Comparison of the Design-bid-build and Construction Manager at Risk Project Delivery Methods Utilized for the Construction of Public Schools
Year: 2014
Type: dissertation
Abstract: According to Fails Management Institute (FMI) and the ConstructionManagement Association of America (CMAA), the most widely utilized and accepted project delivery method is the Design-Bid-Build method (FMI/CMAA, 2010).However, proponents of alternative methods, such as Construction Manager at-Risk (CM at-Risk), believe that these methods offer the promise of better performance when utilized on certain types of projects (AIA-AGC, 2011;Konchar & Sanvido, 1998).Furthermore, it is said that modern projects are subject to increased risk due to complex designs and technology, involvement of multiple and diverse parties, and increased budgetary and schedule pressure, and that "choosing an appropriate delivery (method) is often the key to success-or the source of failure" (Demkin & AIA, 2009, p. 492).In order to empower decision makers responsible for constructing new public schools (K-12), this study sought to determine how the CM at-Risk project delivery method performed in comparison to the Design-Bid-Build method on school projects utilizing the performance metrics of construction cost, time, quality, and claims.The research was carried out over a two year period from 2012 to 2014 and included a twostage data collection effort consisting of a historical document review and assemblage and a survey of district managers regarding the performance of 137 Elementary, Middle, and High school projects constructed in Florida, Georgia, North Carolina, and South Carolina.Data analysis was completed utilizing two group t-tests and chi-square (x 2 ) distributions based on a 95% confidence interval.iii The analysis indicated that public school projects constructed utilizing the CM at-Risk method did not produce the purported cost, schedule, productivity, or risk reduction benefits.The mean values of all cost performance metrics for CM at-Risk projects were significantly higher than those of their Design-Bid-Build counterparts.Analysis of schedule performance metrics provided no statistically significant differences with regard to school project durations.Similarly, statistically significant results were not obtained through examination of risk, productivity, cost growth, and schedule growth metrics.Conversely, the analysis indicated that CM at-Risk school projects produced significantly higher levels of product and service quality as reported by district construction managers in almost every category examined.However, regardless of the project delivery method being employed, almost all managers were satisfied with both the service and product quality provided during construction of their completed school projects.The differences observed were merely indications of the degree of quality satisfaction with the products and services rendered.Possible reasons that the purported CM at-Risk benefits of cost, schedule, productivity, and risk reduction were not manifested in the results of this study could be attributable in part to many issues including: incorrect selection of the most appropriate project delivery method by administrators and district construction managers, utilization of value added designs and equipment in some schools that may have influenced costs and other metrics, contingency management practices, collaborative influences on the scheduling process, lack of respect and appreciation for the differing factors related to each project delivery method, and unrealistic expectations of the decision makers.Based program, it being unimportant to mention anyone by name, except that Deborah should be mentioned first, but that's it, except for Lynn being next, of course.I would like to say that everyone, including the students and professors, have always been willing to provide support, praise, and advice whenever necessary.Having these colleagues to lean on and relate to when times were rough enabled me to keep things in perspective (usually) and enjoy the overall experience.Thank you for the friendship and encouragement.I wish you all well with your lives and careers.I would like to acknowledge Dr. Mickey Lauria for accepting me into the program and launching me back into graduate school with my initial course in planning that first semester.I appreciate the challenges you put before me and the advice you provided to assist in the management of my degree path.I encourage my PDBE colleagues to engage this powerful resource while navigating their way through the program.I would like to individually thank the members of my dissertation committee.I offer thanks to the Chairman, Dr. Dennis Bausman, for providing the initial research direction, ongoing encouragement, and steadfast guidance and coffee during our many hours of discussion.Thanks to Dr. Roger Liska for the direct comments and feedback during many chapters of proof reading and editing.To Dr. Hoke Hill, for his genuine interest with the topic, the statistics tutelage, and the SAS program training
Source: TigerPrints (Clemson University)
Author: Noel Carpenter
Institution: Clemson University
Language: English
Field: Decision Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: design-bid-build, construction manager at risk, project delivery methods, public school construction, construction cost performance, construction quality, construction claims, construction risk management, construction method comparison, cost growth, schedule growth, productivity indicators
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2124750376
