Work

Signal Transduction between the Chloroplast and the Nucleus

Year: 2002
Type: article
Abstract: Chloroplasts are essential for the unique photoautotrophic and sessile existence of higher plants. Chloroplasts account for >50% of the total soluble protein in leaves, and these proteins are encoded by both nuclear and chloroplast genomes. This separation of genetic information necessitates coordinated regulation in the expression of these genomes. The factors that influence the expression of photosynthetic genes include environmental (i.e., light quality and intensity) and developmental cues (McFadden, 1999). It is well known that the expression of chloroplast-encoded components of photosynthesis depends on nucleus-derived factors. A number of reports indicate that the expression of a set of nuclear genes that encode chloroplast-localized proteins is dependent on the functional state of the plastid via a process known as retrograde signaling. Blocking chloroplast development at an early stage by any of a variety of methods inhibits the transcription of numerous nuclear genes that encode chloroplast proteins, yet neither the signal nor its intracellular signaling pathway is known (Oelmüller, 1989). In this review, we discuss the recent genetic and physiological evidence for the existence of at least two independent retrograde signaling pathways, one mediated by tetrapyrroles, the other mediated by redox signaling, and suggest models for both pathways. The Plastid Tetrapyrrole Biosynthetic Pathway. Five small arrows represent the five enzymatic steps that are required for the synthesis of protoporphyrinogen from 5-aminolevulinic acid. The reactions catalyzed by HY1/GUN2, HY2/GUN3, and GUN5 are boxed. Reduction of the 4-vinyl group can occur before or after the reaction catalyzed by protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase. The synthesis of common precursors and Mg-porphyrins is adapted from Beale (1999), and the synthesis of 3(E)-phytochromobilin from protoporphyrin IX is adapted from Terry et al. (1993). Feeding studies with mutants and inhibitors of the chlorophyll biosynthetic pathway in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii suggest that chlorophyll biosynthetic pathway intermediates inhibit the expression of chloroplast protein genes that reside in the nucleus. In early experiments, conditions or compounds that are presumed to cause Mg-protoporphyrin IX monomethyl ester (Mg-ProtoMe) accumulation appear to be the most effective inhibitors of light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b binding protein of photosystem II (Lhcb) mRNA accumulation. Protoporphyrin IX (Proto) and protochlorophyllide (Pchlide) were found to be less effective than Mg-ProtoMe (Johanningmeier and Howell, 1984; Johanningmeier, 1988). In Chlamydomonas, the intracellular pools of Mg-Proto and Mg-ProtoMe increase transiently during dark-to-light transitions, and this increase is correlated with increases in the expression of nuclear genes that encode the cytosolic and plastid heat shock proteins HSP70A and HSP70B, respectively (Kropat et al., 2000). Feeding Mg-Proto or Mg-ProtoMe to dark-grown mutants, cell types, or chemically treated cells that have reduced porphyrin levels induces HSP70A and HSP70B mRNA accumulation. Proto, Pchlide, and chlorophyllide did not affect the expression of HSP70A in similar experiments (Kropat et al., 1997, 2000). Mg-Proto and Mg-ProtoMe activate a heat- and light-responsive HSP70A promoter fragment, but they do not affect an HSP70A promoter fragment that is induced only by heat. This result suggests that Mg-Proto and Mg-ProtoMe can activate transcription through a light-responsive cis element (Kropat et al., 1997). Interestingly, Chlamydomonas cells take up exogenously supplied Proto and convert it to Mg-Proto, resulting in large intracellular Mg-Proto and Mg-ProtoMe pools, presumably in plastids. However, Proto feeding does not affect HSP70A or HSP70B expression. These data are consistent with a model in which Mg-Proto and/or Mg-ProtoMe are retained in the plastids of dark-grown Chlamydomonas cells. Mg-Proto and/or Mg-ProtoMe may be transported actively or passively out of the plastid in response to light, and these exported porphyrins activate HSP70 gene transcription (Kropat et al., 2000). Chlorophyll biosynthetic intermediate levels correlate with the transcription of nuclear genes that encode chloroplast proteins in higher plants. For example, Mg-Proto and Mg-ProtoMe levels, as well as Mg-chelatase activity and Mg-Proto methyltransferase activity, all peak at dark-to-light transitions and decline throughout the subsequent 12-h-light period (Gibson et al., 1996; Jensen et al., 1996; Pöpperl et al., 1998; Papenbrock et al., 1999). The expression of Lhc genes is induced strongly by light, but Lhc mRNA levels peak after Mg-porphyrin levels peak (Gibson et al., 1996; Papenbrock et al., 1999). Procedures that presumably cause the accumulation of chlorophyll biosynthetic intermediates by increasing the level of 5-aminolevulinic acid (ALA) also inhibit gene expression in the nucleus. For example, the overproduction of ALA in transgenic tobacco increases chlorophyll content