Year: 2008
Type: review
Abstract: Predictions of population growth outpacing agricultural production have been made for the past 200 years (Malthus, 1817; Ehrlich, 1968), and though world food supply has more than kept pace with demand, there are over 850 million malnourished people in the world, the vast majority in developing countries (FAO, 2006). In the next approximately 40 years, global demand for cereal production will increase by 60% (Rosegrant and Cline, 2003) as the global population rises from 6.6 billion today to 8.7 to 11.3 billion in 2050 (Bengtsson et al., 2006). Feeding the growing world population will be a significant challenge to agriculture. Simultaneously, global climate change will provide an additional challenge by significantly modifying the crop production environment. What are the additional challenges and opportunities that climate change will present for biotechnological improvement of crop yield and food supply? Global climate change will alter many elements of the future crop production environment. Atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration ([CO2]), average temperature, and tropospheric ozone concentration ([O3]) will be higher, droughts will be more frequent and severe, more intense precipitation events will lead to increased flooding, some soils will degrade, and climatic extremes will be more likely to occur (IPCC, 2007). Drought, extreme temperatures, flooding, and soil quality have challenged agriculture since its inception. Therefore, there is a long history of investment in basic science and crop breeding to produce germplasm that sustains high yield under stressful conditions, and the opportunity for biotechnology to contribute to improved crop stress tolerance has been widely recognized. Advances in the understanding of crop-environment interactions at the molecular, biochemical, physiological, and agronomic scales, as well as their relevance to biotechnological crop improvement, have been extensively reviewed. These include discussions of the response mechanisms and potential targets for improving crop response to drought (Wang et al., 2003; Chaves and Oliveira, 2004; Parry et al., 2005; Barnabás et al., 2008), flooding (Agarwal and Grover, 2006), low temperature (Wang et al., 2003; Nakashima and Yamaguchi-Shinozaki, 2006), high temperature (Iba, 2002; Wahid et al., 2007; Barnabás et al., 2008), and low nutrient availability (Hirel et al., 2007). It follows that a number of companies, including Monsanto, Syngenta, and Pioneer-DuPont, have drought-tolerant, heat-tolerant, cold-tolerant, or nitrogen (N)-use efficient germplasm in their research and development pipelines (http://www.monsanto.com/pdf/investors/2008/01-08-08.pdf; http://www.syngenta.com/en/about_syngenta/crop_protection_pipeline.aspx; http://www.pioneer.com/CMRoot/Pioneer/research/pipeline/DuPont_BG_Pipeline.pdf). However, two other major elements of global climate change, rising atmospheric [CO2] and [O3], have been widely recognized as important to crop production only in the last 30 to 40 years. Even with this recognition, there has so far been little effort to improve crop responses to these factors through breeding or biotechnology. Here we briefly outline the nature of global climate change and then discuss potential biotechnological targets for improving crop production in a future high-[CO2] and high-[O3] world. We conclude by reviewing some practical challenges to developing and testing biotechnology crops that are targeted to a changing production environment. In the last 250 years, atmospheric [CO2] has risen from 280 μmol mol−1 to 381 μmol mol−1. This exceeds the [CO2] at any time in the last 650,000 years and probably the last 23 million years (IPCC, 2007). Atmospheric [CO2] is projected to continue rising to at least 550 μmol mol−1 by 2050 (IPCC, 2007). Rising concentrations of CO2 and other greenhouse gases have resulted in a 0.76°C increase in global surface temperature since the 1800s, and the mean global surface temperature is predicted to increase by an additional 1.3°C to 1.8°C by 2050 (IPCC, 2007). Warming over land is expected to be greater than this average, and it is very likely that heat waves will be more intense, more frequent, and longer lasting. Daily minimum temperatures are predicted to rise more rapidly than daily maximum temperatures. The number of frost days will decrease, and in mid- to high latitudes, an extension of the growing season is likely (IPCC, 2007). Warming will generally increase evaporation, total precipitation, and the spatial variability of precipitation, leading to less rainfall in the tropics and more rainfall at higher latitudes. However, the spatial and temporal boundaries between areas of projected increasing