Work

Avian Habitat Management Meets Conspecific Attraction: If You Build It, Will They Come?

Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: The essence of management for any animal, including birds, is habitat management. Even with endangered species that require intensive measures such as captive breeding, successful habitat management is ultimately judged by the successful release and subsequent establishment of these species in their appropriate natural or restored habitat. In the earliest days of wildlife management, the focus was on manipulating habitat disturbance regimes (such as forest succession or grassland burning) to provide the appropriate habitats for the target species, often with an emphasis on maximizing the edge between different habitat stages (Leopold 1933). Because the focal species were mostly game species that preferred edge habitat, little effort was put into categorizing habitats once they matured past the early successional stages. As late as the 1980s, many wildlife management schemes tended to lump mature forest habitats and their resident species into a single category of “mature forest,” with the implication that diversity in these habitats was low and their resident species of somewhat less value, reflecting the focus on harvestable species prevalent at the time (Faaborg 1980, Noss 1983). Of course, good birders knew that mature forest involved a variety of microhabitat types supporting diverse species, depending on variation in habitat structure and composition. James (1971) and James and Shugart (1970) were the first to measure the structure of a bird's habitat and describe it using multivariate statistical techniques. James's methodology quickly spread through the ornithological world, and habitat structural measures are a part of most research projects even today. Her work initiated what one might call the “era of habitat structure,” as quantitative habitat suitability index (HSI) models for many species were developed (Kahl et al. 1985). The logic behind these models was simple: by knowing the detailed habitat structure required by a target species, forest managers could manipulate habitat to favor such structures and, thus, that species. For example, in parts of Missouri, mature oak forests protected from fire develop thick understory growth that is preferred by Kentucky Warblers (Oporornis formosus); with fire, the understory disappears and Ovenbirds (Seiurus aurocapilla) become common. In the late 1980s, a focus on forest fragmentation and the development of landscape ecology reduced the use of HSI models. Fragmentation studies began to show how, despite the occurrence of acceptable habitat according to the HSI models (Robbins et al. 1989), area-sensitive species disappeared from a location as habitat size was reduced. Studies incorporating landscape- and local-level effects demonstrated that the severity of the local response to patch size could be modulated by landscape-level factors, such as amount of habitat in the area surrounding the study site (Donovan et al. 1997). Demographic studies accentuated the effects of fragmentation by showing that many bird species living in fragmented habitats were not producing enough young to sustain populations (Robinson et al. 1995), which supported concepts of regional population regulation and source-sink models (Pulliam 1988). Perhaps because the broad landscape approaches painted such a bleak picture for bird populations, managers in fragmented regions may have believed that attempts at detailed habitat manipulations for target species were futile. Only recently have studies shown that populations of many species living in fragmented landscapes respond to both local habitat structure and regional habitat distribution (Howell et al. 2000, Thompson et al. 2002). Habitat models, including HSI models, now incorporate both local- and landscape-scale effects in these models (Marzluff et al. 2002, Larson et al. 2003). This trend culminated in what are now called hierarchical models that combine a variety of spatial scales from the tiny vegetation plots of James (1971) to broad landscape patterns (introduced by Kristan and Scott [2006]). A special section in The Condor (volume 108, 2006) highlighted these hierarchical models. An underlying assumption in avian habitat management is that if the manager can provide habitat with appropriate structure at all relevant scales, the target bird species will find and use it. Many of us call this the “Field of Dreams” hypothesis, referring to the movie of that name in which the character played by Kevin Costner hears a voice saying, “If you build it, they will come.” Costner's character builds his baseball field and long-dead ballplayers show up, though it takes a while, and not all humans can see the ballplayers, which perhaps has parallels with current Ivory-billed Woodpecker (Campephilus principalis) management. Several recent observations have made it clear to us and others (Parker et al. 2005, Fletcher and Miller 2006) that we may need to reconsider the Field of Dreams hypothesis. Avian social behavior may be working in such a way that birds do not always use all available sites with optimal habitat structure for breeding. We suggest that some formerly confusing patterns of habitat selection might become clearer with a broad reconsideration of the behavior behind habitat selection in birds. For years, members of the Avian Ecology Laboratory at the University of Missouri, Columbia, have discussed the problem of measuring and modeling habitat selection while conducting a variety of studies on avian responses to habitat fragmentation. Three patterns in the data puzzled us: (1) some large forest fragments did not support otherwise abundant migrant birds (Hayden et al. 1985); (2) sex ratios were heavily male-biased in the smallest populations occurring in fragments (Gibbs and Faaborg 1990, Van Horn et al. 1995); and (3) young male Ovenbirds that did not attract a mate all season were as site faithful as successful males, whereas males that failed in what we assume were multiple attempts dispersed