Terumi Mukai and the Riddle of Deleterious Mutation Rates
Year: 1999
Type: review
Abstract: DURING the 1960s and 1970s Terumi Mukai and colleagues conducted some experiments that have had a major impact in population and evolutionary genetics. Their quest was to estimate the genomic rate and effects of deleterious mutations. However, recent reappraisals of their work have led to doubts about the validity of some of their conclusions. Furthermore, a renewed interest in the problem of deleterious mutations, stemming in part from these doubts and in part from an interest in the perennial problem of the evolution of sex, has led to a series of new experiments. Most biologists would agree that the majority of mutations that change protein sequences or alter gene expression are harmful, because they perturb highly adapted biochemical and physiological systems. Mutations that generate “visible” phenotypes are usually manifestly deleterious, but the deleterious nature of most amino acid changes can also be inferred from the high degree of conservation of protein-coding sequences relative to noncoding DNA. Deleterious mutations impose a “load” (selective reduction in fitness) on populations; individuals either die or fail to reproduce, because they carry harmful mutations, a process Muller (1950) termed “genetic death.” Haldane (1937) showed that the load imposed by a deleterious mutation was independent of its selective effect. This has become known as the Haldane-Muller principle and implies that the mutational load depends largely on the rate at which deleterious mutations occur over the whole genome, U. Haldane applied this principle to estimate the mutation load in Drosophila melanogaster by assuming that the mutation rate to nonlethal deleterious mutations was twice that to lethals, for which an estimate was available at the time. He concluded that populations would experience an ∼4% depression in fitness through the elimination of deleterious mutations, a “loss of fitness,” he suggested, which was “the price paid by a species for its capacity for further evolution” (Haldane 1937, p. 349). In principle, estimation of U requires an unbiased way to measure the mutation rate in a random sample of the genes in the genome. The first detailed work was carried out by Muller (1928) in D. melanogaster to estimate rates for mutations that are lethal when homozygous. Crow and Temin (1964) reviewed a large body of work on recessive lethal mutation rates; average rates are 0.0026 and 0.0046 per generation for the X and second chromosome, respectively, and imply a lethal rate of ∼0.01 for the haploid genome. However, many deleterious mutations are probably not lethal, and the rate for nonlethals could be considerably higher. One approach to estimating the mutation rate to deleterious, but nonlethal, mutations is to use information on the rate at which visible mutations arise. For loci that generate visible mutations in Drosophila, rates typically run around 10-5 (Drake et al. 1998). Assuming that D. melanogaster contains 15,000 loci, this translates to a genome-wide mutation rate of 0.15 per haploid, some 15-fold higher than the lethal rate. Paradoxically, however, mutations with visible effects occur much less frequently than lethals in genome-wide surveys (Muller 1950). The likely explanation is that genes used in assays for visible phenotypes have mutation rates higher than those of other genes, for a variety of reasons. Furthermore, many deleterious mutations do not have visible effects. We need a method that gives an unbiased, genome-wide estimate of the mutation rate for all mutations that are deleterious. Measuring rates and effects of viability mutations in Drosophila: The idea of a mutation accumulation (MA) experiment can be traced back to Muller (1928, p. 288): “if a given lot of individuals, known to contain no mutant genes at the start, is bred through a series of n generations (that is, to “Fn”), and one of the individuals of this last (nth) generation is then tested for mutant genes..., this test will reveal all mutant genes that arose in any of the preceding n generations.” Muller (1928) also suggested the use of the curly (Cy) chromosome balancer system to make large-scale mutation accumulation more feasible (see Crow and Abrahamson 1997 for a recent Perspectives). The first experiment to measure the fitness effects of a chromosome-wide accumulation of spontaneous mutations was carried out more than 30 years later by Mukai, working with lines of Drosophila at the National Institute of Genetics, Mishima, Japan (Mukai 1964). Mukai’s design made use of the Cy/Pm balancer chromosome system to maintain a wild-type second chromosome protected from selection in the heterozygous state for several tens of generations. The wild-type chromosome (+) was replicated, so the random accumulation of spontaneous mutations leads to divergence between chromosome lines for a measurable phenotype and, if mutational effects are directional, to a change in the mean phenotype. The