and decreasing precipitation are uncertain. Globally, the intensity of precipitation events is projected to increase, even in areas with a mean reduction in precipitation, and the time between precipitation events is also projected to increase, thereby increasing both the risk of flooding and drought (IPCC, 2007). Unlike [CO2], tropospheric [O3] is spatially and temporally heterogeneous because O3 is short lived and its synthesis is tied to the abundance of its pollutant precursors, and water vapor and sunlight. In industrialized countries of the northern hemisphere, daily 8-h tropospheric [O3] is estimated to have increased from approximately 10 nmol mol−1 prior to the industrial revolution to a current level of approximately 60 nmol mol−1 during summer months, and is predicted to increase 20% more by 2050 (IPCC, 2007). This is particularly relevant to agriculture because sensitive crops show a reduction in yield once the [O3] exceeds 40 nmol mol−1 for extended periods (Heagle, 1989). The changes in temperature, precipitation, and tropospheric [O3] projected for 2050 are spatially and temporally variable, poorly constrained, and occurring in parallel. This moving and poorly defined target presents a significant challenge to a biotechnology industry hoping to provide cultivars tailored to regional production environments. In contrast, the increase in [CO2] is uniform, global, and unfortunately, committed. Even in the unlikely event that we stabilize CO2 emissions at present-day levels, atmospheric [CO2] would still be >500 μmol mol−1 by 2050 (IPCC, 2007). Therefore, attempts to engineer crops to perform better under the conditions of increasing environmental stress associated with increased O3 exposure, temperature, and changing precipitation patterns should be considered against the back drop of a guaranteed and ubiquitous increase in atmospheric [CO2]. Elevated [CO2] directly reduces stomatal conductance in C3 and C4 species, and also directly stimulates photosynthesis in C3 species (Drake et al., 1997; Long et al., 2004; Ainsworth and Rogers, 2007). All other effects of elevated [CO2] on crops, including the stimulation in yield, are derived from these primary responses (Ainsworth and Rogers, 2007). How can we engineer crops to maximize the advantages of rising [CO2]? As Rubisco is the key carboxylating enzyme and frequently the rate-limiting factor for photosynthesis (Rogers and Humphries, 2000), it is worth asking: Can crop responsiveness to elevated [CO2] be improved by altering the properties of Rubisco, and are current efforts to improve Rubisco relevant to the production environment of 2050? In C3 crops, increasing the affinity of Rubisco for CO2, and thereby avoiding photorespiratory carbon (C) losses, is a target for increasing yield potential (Reynolds and Borlaug, 2006; Ainsworth and Rogers, 2007), but the conserved inverse relationship between specificity and catalytic rate has hindered progress (Bainbridge et al., 1995). The kinetic properties of current C3 Rubisco suggest that the affinity/specificity is optimal for a [CO2] of 200 μmol mol−1, consistent with a Rubisco that evolved under such conditions. By 2050, the optimal Rubisco would actually need to have a lower, not higher affinity for CO2, and a higher catalytic rate (Zhu et al., 2004). Substituting current Rubisco for Rubisco from other species, particularly nongreen algae, which has a markedly lower specificity and higher catalytic rate, could dramatically increase C gain at current and elevated [CO2]. Further gains could be maximized by engineering plants to express different types of Rubisco in sunlit and shade leaves (Zhu et al., 2004). This is not without precedent because Hydrogenovibrio marinus, an anaerobic microorganism, switches among its three forms of Rubisco depending on environmental cues (Yoshizawa et al., 2004). Thus, improving the catalytic properties of Rubisco will remain a viable target for the biotechnology industry. Although the focus of the research may need to shift away from improving specificity for CO2 in crops grown in temperate environments, those grown in high-temperature conditions in tropical environments would still benefit from improved specificity because as temperature rises, the ratio of carboxylation to oxygenation is reduced (Long, 1991). As [CO2] rises, photosynthesis in C3 crops shifts from being limited by Rubisco to being limited by the capacity for regeneration of the CO2 acceptor, ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate (RuBP; Ainsworth and Rogers, 2007). An alternative to reducing excess Rubisco content at elevated [CO2] is to increase the capacity for regeneration of RuBP and thereby match the increased carboxylation rates. Recent modeling