Work

A study of controversial organizational action: organizational action and audience reaction in the context of financial restatement

Year: 2006
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation investigates audience responses to organizational action that, \nwhile violating audience expectations for consistent and reliable organizational behavior, \nis ambiguous in terms of its ultimate impact on audiences. The practical situation that I \nattempt to explain is the reactions to the controversial organizational action of financial \nrestatement by five key audiences of the restating firm (shareholders, institutional \ninvestors, securities analysts, the SEC, and customers). A principal argument I develop \nhere is that it is important to consider that audiences react to the controversial action in \nthe context of the organization’s history of action. In this dissertation I look at prior \naction that is consistent with audience interests, and posit that it is not obvious how such \nprior action will affect audience interpretations of controversy. I examine two categories \nof prior action that conforms to audience interests—agency-problem mitigation and \ncorporate social responsibility (CSR) action—and I draw on competing perspectives \nexplaining how such prior organizational action might affect audience responses to the \ncontroversial action of financial restatement. On the one hand, such prior organizational \naction might dampen audience negative reactions to the organization’s financial \nrestatement. Alternatively, such prior organizational action might aggravate audience \nnegative responses to the restatement. I also predict that such prior organizational action \nwill make it more likely that the restating firm will engage in post-restatement actions \nwith the potential to repair damage to positive audience perceptions, specifically CEO \nchange and board member turnover. And, I predict that post-restatement CEO turnover \nwill dampen audience negative reaction to financial restatement. I test my hypotheses \nusing multiple regression models, employing a two-stage process to first control for the \nprobability that a firm will be among those that restated finances, and then to model the \nreaction of audiences to the restatement announcement. This dissertation contributes to \nour understanding of: 1) how prior desirable organizational action influences audience \ninterpretations of controversial action; 2) how post-controversy organizational action \ninfluences audience continuing interpretations of controversial action; and 3) the presence \nof a secondary link between firm CSR action and firm outcomes.
Author: Donald Lange
Language: English
Subfield: Accounting
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2124258788
Cites: 189
Cited by:
Related to: 10