phenotype measured by Mukai was a viability index, the fraction of +/+ homozygotes relative to Cy/+ heterozygotes in progeny of crosses between Cy/+ heterozygotes (Wallace 1956) (Cy is homozygous lethal). Mukai carried out assays with several vials in each chromosome line and so could partition the variance in viability between and within lines at different generations to obtain an estimate of the rate of increase of genetic variance per generation, Vm. The surprising observation, however, was that mean viability declined at the high rate of ∼0.4% per generation. The rate of erosion in viability extrapolated to the haploid genome was in excess of 1% per generation, excluding lethals and severe detrimentals. Mukai’s principal aim was to obtain information on the rates and effects of polygenic mutations that underlie the changes in mean and variance for viability. To do this, he turned to formulae of Bateman (1959) that relate the observed changes of mean and variance to the chromosome-wide mutation rate, U2, and average deleterious mutation effect, s¯, ΔM = U2s¯, and Vm=U2s‒2(1+C2), where C is the coefficient of variation among mutational effects (Crow and Simmons 1983). If C is assumed to be zero (i.e., a model of equal mutation effects), an estimate for U2 is ΔM2/Vm, and an estimate for s¯ is Vm/ΔM. Mukai calculated that a minimum of ∼0.14 mutations per generation with viability effects of ≤3% was required to explain the change of mean and variance of the second chromosome lines. Mukai subsequently moved to the University of Wisconsin, where, encouraged by James Crow, he repeated his 1964 experiments (Mukai et al. 1972). Distributions of relative viability at four generations in one of three sets of lines studied are shown in Figure 1. There was a build-up of lethal-bearing chromosomes at a rate similar to the first study (∼0.006/second chromosome/generation). Chromosomes with severely reduced viability (detrimentals) accumulated at a frequency similar to that of the lethals. As with Mukai’s earlier study, the most striking result was the drop in relative viability of the remaining “quasinormal” chromosomes, at a rate of about 1% per generation, when extrapolated to the whole genome. Also at Wisconsin, Ohmi Ohnishi, as part of a study of the effects of the chemical mutagen ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), investigated the viability effects of spontaneous mutations in a design similar to Mukai’s. The results were qualitatively similar to the two earlier studies, although the rate of mutational decay of the quasinormal chromosomes was somewhat lower (Ohnishi 1977). A summary of the findings from these three studies, along with a series of later experiments, is given in Table 1. Estimates of rates and effects of deleterious mutations (per haploid genome) Estimates from MA experiments are all based on models of equal effects. Approximate standard errors of confidence limits are given, where available. Band-morph amino-acid-altering mutation rate in protein coding sequences. Amino-acid-altering mutation rate based on divergence between melanogaster and obscura groups. Assumes an independent estimate for nucleotide mutation rate (see text). Band-morph amino-acid-altering mutation rate in protein coding sequences, assuming 38% of amino acid mutations are deleterious (see text). Amino-acid-altering mutation rate based on divergence between humans and chimpanzees. Estimates of rates and effects of deleterious mutations (per haploid genome) Estimates from MA experiments are all based on models of equal effects. Approximate standard errors of confidence limits are given, where available. Band-morph amino-acid-altering mutation rate in protein coding sequences. Amino-acid-altering mutation rate based on divergence between melanogaster and obscura groups. Assumes an independent estimate for nucleotide mutation rate (see text). Band-morph amino-acid-altering mutation rate in protein coding sequences, assuming 38% of amino acid mutations are deleterious (see text). Amino-acid-altering mutation rate based on divergence between humans and chimpanzees. Taken together, Mukai and Ohnishi’s experiments imply that most individual flies will contain one new, mildly deleterious mutation with an effect of the order of a few percent, but the mutation rate could be very much higher and the mean mutation effect lower if mutation effects varied. Mukai and Ohnishi’s results on the genomic deleterious mutation rate in Drosophila have been the only data available for the past 20 years, have been highly influential in evolutionary genetics, and figure frequently as parameters in population genetic models (see, e.g., Charlesworth and Charlesworth 1998). —Distributions of line means for relative viability in Drosophila melanogaster at four generations (t) of mutation accumulation, replotted from Mukai et al. (1972) (CH lines). Mutation rates in Drosophila protein-coding genes: Mukai’s 1977 experiment on spontaneous mutation rates at enzyme loci in Drosophila, carried