analysis suggests that manipulating the partitioning of N resources among enzymes of C metabolism could greatly increase photosynthesis without any increase in the total N requirement (Zhu et al., 2007). Greater capacity for the regenerative phase of the Calvin cycle was identified as a key target to improve C acquisition. There is already some evidence that crops increase RuBP regeneration capacity at elevated [CO2]. The level of Fru-1,6-bisphosphatase was increased in a forage crop (Lolium perenne) grown at elevated [CO2] with a high N supply (Rogers et al., 1998) and in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum), Rubisco activity decreased and other Calvin cycle enzymes increased at elevated [CO2] (Geiger et al., 1999). In addition, antisense technology coupled with flux analysis has shown that sedoheptulose-1,7-bisphosphatase exerts considerable control over photosynthesis, and plants overexpressing sedoheptulose-1,7-bisphosphatase had a marked increase in photosynthesis and growth (Raines, 2003; Lefebvre et al., 2005). Accumulation of foliar carbohydrates is one of the most pronounced and universally observed responses of C3 plants to elevated [CO2], even in field-grown plants where rooting volume is unrestricted (Long et al., 2004). Knowledge of the relationship between C status and growth is advancing (Raines and Paul, 2006; Smith and Stitt, 2007), but a clear picture of how carbohydrates are sensed by the plant and how they regulate the flux of C through different pathways, impacting growth and partitioning, remains a major challenge to developing crops that will respond maximally to rising [CO2]. Large and sustained increases in Suc, starch, or fructan content that persist over a number of days are usually indicative of replete sinks (Rogers and Ainsworth, 2006). This has two important implications. First, crops could be manipulated to use the additionally available C to increase growth, seed yield, or stress tolerance (see below). Second, because foliar carbohydrates are known to have negative feedback on photosynthetic capacity (for review, see Long et al., 2004), ensuring adequate sink strength in crops will be an essential part of maximally exploiting rising [CO2]. Evidence from a Free Air Concentration Enrichment (FACE) experiment supports this view. There was no reduction in maximum Rubisco activity at elevated [CO2] in an indeterminate soybean (Glycine max) cultivar, but in an otherwise identical isoline that had a single gene mutation resulting in a determinate growth habit and lower sink strength, carbohydrates accumulated and photosynthetic capacity was significantly reduced (Ainsworth et al., 2004). This illustrates that the capacity for utilization of photosynthate is critical to a crop's ability to sustain increased C acquisition at elevated [CO2]. Further, a recent review concluded that at current [CO2], yields of maize (Zea mays), wheat (Triticum aestivum), and soybean were limited more by sink capacity than photosynthetic capacity (Borras et al., 2004). In contrast, results from elevated [CO2] research clearly show that increased photosynthesis does stimulate yield at elevated [CO2] (Kimball et al., 2002; Ainsworth and Long, 2005; Long et al., 2006), suggesting that increases in yield can also be source driven. However, it is likely that increases in photosynthesis will need to be balanced by commensurate increases in sink capacity if maximum yield potential is to be realized. What are the components of yield that might be limiting the response of crops to elevated [CO2]? Yields of soybean and rice (Oryza sativa) grown under elevated [CO2] in FACE experiments were 15% and 13% higher than yields of crops grown at ambient [CO2], despite significant declines in harvest index (HI; seed yield/total aboveground biological yield; Kim et al., 2003; Morgan et al., 2005). Genetic improvements over the past century in grain yield in a number of crops, including soybean, wheat, and rice, have been closely associated with improvements in HI (Gifford et al., 1984); however, it has been argued that the scope for further increasing yield through increasing HI is limited (Austin, 1999). Still, at least maintaining current levels of HI at elevated [CO2] would improve productivity. Regardless of improvements to HI, a second way to increase yield is to increase total biomass at maturity. More aboveground biomass per area has been the major factor in yield improvements at elevated [CO2] in FACE experiments. In rice, elevated [CO2] decreased the productive tiller ratio (Kim et al., 2003) and reduced the of et al., 2006). However, because the tiller number per area was significantly higher at elevated [CO2], yields were increased despite the negative effects on productive