Year: 2004
Type: article
Abstract: This project begins from the researcher's lived "tensions" as an academic in activist community, and as a feminist activist entering the academy.The investgation takes up critical pedagogy's methods of mutual dialogue and critical reflection to explore the community-based involvement and research methodologies of activist academics.The thesis particularly considers the ways in which troubles and complements between activism and the academy characterize graduate students7 trajectory toward becoming "activist academics."Discussion with twelve activist-oriented graduate students reflecting on their experiences suggests that, across disciplines and interests, activist graduate students may share experiences situating them similarly as novices, learning to participate in the practices of an activist academic commzlnig ofpractice.For some, activism is the starting point for academic work, while others develop commitment to community involvement through, and beyond their thesis research.However, as participants recall "getting their hands drrty" in the discursive work of activist communities, all describe having developed skills and knowledge that overlap and integrate in both academic and activist work.This inq-applies an institutional ethnography analysis to participants' critical reflections on the "tensions" for them of activist scholarship.Such an approach brings into view the discourses.relationships, and institutionalized procedures constraining and organizing ----.action in both activist and academc settings.Whlle participants r e d difficuiues in nego&&lg the written and unwritten rules of the academy's procedures, relationships, and drscourse, they also expose relations w i h ostensibly counter-hegemonic activist settings that resemble mainstream (class, race, and gender) social stratification.This brings into view the ruling relations enacted in both community and academic semngs.Strikingly, eleven of the sampled thirteen community-involved or activist pdcipants are women, people of colour, working class, and/or le~bian/~ay/queer.While these "outsider" students describe particular difficulties and tensions in the intersections of identity, community, and academy, nonetheless, ten participants continue in academic careers incorporating community interests.The study concludes by considering some possible implications of this juxtaposition, and asks in what ways activist community involvement might prepare "outsider" students, in particular, for academic success.. . .lll It is only when the oppressed find the oppressor out and become involved in the organized struggle for their liberation that they begin to believe in themselves.This discovery cannot be purely intellectual but must involve action; nor can it be limited to mere activism, but must include serious reflection: only then will it be a praxis. PauloFreire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed (1970) practices, (Lave and Wenger 1991) of a primarily text-based community of activist-oriented academics., This research is concerned with research participants who are enough "like" me that I might hope to learn from their experience of integrating graduate research and activist work, and whose experience rmght assist to explicate and elucidate the "tensionsy7 I perceived as I sought to deslgn graduate-level research that might "matter."About research begmnmg in one's own experience, Himani Bannerji writes:There is no better point of entry into a critique or reflection than one's own experience.It is not the end point, but the begmmg of an exploration of the relationship between the personal and the social and therefore political and this connecting process, which is also a discovery, is the real pedagogic science, the "science" of social science.(1995, p.550) Begmnmg from reflection on my own efforts working to integrate activism into academic work, I sought others who had recently completed their degrees, and who might, therefore, have shared available theoretical perspectives, similar institutional structures and local supports, and perhaps, experienced similar "tensions" between activist community involvement and the academy.The search for other activist-oriented student researchers has relied heavily on a practice of community mapping and network building.In order to locate some of "nerghbours" in this community of activist academics, I namgated through a series of connections between students, connections visible in their texts or made through personal contact.In effect, mine has been a snowball sampling approach (Blaxter et a1 2001, p.92).Integrating data gathered through textual analysis and interviewing, this project aims to generate a "map" of the links and tensions of concurrent activist and academic work.The view from the standpoint2 of the sample "community" of graduate students will generate an analysis of ways in whch socially progressive graduate-level research might be constrained-or gmded and supported-by the academic institution and activist communities.Further, it will explore Dorothy Smth (1987,1990,1999) uses the term "standpomt", as do other f e r n s t (e.g.Hartsock, 1995) and Marxist theorists to denote a paradar, concrete positton m the pohtical economy of a soaety, and therefore, the mew of the world that is possible from that position.Th~s m q u q takes the standpoint of a (fermtllst) actmst newcomer to progressme, transformatwe, or 'cnbccal' academc mquuy m order to mterrogate those modes of mquuy themselves.Bose, P. (2000) The Rise ofthe New Grassmots in the Ckyoqaot Soand and the Namaah VaLlls,.
Source: Summit (Simon Fraser University)
Author: Jacqueline Gullion
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2128467256
