Second Thoughts on Gender and Women's History
Year: 1995
Type: article
Abstract: For a women's historian working on the antebellum period, the "cult of true womanhood" or the notion of "separate spheres" looms as an ever present, inescapable, even archetypal framework.As Linda Kerber has suggested, the trope of separate spheres has in fact determined the boundaries of the entire field of American women's history, because it simultaneously carved a space for women in the current historiography and a place for feminist inquiry in the historical profession.Nevertheless, many women's historians have questioned this ruling paradigm.Kerber notes that spheres operates as a spatial metaphor in much of the existing scholarship, which in turn frames women as historical subjects within a rigid dualism and insular conceptual domain. 1 Nancy Hewitt, bell hooks, and Christine Stansell have further demonstrated how race, class, and religion cut deep divisions-physical, material, and ideological-that make the unifying logic of women's sphere seem contradictory, if not illusionary.2 In its place, historians have turned to the category of gender, which is not new to feminist scholars, but which has emerged as the most promising theoretical departure, especially for those scholars interested in expanding the range of topics explored by women's historians.Joan Scott added a new-and to some degree controversial-dimension to the meaning of gender by urging women's historians to embrace poststructuralist theory as well.3 In this paper, I plan to review Scott's definition of gender, focusing on its strengths, possible pitfalls, and omissions.In the course of doing so, I will assess how several of the most influential studies of "separate spheres" elide the issues raised by poststructuralism.
Source: American studies
Author: Nancy Isenberg
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Gender equality
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2117058676