tiller ratio and (Kim et al., 2003; et al., 2006). Elevated [CO2] also has little on grain or seed et al., 2005; et al., 2006), which may not be because grain has not with improvement in wheat, or soybean over of the last century et al., 2007). Therefore, efforts to target grain or seed may not be but there to be the opportunity to improve biomass the number of and In their research and development the major biotechnology Syngenta, and have at improving N use Although growth at elevated [CO2] N use (Drake et al., improved is essential to maximally rising [CO2]. The greater of carboxylation at elevated [CO2] it for C3 crops in 2050 to their Rubisco content by approximately and the photosynthetic rate as they have today (Drake et al., with this C3 crops grown at μmol mol−1 [CO2] in FACE reduced their maximum Rubisco activity by approximately 20% (Ainsworth and Rogers, 2007). This reduction in Rubisco activity is most likely to a reduction in Rubisco content (Long et al., 2004). with the C3 to of their N in Rubisco to for its catalytic rate (Long et al., 2004). The investment in Rubisco, coupled with a potential reduction in Rubisco could approximately of N at elevated [CO2]. However, there is only benefit in reducing the of N in Rubisco the resources can be the or to sink development in the plant et al., this in N is to the predicted to increase in C acquisition (Long et al., 2004), the N acquisition at elevated [CO2] is increased yields in C3 crops at elevated [CO2], a recent of the concentration in food crops that the N acquisition at elevated [CO2] as a to 15% reduction in grain even in field-grown crops et al., This is because the major biotechnology are to increase content in grain crops and will have to against the effects of rising [CO2] to this 2007). might be expected to the N acquisition at elevated [CO2] because they can their excess C for N with their Evidence from soybean supports this because grain content only a at elevated [CO2] et al., and soybean grown at elevated [CO2] FACE technology N (Rogers et al., 2006). the capacity for N plants to improve and demand for has been but the N acquisition at elevated [CO2] and increases in yield will this even more in These targets for biotechnological improvement of crop responses to elevated [CO2] should be with for the projected increase in temperature, drought and [O3] that will rising [CO2]. C supply is increased at elevated [CO2], it may be to a greater of photosynthate associated with stress and are of that of under drought and high temperatures, such as have been in tolerance of crops to and et al., and 2005; et al., 2005). of these could the of growth at elevated [CO2] in germplasm to in growing not agricultural Greater of C4 crops at elevated [CO2] has been from some (for review, see et al., However, evidence from FACE suggests that photosynthesis at elevated [CO2] is an of reduced stomatal conductance and water leading to of drought stress et al., et al., et al., 2006). There have not been FACE on C4 crops in nutrient but it that the of elevated [CO2] to crops such as and will not be universally but limited to and of In addition, because elevated [CO2] is only stress in C4 species and not directly there is no gain in yield potential that can be by the targets for C3 Thus, climate change presents a challenge to C4 crop improvement, than an The variability of [O3] over time and as well as the nature of plant responses to [O3] have made it to the average agronomic of elevated [O3] or to a synthesis of the mechanisms of a number of present-day crop to O3 in the of to billion in the et al., and billion in and There is that elevated [O3] in the future will further crop yields as a of stress in foliar and et al., et al., 2005). Recent of the effects of elevated [O3] on plants have identified mechanisms of response to and O3 (Long and 2002; et al., 2005; et al., 2005). to daily [O3] of nmol mol−1 for or are considered to be to daily [O3] of to nmol mol−1 for as little as a are considered (Long and 2002; et al., 2005). between and responses has of experiments those current or future conditions. However, the concentrations experiments are and the between plant responses is in such as maximum [O3] nmol mol−1 and average concentrations of nmol mol−1 (Wang et al., 2007), plants in the will likely both and O3 conditions This is more likely to occur in the future and the [O3] for of molecular, biochemical, and responses will be The of the results of of years and environments, would be expected to of some of the potential of elevated [CO2], be it with a significant time In contrast, the variability in [O3] will not lead to the consistent that is to breeding discussions of improving tolerance to elevated [O3] have on three O3 the