Work

Scuba Revolutionizes Marine Science

Year: 2013
Type: book-chapter
Abstract: Scuba provides scientists with the capacity for direct observation and experimental manipulation in underwater research. Technology allows broader- scale observations and measure- ments such as satellite detection of coral bleaching up to a global scale and LIDAR determination of reef- wide topographic complexity on landscape to regional scales. Scuba- based observations provide a means of ground truthing these broad- scale technologies. For example, ground truthing the read- ings on a scale as small as a video transect taken at 50 cm above the substratum can reveal that the previously confident interpretation of the transect data from the video analysis was inaccurate. At the opposite end of the spatial continuum, electron microscopy and DNA analysis provide the ca- pacity to determine species traits at a scale too fine for direct observation, while observations made during the collection of samples by scuba can provide vital information on the context of the tissue sample collection. Using our hands and eyes to set up experiments under water is less expensive and more adaptable to the unexpected topographic complexities of hard substratum habitats than doing so with submersibles, robots, or via cables from ships. The most profound contribution of scuba to underwater science, however, is the otherwise unobtainable insights provided by direct observation. Ecology is not always predictable from species traits because the behavioral or interactive charac- teristics of marine organisms together cause them to function in surprising and often synergistic ways. Although our research is often framed around hypotheses developed by deductive reasoning, the solutions to research questions cannot always be found by deduction. Data taken by video or sensors from satellites, tow- boards, or other vehicles are all incomplete in their context evaluation in comparison to direct observation by the human brain. Scuba provides a unique ability to inte- grate detail with context across small and large scales. The history of marine research has provided numerous examples of mysteries that would have been unsolved and findings that would have been misinterpreted with confidence if not for direct observation on scuba. We illustrate this aspect of the utility of scuba for science with three examples of how direct observation of species in their natural habitats has furthered the development of ecological concepts.
Language: English
Subfield: Ecology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2114876418
FWCI: 1.225
Cites: 63
Cited by: 8
Related to: 10