the next year (Porneluzi and Faaborg 1999). For example, in a five-county survey for Ovenbirds in mid-Missouri, we found that our smallest populations had at least five males, even though some of these populations apparently did not attract a female all summer (Van Horn et al. 1995). Some of our ideas about habitat selection have recently crystallized after seeing the experiments of Ward and Schlossberg (2004) on conspecific attraction in the Black-capped Vireo (Vireo atricapilla). They used playbacks of song at sites they believed were empty in previous years and had immediate and sometimes impressive responses: 73 individuals established territories on the five experimental sites in the first year. Because many of these birds were successful and returned to the site the following year, song playbacks were necessary in these sites only once. This experimental evidence demonstrates that a cue, such as presence of conspecifics, may play an important role in the habitat-selection process by attracting individuals and stimulating them to establish adjacent territories (Muller et al. 1997, Parker et al. 2005). This response, commonly known as conspecific attraction, suggests that some birds, in the process of selecting habitats, may also be cueing in on singing males rather than searching only for an appropriately structured breeding site. The success of Ward and Schlossberg's (2004) study, and observations that Baird's Sparrows (Ammodramus bairdii), along with many other species of grassland birds, tend to exhibit clumped distributions across the landscape (Green et al. 2002), prompted M.A. to conduct a similar experiment with the Baird's Sparrow in North Dakota (Ahlering 2005). She played back song on three sites at each of two locations where Baird's Sparrows had not been observed the previous two years. Males colonized three of the six playback sites and none of the control sites. The three colonized plots had one, two, and three males for a total of six individuals establishing territories for the duration of the breeding season. Although these numbers seem low, the densities on these small experimental sites (9 ha) were comparable with the natural low-density situation observed in many species of grassland birds (Cody 1985). Habitat assessment indicated no difference in structure between the control and experimental plots. The willingness of a few Baird's Sparrow males to establish territories adjacent to, and countersing with, the playbacks suggests that conspecific attraction may be influencing their habitat-selection decisions and that this response might be elicited in both grassland and forest birds. Conspecific attraction is known to occur in colonial-nesting species and has been used in management of seabird populations for several years (Kotliar and Burger 1984, Kress and Nettleship 1988, et al. et al. we focus on the of conspecific attraction for even in this the of conspecific attraction is not on habitat selection in birds that and were many bird species, with observations on the by many social behavior and habitat selection have been somewhat and discussed some of habitat they on used by birds to on habitat selection and In et work on and et work on supported the use of conspecific attraction as a for In North studies on a diverse of species have demonstrated some support for the use of conspecific attraction in or (Muller et al. 1997, et al. 2003). In the that of the recent work on migrant bird ecology and the of these patterns for birds, though few of the on this have on his Although are of the of the role of behavior in use and and et al. the role of social conspecific attraction in the process of habitat selection is to be in the and management of birds. Many for the of conspecific attraction and they are often not and 1988, et al. have demonstrated the of establishing a that an a that to of territories habitat is not many of the recent for conspecific attraction in birds can be in two (1) the use of other birds as a of about habitat and (2) the to Males may use as a of about previous or current habitat et al. 2002, and 2005). birds may use birds as a of about habitat have that following such may or the of the and successful males are to be (Porneluzi males could use these males as an of habitat structural habitat This be most for males that may be less in breeding habitat. In Ward and Schlossberg (2004) that Black-capped a of the experimental population than in the population as a In species with low of such as many species of grassland birds and et al. may be cueing on males that may have about types of habitat for breeding from previous even though they are not from that even low of may be enough to in males that in a year can use the breeding success of other birds as a of by success of at the of the breeding season et al. and 2003). This of conspecific attraction is known as conspecific attraction or and has been shown to occur in some species et al. 2002, et al. et al. may use the previous breeding success to successful in the following breeding as in the studies some birds, with no previous breeding may use about the location of across the landscape at the of the breeding season to establish territories in the following year. song playbacks with in et al. recently demonstrated that use about the location of at the of the breeding season in decisions their first breeding season the following year. and the playback study with suggest that for some species, conspecific at the of the breeding season can be into the habitat-selection decisions of birds the following year. Conspecific attraction also could be by the to work with conspecific attraction has on the of in an to and et al. et al. and This response may be by males that to establish a adjacent to to their for or by that to mate with males in an rather than males in an to their for In these males may a in of early in may be in years if they enough to become males preferred by local Several studies have developed the of of and species Fletcher and Miller As we to about conspecific attraction, use in will become may be habitats available that only