and reduces glutamate 1-semialdehyde aminotransferase mRNA levels, protein levels, and activity (Zavgorodnyaya et al., 1997), and ALA feeding represses Lhcb mRNA levels in Arabidopsis (Vinti et al., 2000) and cress seedlings (Kittsteiner et al., 1991). Moreover, compounds that affect chlorophyll biosynthesis also have been found to affect Lhcb gene expression. For example, thujaplicin, which abolishes Pchlide synthesis and causes the accumulation of porphyrins (particularly Mg-ProtoMe) upstream of Pchlide, specifically inhibits Lhcb transcription (Oster et al., 1996). The herbicide amitrole, which prevents normal prolamellar body development and causes Mg-Proto accumulation, inhibits the light induction of Lhcb and ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase small subunit (RbcS) mRNA levels and represses RbcS transcript levels in dark-grown seedlings (La Rocca et al., 2001). Reduction in Mg-porphyrin pools also affects the expression of chloroplast protein genes that reside in the nucleus. Mg-chelatase inserts Mg2+ into the porphyrin ring of Proto IX and is composed of three subunits. These subunits are referred to commonly as ChlD, ChlH, and ChlI and have molecular masses of ∼70, 140, and 40 kD, respectively (Walker and Willows, 1997). Antisense tobacco plants with suppressed ChlH genes have reduced Mg-chelatase activity and chlorophyll content. ChlD and ChlI expression is not altered in ChlH antisense plants (Papenbrock et al., 2000). A lack of feedback regulation among Mg-chelatase subunit genes might be expected because these genes are expressed differently during the diurnal cycle (Papenbrock et al., 1999). However, compared with wild-type plants, the antisense ChlH plants showed reduced levels of ALA-synthesizing capacity, ALA dehydratase activity, Proto IX, and heme as well as a reduction in steady state mRNAs corresponding to glutamyl-tRNA-reductase, ALA dehydratase, and Lhcb genes (Papenbrock et al., 2000). Papenbrock et al. (2000)suggest that the Mg2+ branch of the tetrapyrrole biosynthetic pathway regulates the enzyme activities and nuclear genes for the enzymes in the early part of this biosynthetic pathway. If Mg-porphyrins in Chlamydomonas and higher plants affect the same plastid-to-nucleus signaling pathway as Mg-chelatase subunit underexpression, the signaling pathway might not be triggered by absolute levels of a chlorophyll biosynthetic intermediate(s). Instead, pathway flux, ratios of particular tetrapyrroles, bound or free levels of the porphyrin binding subunit of Mg-chelatase, and/or partitioning of intermediates into particular regions of the plastid might coordinate enzyme activity and nuclear gene expression. Susek and Chory (1992)devised a genetic strategy for isolating mutants that do not repress Lhcb transcription completely in Arabidopsis seedlings in which chloroplast development is prevented by photooxidative damage. Using this approach, recessive mutations were isolated in five nuclear genes in which the normal coordinated expression of nuclear and chloroplast genomes is disrupted. This group of mutants is referred to as gun for genomes uncoupled (Susek et al., 1993; Mochizuki et al., 2001). The recessive nature of these mutations suggests that they disrupt a repressive signaling pathway. However, the possibility cannot be excluded that a positive signal accumulates in some of the gun mutants and that the positive signal does not reach an essential threshold in heterozygotes. None of the gun mutations affects the tissue- and cell-specific, light-dependent, or circadian regulation of Lhcb genes. Therefore, these mutations appear to specifically impair the plastid regulation of nuclear transcription (Susek et al., 1993). Despite a clear interorganellar signaling defect, many of the gun mutants appear strikingly normal. However, a few of the gun mutants have defects in tetrapyrrole metabolism that cause paleness or light-signaling defects. The gun1 mutant and the gun4 and mutants appear to two pathways, because gun1 gun4 and gun1 mutants Lhcb transcription in In the gun is not among the gun4 mutant and the corresponding mutants et al., 2001). gun1 mutants chlorophyll after in the for and appear to be light during et al., mutant studies suggest that gun1 mutations do not affect tetrapyrrole metabolism (Vinti et al., Mochizuki et al., 2001). In and GUN5 are essential for tetrapyrrole metabolism (Vinti et al., Mochizuki et al., 2001). and are of and heme et al., et al., and et al., 2001). These enzymes are part of the of the tetrapyrrole biosynthetic pathway and are required for the synthesis of the of The chlorophyll among and from to and the chlorophyll of the and mutants are (Vinti et al., Mochizuki et al., 2001). The chlorophyll of a mutant from and a mutant is from the which that the of the mutant is not by a reduction in synthesis (Vinti et al., 2000). A from the that the chlorophyll biosynthetic pathway is in and heme mutants in and et al., Terry and 1999). GUN5 the ChlH subunit of Mg-chelatase et al. 2001). Lhcb transcription also is in the Mg-chelatase mutant and 1988). and mutations affect tetrapyrrole biosynthesis The of gun4 and mutant studies suggest that gun4 also affects