out at North Carolina State University, clearly presented a challenge to the earlier results on rates of polygenic mutation for viability (Mukai and Cockerham 1977). The experiment involved the maintenance of 1000 Cy/+ second chromosome lines for 175 generations, followed by a search for new electrophoretic (band-morph) variants at five enzyme loci located on chromosome 2. Like many of Mukai’s experiments, this experiment was carried out on a grand scale. After more than 1.6 million allele generations, in total three new variants were detected, a mutation rate of Assuming chromosome genes, the mutation rate for is, However, a study of the lines an generations with two loci million allele no new mutations et al. A later study by et al. with a different of lines and enzyme loci million allele also no mutations. The mutation rate estimate for the two surveys is confidence of et al. The inferred chromosome mutation rate is, This is an because the genes by Mukai and colleagues are than Drosophila genes in in the an average of A estimate for chromosome is, and this translates to a haploid genomic rate of a figure the minimum of mutation rates to viability The mutation rate was higher than the mutation rate, but is likely that this was because of of the in the lines by Mukai and Cockerham and Mukai et al. In the other of et al. that five out of were with the of a a We can that would not have the mutation the be with high rates for There are several for the between the MA and the of their estimate for the mutation rate, Mukai and Cockerham concluded that the majority of the viability mutations observed in the earlier have coding sequences. the in the noncoding of the Drosophila melanogaster genome is and of that is protein the Drosophila genome is in and contains 15,000 genes et al. which are on average in that all mutations are deleterious and that deleterious mutations are as in the noncoding as in coding DNA. these the genomic deleterious mutation rate would be a figure that is about with the minimum deleterious mutation rate from MA experiments have assumed that the noncoding is the of as and this to be sequences, and much than in Drosophila and that the of mutations by selection is much lower than the of amino-acid-altering mutations. make that mutations at a rate inferred from the mutation rate can explain the minimum for viability mutations. mutations do not occur at a high rate to make the et al. and 1998). A for could explain the between the estimate of U from MA experiments and studies, are to generate changes other than they can generate deleterious mutations. To do this, need to occur at and effects of a few In the of the second chromosome lines investigated by Mukai et al. out the that had and Mukai However, are many other of in Drosophila, and that crosses to the of several has accumulated over the last et al. and and The for which is are usually or The not be with the balancer per but to be to is and for many generations et al. effects that are large et al. carried out an experiment to measure the fitness effects of in the X chromosome of Their estimate for the mean effect of a was As by et this is to the for viability effects of spontaneous mutations A second line of that can generate mildly mutations from work in The of of lines independent et al. is similar to the of viability in the Drosophila balancer The average fitness effect of a was at Crow and Simmons also that in a of can to an frequency of of the balancer chromosome relative to the et al. 1977). viability is measured as relative of to this could be if the of with time. There is no that a in MA experiments. about the has been suggested that some of the in fitness of the quasinormal lines in Mukai and Ohnishi’s experiments be in this was a large in the fitness of the quasinormal lines a large increase in the suggested that this was with a model in which the effects of new mutations from a a effect is in the the in viability of the quasinormal lines in an experiment of Ohnishi, and in a more recent spontaneous MA experiment and was not as as in Mukai and Ohnishi’s MA experiments. The most explanation for Mukai and Ohnishi’s results from a later Drosophila MA experiment et al. observed that expression is and heterozygotes be from only if an chromosome is If the of an to expression over the relative viability of wild-type chromosomes would to over time. However, is some that the in fitness of the MA lines by Mukai is Mukai (1964) and Mukai et al. (1972) used an to obtain viability viability lines in generation were used to lines at generation for use as the the assumed to be from new mutations. Mukai’s in his 1964 for the last generation was probably the remaining data imply similar to those inferred D. could be a large in the mean viability of Mukai’s but not a large increase in the is that the of mutation effects is in to a of mutations with large be a much of mutations with very effects. The mutations with effects could to a in mean viability a large increase in the could be in