Year: 2004
Type: editorial
Abstract: general secretary, for assisted suicide prompted the organisation to change its name from EXIT, in order to distance itself from his activities. 5Then as now the organisation clearly stated that it does not condone operating outside the law, although it does seek a change in the law.Surely a case is to be made for reform, but not along the permissive lines that have been proposed, including those in a controversial editorial in this journal. 6Rather, what is needed is greater clarity in the definition and application of the offence.The prosecutions to date in England and Wales show a body of law that is replete with uncertainty, obfuscation, and injustice.Consider the "classic" case of "leaving the pills."Certainly convictions have been made in such circumstances, but this does not explain why one case was dismissed by the court since the accused "only provided the option," which was, said the judge, "not enough." 7 Furthermore no health professional has been prosecuted for the offence in this jurisdiction despite at least anecdotal evidence indicating that such assistance does occur. 8o less confusing is the (il)legality of "death tourism."After Reginald Crew was assisted to die in Switzerland, uncertainty prevailed over whether his wife, Win, had committed an offence in helping him to travel there.Although the police declined to prosecute in that case, they have yet to promulgate their prosecuting policy on this issue.
Source: BMJ
Authors: G David Batty, I-Min Lee
Language: English
Topic: Physical Activity and Health
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2125043725