tetrapyrrole this Mg-porphyrins in plastid-to-nucleus signaling (Vinti et al., Mochizuki et al., 2001). these that the in the mutants of and result from the of a (Vinti et al., 2000). The Arabidopsis after mutant also to affect tetrapyrrole metabolism and nuclear by its in light, which suggests a in signal a soluble binding protein that at the chloroplast These proteins are in the of The and gene expression of are to Proto levels are in the mutant accumulates Proto, this mutant normal levels of et al., 2001). is from glutamate in the is transported to the or it is to Proto by the also is exported for heme synthesis et al., 2000). is to in the of Proto into the which presumably that pools of Proto be for tetrapyrrole In levels of Proto are to affect a signaling pathway or et al., 2001). Lhcb expression is not in mutants which suggests that and the gun mutants affect pathways. This result is because and affect tetrapyrrole but might have a on pathway It be to mutants from and from the mutants from and three ChlH, ChlD, and Arabidopsis ChlH mutants, and have similar gun However, two Arabidopsis ChlI mutants, and are not gun The of these mutations on Mg-chelatase activity and chlorophyll synthesis is and and the have of Mg-chelatase is than but accumulates chlorophyll and higher levels of Mg-chelatase than et al., 2001). does not chlorophyll and cannot et al., is a of ChlI in the Arabidopsis et al., These also suggest in to a in the of Proto, also as a porphyrin for a plastid-to-nucleus signaling pathway et al., 2001). This is not because porphyrins as a in the of the other Mg-chelatase subunits et al., 2001). Mg-chelatase to be at the chloroplast which is a for a tetrapyrrole for a plastid-to-nucleus signaling pathway. In ChlH with in However, in ChlH is found in the (Gibson et al., 1996; et al., The of ChlD with is dependent on Mg2+ et al., but ChlI is found in the are with et al., of the of ChlH with and the in plastid Mg2+ et al., studies be required to the of ChlH and other Mg-chelatase subunits the for is from ALA in the and transported to it is by The model of and an in the of Proto into the is adapted from et al. ChlH is required for and may in plastid-to-nucleus signaling, as in the The may reside in the but it is in the for nuclear genes that encode chloroplast proteins are by However, Mg-porphyrins activate Chlamydomonas HSP70 genes. may Mg-Proto and the chloroplast chloroplast nuclear If ChlH in interorganellar a ChlH may by or as a with other factors. A might in signaling during diurnal in Mg-porphyrin A might tetrapyrrole levels before essential is or as chloroplast is as by Rocca et al. porphyrins enzyme This tetrapyrrole signaling pathway may be to the accumulation of porphyrins and to coordinate the expression of nuclear genes that encode chloroplast proteins with the that occur in the photosynthetic during development and in response to the and other have been to have in the it be to the binding of ChlH for other might with cytosolic signal as by et al. and et al. ChlH in the of the plastid but it is as well that ChlH in plastid-to-nucleus signal tetrapyrrole in both Chlamydomonas and higher plants that through the tetrapyrrole biosynthetic pathway in the chloroplast affects nuclear gene expression. However, numerous studies in and higher plants have that the redox of the in the photosynthetic also nuclear gene expression. This is a of the that light induces in the of the two the of through the and the redox of the of in The both and nuclear in with the redox state of the the expression of genes and and of of gene of is in and in it is mediated by as the of review, et al., 1999). and in the plastid are by redox the the reduction of to a protein that light-harvesting II from the to the regions of the and the of light by the by the of a is is and to the This cycle the of light the two in is by the redox state of which is by the reduction of by and synthesis in increases to after to However, is increase in chloroplast mRNA that light the of In the proteins to the regions of and The binding of proteins to the of is by the redox state of which is reduced by The of mRNA a that of these proteins, a The of the is by the of a but not by a and is by the the of and the of and the of this with a Chlamydomonas mutant that the reaction showed that light not wild-type levels of these suggest that the redox state of by in the The of the transcription of some chloroplast-encoded genes also is to redox by photosynthetic conditions that one photosystem during the other cause an in and This the of photosynthesis and may be in the by state a the cell the of and by in gene expression. The of transcription is by the quality of and are the components of and the transcription of these genes to light and increases to light causes the reduction of the The of an that prevents the reduction of causes a in the of transcription in isolated the of which prevents the of the increases the transcription of in light Therefore, the regulates the transcription of a of chloroplast genes through a redox signal to the of the two reaction The which the of also is to regulation by redox et al., 1999). of the to redox the However, in photosynthetic a number of