need an to attract populations and establish resident birds to as natural to the In these manipulating the population into using available habitat may be a than the amount of available habitat. In species where conspecific attraction is habitat may not be enough to a Some of the social by males may be necessary to a male to at a even if the only is such patterns because of conspecific attraction, may be where the occurrence of conspecific attraction may patterns of avian distribution and provide a of local or regional populations through a of habitat management and we some management of conspecific attraction for as we in the is we do not about the of this the behind it, and the effects the use of this in management may have on the population as a We suggest that conspecific attraction is an important of avian behavior to we of our of habitat and the of habitat. Of the of studies on responses to habitat all show diversity of species with in part because some species are only on fragments of a size or area were a focus of studies in the et al. less important as the to regional landscapes and source-sink (Pulliam 1988). The most area-sensitive species the were often which that these species could such between breeding and The these often at the that a forest that not support a species, though it to have for of For example, in the 1980s, a survey for Ovenbirds in Missouri, found several forest that were than the observed area of species occurrence and to have habitat, Ovenbirds the evidence that conspecific attraction may be important for some species the of conspecific attraction on these sites could the local of these species. with the fragmentation process these empty sites. if resident birds were and across the landscape fragments that did not support any breeding birds be empty following the of surrounding habitat. if all fragments had some breeding birds, small fragments with of local might also In both the of any males faithful to these sites could them empty for The need for an established male to attract other males the structure of and source-sink models once local has by what is the and conspecific attraction could the of habitats across the landscape by and of empty habitats and to habitats and 1990, et al. and Parker et al. 2005). In populations that are small or or both be most to all males and or in a year through a habitat patch an of that species on to that site the following Although these small populations may most often successful males to the site of their previous it is to that found that Ovenbirds returned to their at the as successful males, which may these populations also that males that failed all summer tended to a of years of could also to an empty habitat the that a population the edge of the habitat is in the which often will not establish a of the habitat Van Horn et al. 1995), large habitat fragments could species, which has been shown in studies of area (Hayden et al. et al. the to which conspecific attraction may these patterns of area of occurrence Although the of conspecific attraction might an acceptable habitat to a species for some conspecific in a natural population may rather as population size and the of males an of the behind conspecific attraction or effects after the of breeding males on an it is to any of that might occur with to the behavior of conspecific the of adjacent to others as population size or do these some of rather are important that need to be a bird conspecific attraction with the of habitat-selection could the of habitat use in large is that birds use a variety of both social and to if are an important of a optimal habitat for that species might both habitat and social For example, if birds use as a to success they may be to use a of habitat to the of next to Although we of few studies to a that birds habitat selection to be other birds, studies at other of habitat use have where a population size a landscape to have in individuals using territories with a of habitat The of Baird's Sparrow habitat use at a site in the of the distribution suggests that males at this site establish territories in a of habitats to be (Ahlering 2005). Habitat use was for three different populations of Baird's Sparrows in North Dakota and and the of habitat use for all was the in the site with by the of birds. that Baird's Sparrows in North Dakota a conspecific attraction response to this suggests that birds may their habitat to establish a A study in the habitat of the suggests a similar In this we have been an experiment on the effects of forest management on bird populations et al. 2003). The study with study of all of which supported mature forest and all of which were for birds for five years the was not because the study had few of the that the species for We on only all study sites mostly along In three of the sites had by management of the three sites had an amount of by and of and three sites were as with no et al. 2003). Because both types of to populations both sites the next few years, with both at their the control sites no in numbers for the first two years, with five the of the years despite no in the habitat on these sites. In all the were adjacent to one the involved were not As local populations breeding apparently to use habitats that had been for a perhaps because of the of a part of this other species that abundant in the by forest Vireo (Vireo and in the control sites et al. which suggests that we be about this the of these it that in populations may be some in the habitat we could show that a of intensive habitat a target species also to use habitats in the total population with spread a we important for management, even if we did not the behind it. such a be of for we also need to the effects of these manipulations on the of these the to is by the to we may need to we habitat suitability for species. a bird's be a between the appropriate habitat structure and we need to back and our data to see the to which the in on the parts of the control sites to the As several studies of birds in habitats have shown a of territories that to be of variation in habitat