease of thought from infectious the of the of in with of in not until later in The that we are being from the of disease because of the power of of disease causation be considered if we are not to of epidemiological of epidemiology which has much is the apparently of particular of as to As Figure this is not to or public health and it is this of epidemiology which the medical in The and of to that the to the of was to all of epidemiology. The of from epidemiological this is the case and a of an which is not in for example, the on consumption and the of revealed apparently of but if disease There are now a of and in to or in to cancer What have in is that the of who were apparently from in the were from the not on a of of their that could be in of a and for in to recognize the of the reasons with to particular and of their in (and adult in early as or the to to increasing the of lung of a which particular and of and of dealing with may to but they are all of which influence health. epidemiology which the of will the to which based on the of from their can It would be if the of by in to a of which are or the of the and of and to health It is however, that as in many will be to on a rather than there being a of of the broader paradigm which the discipline the is the case the of a simple which a of its epidemiology will be a or a in the century will on it with a of it As our reflect our and are far from epidemiology to the of the sequencing way would be to that change had can be a in the and of the anti-contagionist of in of until death in and by at one of the of the in the long the is and in the late 20th century is the of in the late 19th The to in population health or even but in the long our of the of health and disease in The may be the case with the sequencing of the human the of advance in control of disease are to be However a understanding of of disease development and advances in may be The of will influence epidemiology, it is that only a with more (and journal than if were with other some as is a less in to disease than in of or The population of such however, probably be The of and is much in to including in epidemiological on the of genome and be to not the need to and the big the of gene and to be considered the of changes in disease that the in health and and the health to and for example, to the of and that of the in is in However consider in in the for example, have from in to in a remarkable increase in less than changes are not to of the but in as as and in have been and changes clearly the influence of since there will have been change in the of the population a and changes in disease been seen for The a of for by and the clear of population disease the potential of on one of the There are reasons for such the used to may be they can make about of the of and the influence of and there has been some in the of of made by some with early of being to less than a the contribution of to disease is an the determinants of disease for a population and who a disease a population is in the population to for example, by the of in in the and of the can strongly but this can make a contribution to the population of which is what and public health be concerned While the new by to and to understanding of disease and the big health and disease are as much as not be from issue of increasing is the to which epidemiology to understanding the world is (and to the features or is a of for out of particular diseases in particular have been of the of epidemiology in the of the 20th century with rather than with health. a for and the of that would do to a and that at to all that is and in epidemiology an of and a by The of epidemiological and to more of thinking about what we are we out to diseases in particular by recent is to improved in our which not be with the of an the to which the health of has from the epidemiological will be by an which the to the important health the of what can be to to what is is a real which are appropriate for if treatments produce the of to and in health a population a with The of new is if they to advances in understanding the determinants of disease and and to their is an empirical one which is of the positive and of the of to in epidemiology, would an important to the to the in which they if they are to of or even if they are to The future for as for all is The is the in which is and The IJE has as a for of There have been and we of because of It is if we are epidemiology by the of which we as other material is of relevance to our the of which we a are of but cannot be the journal We however, that of the can help this and the public we to with is a of that and on the provides an to the of by which the public for the of to the and to the for many and in that cannot afford journal we in will their effective from the in will also the and in work and the and their of part in an and of and to with and and all by has such What our policy be regarding the type of material we In other for it may be to a and editorial In we the editorial policy of one we need a more to increasing the relevance of the The editors of that that this is and with the We the of and that with head in the of in and and not that to say or of or will at We for that because has and not the other way only such as would in of a cigarette by do not that can make us and We that with the of but not that and the that their a of is but not work and with in it is an for is to the of the in the at a about in the but this is far from the of that is with and We are not at are we We are and The for is a of and we as in the of is only the of and even be if a of have to us the is a of in a of with a as of that are not are a do not but do We and us with to is the out this, this, we are not our we are not have way past and we not us for at We are concerned to epidemiological to what has many disciplines, epidemiology has not from as much as it could have There is a sense that new is of more than but the to the latest issue of a journal could the fact that much could be from a more of As the Peter in to a the We to this by contributions to with on which lessons can be In the issue we a of a case-control of smoking and lung first in in with We would from regarding material which we consider We are in less contributions than the rather which are and we material not in which we will have for in the from the with of the and editor There is an in our in the only reflect on epidemiological the of which is later revealed to the We that at as much can be from cases epidemiology has the answer wrong to thinking on an or only in on cases and have reached what are now seen to be conclusions we can much about our may be We discussed the case of but many other cases was as being caused by the of a particular a of were apparently by the epidemiological including an infectious of the disease by a a in and would clearly be to but would not be on the the of which was to for the of by was the which the of We to which may have revealed to be but which at as much as the As is clear from and from this many other changes to the IJE are being We would to increase the of of the both through the of for and through for for issues or more of the We the IJE can in some way to that our epidemiologist has considered the past and potential future of epidemiology they see far from an of epidemiology there is new and work to be so long as the on population health is have from to from a of and disciplines, with the of increasing and relevance of what are and to place in with and from epidemiology. The is development which will of and if have not if work is of and we will it the of for if in and because lessons they can are for are to provide on or difficult for this are to public and traditional from of epidemiology, are issue will have a theme with and to the and in this we to advances which produce benefits to understanding of determinants of In the case of more empirical rather than theoretical are We also theoretical in epidemiology. What we less from but What we more in epidemiology of and of public health services in Broad London The pump handle was the epidemic was and to have had although the Henry who thought that the of the pump may have of the of the of epidemiology of of of and and of of the of in from to We for our to Henry and Figure also to John Peter and for
DOI: 10.1093/ije/30.1.1
Authors: George Davey Smith, Shah Ebrahim
Institution: University of Bristol
Language: French
Subfield: Epidemiology
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: future of epidemiology, human genome sequencing, genetic determinism, fetal origins of adult disease, coronary artery disease, animal experimentation, population health, public health science, International Epidemiological Association, chronic disease prevention, health education, health services research, health economics, health research funding
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $4,514
OpenAlex ID: W2113981951