genes that encode components of the photosynthetic are in the nucleus. This the of experiments that suggest that redox from the chloroplast influence the expression of a of nuclear genes in light the redox to photosynthetic gene expression. light levels, in light quality are via that are to in or the higher of redox are via the redox cycle and et al., evidence for the of both of these in signaling. of nuclear gene expression is an not a development is mediated via the and as by photosynthetic are for the photosynthetic to environmental and is to the to to light and to photosynthetic experiments with transgenic tobacco plants that photosynthetic the transcription of the gene as well as mRNA et al., The of mRNA and it to in the chlorophyll a/b of have been to correlate with in of the are to or et al., this of experiments, cells were any The that in the chlorophyll content of the chlorophyll a/b and and Lhcb mRNA are by the redox of photosynthetic as by in et al. that the redox of the nuclear photosynthetic gene expression and experiments that suggest the of signaling components in the and/or that may in signal The the of to light a process known as These in the of are and occur in that this is not a chloroplast development pathway as an pathway. et al. by in chlorophyll a content. A increase in the of chlorophyll in cells of from light to light in content are a of and a to increase in Lhcb mRNA of a to The of to the of to in and induced a increase in chlorophyll a content of on to the levels of chlorophyll a by that this is to the redox state of the of and an of were to None of these inhibitors altered chlorophyll levels, that neither synthesis nor is in Lhcb expression. the redox state of the a protein that It is of to are that may be to the redox state of the If the of Lhcb genes is mediated by a protein inhibitors of protein affect the (i.e., the of Lhcb gene expression at The of and to the increase of chlorophyll a cell by to acid and specifically inhibit activities found only in the and nucleus. Therefore, the are signal components of the experiments with protein isolated from and that a from the promoter a protein only in cells. conditions that or an in and which in a in photosynthetic This is by an response and a response that causes a of photosystem we have in this in photosynthetic gene expression. is not the same in higher plants and and 1997). in light higher plants are to a of light conditions as or as be found a However, are to the diurnal and higher plants be to photosynthetic these et al. that the redox of the also affects nuclear photosynthetic gene expression in higher plants. This nuclear genes to photosystem and that redox that the transcription of genes to the chloroplast also affect the expression of photosynthetic genes in the nucleus. The from and were to the gene and to transgenic tobacco The were for response to to the two The promoter similar activities all light The and showed higher activity in than light, but reduction after from to The the and higher activity in light compared with light, but the other two it by a The same tobacco also were treated with photosynthetic The promoter did not to with or For the and by a light and the expression of in plants. effective only in with but not This suggests that may be a threshold not by the redox state of the or light The and showed a in the same as after with Therefore, these two to to redox that the and or to in prevents the of it that the redox of the regulates this The of studies that redox in the of photosynthetic gene expression have we be and induced by the altered metabolism of the treated cells. The Arabidopsis mutant evidence for the of the redox state of the in the regulation of nuclear photosynthetic genes et al., 1999). Arabidopsis mutants nuclear genes that encode chloroplast-localized chloroplast and which in a The of the is dependent on light the plastid The biosynthesis of compounds is in plants the This in reduced through the the of light as and also is from the and plants a in the induction of chlorophyll a The of the in the and mutant is to than that for wild-type plants. of photosynthetic and and that the of is reduced transiently in the mutant and that altered redox may affect Lhcb expression. The reduced levels of in the mutant may to light in Lhcb of the evidence that we have suggests that the of this signal is the However, et al. evidence that and not the is the redox that the of a signaling to the nucleus. The the signal pathway components in protein which also is redox et al. plants a variety of light and by from a at to light and at at at and at the level of and the accumulation of and protein and Lhcb transcript showed a positive The that the of the via a of redox In leaves, this the of via reduction by the and its by the et al., 2000). the regulation of Lhcb to this is not the of the redox state of the et al. plants a variety of light and and that cycle and early proteins and mRNAs with increasing found the reduction state of and chlorophyll a/b or protein or in higher plants, the chlorophyll of is not by the redox state of It is that are a number of that the expression of plastid components encoded in the and redox is but one