structure and the from habitat patterns is we with the of this behavior and such as observations of conspecific attraction are mostly in rather than assume that attraction is we need to do the appropriate for patterns that show of species that do not do not use conspecific attraction as an important part of their habitat-selection even if a species this be by conspecific For example, recent work by and the of in forest at spatial scales and after for the effects of vegetation species territories in at least one spatial and were at all This trend suggests that only about the species show that could be by the other experiments by with a species observed to that presence was not important to involved in the habitat-selection process could in territories conspecific attraction as a For example, several recent studies have shown that many forest breeding birds their habitat use to some of vegetation after or breeding et al. et al. 2000, 2005, et al. 2005). In at least two species that this habitat our experimental work has shown that they seem to breeding territories that their structural habitat of mature forest that are in to this habitat, which is used by both young and after breeding. In the experiment we found that both the and have their breeding territories in such a way that they are to large such as et al. This to breeding densities has in densities from such and the has our control which are from any habitat, even though these sites have little in the past Studies of in the that was an in as and through the forest for these sites et al. whereas living in fragments in did not have to to find habitats are part of and did not show a similar in 2003). A from these studies is that may have success they from and other habitats required by the young after Although this of a habitat may seem different from the conspecific attraction the is that we have a local in distribution where breeding birds seem to be in some locations and or from structured sites where they formerly a at a large could be to a distribution to the attraction we in this we can see that a to has been to the other structural that a habitat may be part of the selection process to young through the Perhaps we all species that have shown patterns by conspecific attraction to see for these distributions can be In few species have been for the of habitats for and birds, this may be in patterns and may even regional population have been to other For example, the has been shown to be of et al. 1995), including such sites as in and 1988). et al. have developed a to this that the effects of on in this where reduced to which to which to low We suggest that a the and of forests in the where mature forest next to has become to a in is that are from and in if you forests or in that you can find In this example, it is clear that the appropriate habitat is important for all species, and it is that we to our of habitat selection and use for all and stages of their as in the past we our of breeding habitat to both local structural and regional landscape we now for some species, a habitat is the breeding and both the structural of this habitat and to the breeding site may be these locations are we may see of are these to conspecific attraction or on a which both optimal breeding and a the evidence suggests that conspecific attraction may play a role in habitat selection for some species and that habitats may that require some of to attract and establish The of this response has been for some endangered species through presence or on a local and Ward and Schlossberg our of the and of such manipulations to all the populations of a species is from a of breeding birds is a if empty habitats are empty for good such could be we need to we do not with these manipulations and attract birds into habitats where they have little of breeding We have discussed where conspecific attraction may be important in large populations and might patterns of habitat we the that some distributions that to from conspecific attraction may of breeding birds an habitat used in the season. managers to manipulate conspecific attraction in populations and at spatial scales, we in the in our about the of this response and of species, the of in to of habitat and the behind these of conspecific attraction is occurring with it is important to focus on optimal habitat, if males are using other individuals as about habitat if males to because of social such as the that birds use both habitat and other and attraction may need to be in these As an of if birds are using the presence of as a in selecting breeding habitat, it is also that birds use this response to habitat on the of conspecific attraction total populations will require research at spatial scales than with even several recent studies have that some birds may both conspecific and habitat et al. Fletcher is to all the involved in a bird's of habitat and the study of such behavior will be at the spatial For example, Fletcher to different habitat-selection and their effects on and bird distribution in different distributions that could to for the effects and of different habitat-selection in the As studies of habitat selection have the from habitat at a local to the landscape and even the regional we have a of these different scales habitat selection and the recent in observations and evidence that social may habitat selection for it clear that we need to to incorporate these social in our habitat-selection As development in avian populations that are and we will have to be as as with the This may that we the you build and the and the that occur with the will part of the As the ideas in this have been discussed by members of the Avian Ecology Laboratory at the University of for two We all past members and data have to this The was by members of the including and Fletcher and Thompson also an early of this we and for to that in this We to working in this field we were not to in our for current
Source: The Auk
Language: English
Subfield: Ecology
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2133648901
FWCI: 6.576
Cites: 76
Cited by: 183
Related to: 10