Work

Comparative methods for studying primate adaptation and allometry

Year: 2001
Type: article
Abstract: A well-known comparative biologist was once asked by a field biologist whether the latter’s detailed and painstaking field study of orangutan behavior, carried out over many years, qualified as an example of the comparative method. “No, ” replied the comparative biologist, “that’s an anecdote. ” The reply is somewhat harsh, as useful comparisons can be conducted both within and across species. The reply does emphasize, however, that analysis of patterns across species is fundamental to the study of adaptive evolution, particularly when variation needed to test hypotheses is present only at this interspecific level. 1–5 Examples in primatology include the occurrence of female sexual swellings in species with habitually multimale, rather than single-male, breeding systems, 6,7 the relationship between polygynandrous mating and relatively large testes size, 3,8 and the association between brain size and social group size. 9 Thus, in many cases, interspecific variation is required to test adaptive hypotheses. 10 In this article, we review developments in comparative methodology that have emerged in the last fifteen years, with particular emphasis on the importance of incorporating phylogeny into comparative studies. We define “comparative study ” as meaning analysis of trait variation across rather than within species, with the aim of testing hypotheses or generating new ones. 11 We provide information on how to implement phylogenetic comparative methods, including available computer programs (Box 1).
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2114809609
FWCI: 13.01
Cites: 111
Cited by: 223
Related to: 8