of these et al. the photosynthetic and signaling. Using Arabidopsis cell and transgenic Arabidopsis genes by the promoter or the they found that the of Lhcb and depends on photosynthetic and not the of the cells. that a redox signal from the plastid the expression of nuclear photosynthetic genes. this on the that light-harvesting and photosystem in response to light levels of light can be by photosynthetic or as can as and activate in both the plastid and the which in can activate nuclear gene expression. The Arabidopsis gene is an part of the the reduction of to as an are at least five of the Arabidopsis and a number of have been as in the Arabidopsis are to the chloroplast and and and The expression of all of the genes is with signaling and et al., 2000). light levels can to in the of If the cannot the of via its cells photooxidative damage. in are by an increase in the of is one of the of redox In two et al. that the expression of a number of nuclear genes in the of cells is by the redox state of the increase in induced the expression of and mRNA the of light et al., 1997). levels in the they higher than in plants that not been to not before to light but induced after to light and during the of the If the conditions that the cell and the expression of been to inhibit the induction of and by which inhibits the of induces the expression of and in These data suggest that redox in in the of to a that gene expression. The of Arabidopsis with can and expression and increase to light However, the of to to light and does not the of expression et al., 1999). This suggests that is a set of by light and in nuclear gene and it is not only an increase in levels that in the nucleus. may have a on the photosynthetic or they may in with a photosynthetic this signal is to the is et al. three a and out of a plastid and activate a cytosolic conditions increase which to in the A redox in the a signal via through the et al. an with cytosolic as the This redox be a for the of a redox signal out of the The and nuclear proteins that in the plastid-to-nucleus signaling are However, been on the of cis in nuclear genes that to positive from plastid in Chlamydomonas (Kropat et al., and repressive from plastids in higher plants. the gun mutants suggest a for in one of the repressive signaling from plastids. genes that encode chloroplast proteins are by a group of cis that in a et al., 1996). gene have been to light and plastid response in of nuclear genes that encode chloroplast it not been to and light-responsive cis et al., 1996; et al., 2001). of five from to in the which the of the chloroplast causes and that these five are part of a binding et al., 1996). These five are upstream of a it is that transcription in and by binding to the and the of a binding of the promoter light and are to inhibit which the binding to on the et al., 2001). and appear to on the same cis a number of experiments suggest that these two are For example, from dark-grown plants a prolamellar body and chlorophyll and are to and The herbicide prevents normal prolamellar body development and represses ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase small subunit (RbcS) mRNA levels in dark-grown plants (La Rocca et al., 2001). A number of dark-grown mutants in the and these do not or chlorophyll because of a in the chlorophyll biosynthetic pathway. genes that encode chloroplast proteins are in the in many of these However, of these genes is prevented by plastid which also development and 1999). and to plastid they are not induced by light that are in to affect et al., 1996). also can the of some In the of light induction of is independent of the plastid signal et al., 2001). on common promoter light and plastid signaling at some a plastid signal is required for the of nuclear photosynthesis genes in the mutants and the of to be of and 2000). In the is a nuclear protein that is required for by through the et al., 2000). body of evidence that at least two of from the chloroplast and to the expression of nuclear genes in of these in the tetrapyrrole biosynthetic pathway. The in this is intermediate the any the In heme regulates the expression of the It been conditions that the biosynthesis of the heme the and the transcription which in the of the gene and et al., 1989). The Arabidopsis of the it is that in higher plants. is (Kropat et al., et al., that some porphyrins are exported from the to the of the is at It also is known that some of the enzymes of the branch of the tetrapyrrole biosynthetic pathway to the chloroplast 1999). It is that signaling components the of the plastid and that information to the nucleus. of chloroplast is on redox it to that be redox of plastid genetic have evidence in the redox of gene expression been to the nuclear at this we may only redox are from the they activate and in they activate or repress transcription factors in the nucleus. to in this and to the evidence that the components of retrograde signaling. for on the on intracellular signaling the chloroplast and the is by a from the of and The is an of the from of and by a of
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2116216358
FWCI: 6.435
Cites: 74
Cited by: 256
Related to: 10