improving and altering the regulate the flux of O3 and the of stomatal in response to O3 has long been recognized and Therefore, reducing stomatal conductance is an biotechnological to increase O3 tolerance et al., However, the of lower stomatal conductance leading to lower photosynthesis be and the between reducing stress reducing Elevated [CO2] will stomatal conductance and O3 in the increasing than decreasing This will the negative of elevated [O3] and 2005). In many growing increases in [O3], the gain from reduced stomatal conductance to stress would likely be as the in would any reduction of The wheat in between and today provide an of gain in yield, despite increased to elevated for higher C and improved HI has improved the yield potential from approximately to approximately despite greater O3 from greater stomatal conductance et al., Although there is not a relationship between stomatal conductance and O3 stomatal conductance as a to improve crop production under elevated [O3] unlikely to be an for maintaining other than in with the it should be that the concentrations of CO2 to crops from O3 are very poorly and for species and any of elevated [O3] on will probably not be by elevated [CO2], and of sinks may the response to elevated [CO2] et al., 1997; 2005). In addition, elevated [CO2] not of that is of O3 at ambient [CO2] et al., 2005). further it is not to where and the stress of elevated [O3] will be or by the of elevated [CO2]. second for improving crop tolerance to O3 has on improving of species et al., 2005). through the and is rapidly in the The O3 is to the associated with the which to et al., is one of the major to O3 tolerance in and total content has been with O3 tolerance in a of species (for review, see and 2004). of or other to the where and to be important in from O3 as is of back to the reduced et al., 2003; and 2004). However, not have that O3 tolerance with content et al., and concentrations in some plants may be low to a significant in Still, increasing the capacity of crops may be a target for limiting of the O3 and to be potential targets for biotechnological to improve crop productivity. of and are more to O3 than control et al., et al., 2005). However, it is important to that the associated with O3 has considerable with the that et al., In addition, interactions among and are in the cycle et al., as well as of et al., 2007). Therefore, improvement of crop tolerance to O3 by altering or will on targets for that not other and 2004). Although some of global change rising [CO2] will be the such as rising tropospheric [O3] and precipitation will the of a growing the next of biotechnology and future crop breeding will be challenged with that can maximally rising [CO2] for yield and have improved stress tolerance (Reynolds and Borlaug, 2006). Global climate change will at least three to this the production environment will be more and more climatic will be greater between years and of and the environment for which crops are being will be a rapidly moving understanding the environment interactions and the understanding the of crop in their production environment 2000), will be a major in the to of improved yield in the rapidly changing This the of for and germplasm in the production and that crops research and development pipelines today will in 10 to years a different the last crop technology has been than any other technology in the history of agriculture 2007). The approximately 250 million of maize (Zea mays), (Zea and have increased global by approximately reduced by approximately million reduced the environmental of use by approximately and reduced greenhouse emissions by approximately million of CO2 and 2006). These improvements have from engineering single however, crop responses to elevated [CO2] and [O3] are and will be more to control and germplasm with greater stress is progress through research and development Knowledge of crop responses to elevated [CO2] and elevated [O3] could match that of flooding, temperature, and nutrient stress with greater investment in and we have identified a number of potential targets for biotechnological improvement in a high-[CO2] and high-[O3] world. We for discussions and on a of this
Source: PLANT PHYSIOLOGY
Language: English
Subfield: Agronomy and Crop Science
Domain: Life Sciences
Keywords: crop biotechnology, elevated CO2, tropospheric ozone, climate change, crop stress tolerance, drought tolerance, flooding tolerance, cold tolerance, heat tolerance, food security, crop yield, crop-environment interactions, abiotic stress, biotic stress, population growth, germplasm improvement, climate extremes, soil degradation
SDGs: Zero hunger, Climate action
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2115161333