a (see and could explain the qualitatively different of line means for viability observed by in his study mutation accumulation There has been renewed interest in rates and effects of deleterious mutations, and the experiments Drosophila The MA experiment in a has been by and from a lines were by for more than generations. selection deleterious mutations with higher in lines than chromosome balancer mildly deleterious mutations in at the of the when and viability are deleterious mutations are to be As a a population of large of the was the idea that deleterious mutations would be by selection at a higher in a large viability declined relative to the at a rate of only about per generation Bateman of U (per haploid genome) and are and et al. The estimate for U is, more than lower than those by Mukai and et al. have the results from a chromosome MA experiment in Drosophila carried out over generations with a design similar to Mukai and but in they assays of three populations at large of second chromosome homozygotes to the declined at a rate to that observed by Mukai and However, genetic variance for viability three to five and the rate of lethal mutations was higher. Bateman of U to the whole haploid genome) and s¯ are and The in these experiments are not they do not the of to the from the of mutations or a in mean fitness from a build-up of deleterious mutations that will at although et al. not changes in the viability of populations or population genetic is that were in et lines A different design of MA experiment in Drosophila lines has for the rate of in fitness from mutation accumulation et al. although has been about changes in fitness can be to mutation et al. et al. MA experiment in a different has been by et al. but were with fitness of a and carried out an MA experiment in which lines were for fitness with a so with an not for of between of one per In and showed that the majority of mutations with effects would be the mutations with effects 1% or less would as and be fitness of the lines declined by in generations, and variance also (1959) the lower for U was and the for s¯ was This MA estimate for U can be with a estimate based on the rate of spontaneous mutation per rates of mutation for or that the spontaneous mutation rate per in is a figure with from experiments The genome is of which is and the or et al. The relative of and between imply that of amino-acid-altering mutations are deleterious The fraction of that change an amino acid if is so an estimate of U in is = The MA estimate is, about lower than the to among effects of new mutations. Deleterious mutations in noncoding and mutations are not in the In two MA experiments carried out over generations and and generations and individual of the wild-type were in each generation, and populations were used as The results from the two experiments are qualitatively For in the of rate for U are and and for are and For Bateman are similar to if equal mutational effects are For other Bateman and are more but agree with each other between experiments and also have standard with mean among for U of in experiments and The of U are one to two of lower order of than Mukai and Ohnishi’s for a part of the between the rates can be by the in the of per generation, about three lower in than in However, the most striking between the Drosophila and MA experiments is the much drop in mean of the quasinormal lines over a of generations, the of lines were similar and This between the and Drosophila experiments be by which with in lines than in chromosome balancer because selection a higher fraction of deleterious mutations than mildly deleterious mutations. of mean and variance in by lines mutations with deleterious the mutations with effects have had a much not have and and this could explain the in between the Drosophila and MA lines. of mutation accumulation experiments and MA experiments have information about the rate and nature of deleterious mutations, their major is that they or no information about mutations with very effects. mutations of effect are as as mutations of large effect in for the mutation load by a mutation is independent of the of selection and mutations can have effects on genetic variation through selection than mutations et al. Mutations of effect can in an MA experiment because fitness assays in experiments are selection the of any mutation with an effect than the experiments can fitness of only most probably have population than and the majority of deleterious mutations could be in an MA —Distributions of line means for rate in two MA experiments. from data on from and by of Charlesworth The measure is the mean for lines with four each a of from and The measure is the mean for lines with five each one this more variance than a measure based on of approach to estimate U is to use The method is in the of some 30 years the mutations are either they have no fitness or they are deleterious. at a rate the nucleotide mutation rate, selection at a rate where is the of mutations that are so is