Work

Ice. II. A proton-ordered form of ice

Year: 1964
Type: article
Abstract: Ice II, one of the high-pressure polymorphs of ice, of density 1.17 g.cm -3, has 12H~O molecules in a rhombohedral unit cell with a = 7-78 A, a = 113.1 °.According to the Laue symmetry shown in single-crystal photographs, the space group should be either R3m, R3m or R32.Centrosymmetry is indicated by a statistical test with essentially three-dimensional intensity data.However, the Patterson function indicates a pseudo-structure in space group R3c.The true structure must be appreciably distorted from this because of moderately strong violation of the c-glide extinction condition.The distortion could degrade the space group to /~32, but the resulting structure has unsatisfactory features, and does not conform well with the experimental data.Structural reasoning indicates space group R3.The observed R3m Laue s:~nnmetry must therefore be the result of intimate twinning of Rg individuals.The structure in R3 can be refined, under the assumption of twinning, and with the inclusion of hydrogen atoms, to R = 0.08.The basic R-3c structure contains ice-I-like units built out of puckered 'six-rings' of water molecules.These traits are linked together in a more compact way than in ice I.Each oxygen atom is bonded to four nearest neighbors at 2.80 + 0.04 A, and has in addition a next-nearest neighbor at 3.24 _~.The distortion of the true structure ~ from the pseudo-structure leaves the bond lengths essentially unaltered but changes the bond angles appreciably.It constitutes evidence that the hydrogen atoms are in ordered arrangement in the crystal, rather than disordered, as in ice I.The particular ordered arrangement actually realized can be deduced from detailed features of the structure.This arrangement gives better agreement with the X-ray data than any other, although the X-ray distinction among various arrangements is necessarily marginal.The ordering energy in ice II, formulated in terms of the H-bond strain, must involve significantly the effects of both donor-and acceptor-misorientation.The accepter strain energy contribution is formal to depend primarily not on deviation from tetrahedral bond orientation relative to the accepting H20 but on deviation from the 'accepting plane' that bisects the H-O-H angle of the molecule.The H20 environment in ice II deviates greatly from an ideal tetrahedral one, yet the H-bond strain energy, although greater than in ice I, is small enough to be offset by the extra van der Waals energy, so that the energy of ice II is only 0.01 kcal.mole-1 greater than that of ice I.The measured entropy difference between I and II is a direct reflection of the entropy of proton-disorder in ice I. * Bertie et al. (1963) have recently reported a unit cell determination for ice II, obtained by methods very similar to those used here, and in agreement with the above results.
Author: B. Kamb
Language: English
Field: Chemistry
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2133894222
FWCI: 6.701
Cites: 25
Cited by: 183
Related to: 10