the that are deleterious. estimate of the of mutations that are deleterious in a of can be by the rate of evolution in some to that of a This is an if have been mutations. The idea of data and James Crow earlier in this and Crow out a for estimating U by random of the genome in two the rates of evolution in these random to that in a they that would be to estimate the average of mutations that are deleterious over the whole genome, and U. the data required for this approach were not available. However, and have been to part of the with and its relative random of the genome to the where they an that in a of they inferred that about of the in and were with of the in The results imply that about of all mutations in the genome are deleterious. are no of the per nucleotide mutation rate in so they could not estimate U. A of and idea is to estimate U for protein-coding sequences by assuming that mutations are the rate is, an estimate of the nucleotide mutation rate. The of mutations that are deleterious can be from the of the to the = a an estimate of the deleterious mutation rate per nucleotide over the of the rate is the divergence of the species This can be to a genomic per generation, if the and of genes in the genome are and are available for the generation and the divergence time. We this for humans and that on average had been mutations each generation in the haploid genome the from and that of those were deleterious and are likely to be for several because deleterious mutations that occur protein-coding sequences are not The approach to estimating U is not its If an independent estimate of the nucleotide mutation rate is not as is the then estimate the nucleotide mutation rate from and this means that need an estimate of the generation and the of divergence of the species Furthermore, many divergence have been from data and the so is a of In an independent estimate of U can be from to the effect of to from the and on rates of mutation et al. In of an three mutations were in allele a mutation rate of confidence to of amino acid mutations change which implies a haploid mutation rate of This is to the from In the study that the of mutations that were deleterious and by selection was only 38% in so the estimate for U is a estimate of U in Drosophila with from MA and the method to Drosophila is by selection on et al. selection can the rate of and to an of the nucleotide mutation rate. rates for Drosophila genes, from the divergence between the melanogaster and obscura which are to have 30 million years The mean rate is and the mean rate is If that the Drosophila genome contains 15,000 genes of average and that Drosophila generations a estimate that the mutation rate for Drosophila is per haploid per generation, of which are deleterious. The estimate of the of mutations is lower than the from the per If estimate the rate from the of genes with the assumed to be the the Table the of in Drosophila and other that have been Mukai’s experiments. In Drosophila the by over an order of with the given by Mukai and colleagues considerably than all other the of U given by Mukai and colleagues is that they but for the reasons. The experiments by and and et al. that Mukai and colleagues probably the mutation rate to mutations of effect (i.e., the mutations in an MA or was in Mukai’s lines. However, the and divergence are because they do not mutations coding or mutations by The of in noncoding of the genome that of the deleterious mutations occur in noncoding this means that the deleterious mutation rate by mutations in Drosophila is likely to be the rate to that approach those by Mukai and The of U and given by Mukai have been and used by However, is from Table that they have only very For all but have of U for protein-coding sequences, and they by several of from at to humans at also to considerably with humans and few mutations with Drosophila and and is a between and the mutation rate, will generate variation in the deleterious mutation rate. Muller was one of the first to an interest in deleterious mutations. principal interest was the mutation load in a that has renewed Crow has that need to be that and have on genetic As selection is some populations will deleterious mutations, to a on population at if the to and is We that humans have a high deleterious mutation rate, but the of selection in populations will on the of fitness effects of new mutations, and information from an assuming Mukai’s estimate of the average selective effect of deleterious mutations in Drosophila, Crow and et al. have that populations genetic within a of time. However, if is variation among selective as likely given the MA and of U in then the average selective effect is a as is likely genetic humans and species the effects of mutation load on an evolutionary is also an
Source: Genetics
Authors: Peter D Keightley, Adam Eyre-Walker
Institutions: University of Edinburgh, University of Sussex
Language: English
Subfield: Genetics
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2131157758
