Work

Political Science since World War Two: Americanization and Its Limits

Year: 2010
Type: book
Abstract: Many histories can be told of political science.Some start in classical Athens. 1 Others start in the Scottish Enlightenment. 2 But if we are specifically interested in political science as one of a set of institutionally differentiated disciplines that together make up contemporary academic social science, it was born in America early in the twentieth century.3 The prominence of America then and now may seem to point to a narrative of Americanization.However, we will argue that this narrative needs tempering with recognition of the influence of Europe on America and the way in which different traditions modify ideas adopted from elsewhere.The history of political science is one of contingent transnational exchanges in which ideas are appropriated, modified, and transformed.The direction and extent of the transnational exchanges varies across different aspects of political science.While the Americanization narrative may appear plausible in the case of the institutions of political science as an autonomous discipline, it becomes hard to sustain once our focus shifts to intellectual history.When we look at the British case, for example, we will argue that: new empirical topics arose in political science from exchanges in which British figures played as great an initiating role as Americans; new quantitative techniques were more commonly developed in America and then adopted in Britain, but they were modified in the process of adoption; and the postwar history of American political science has been dominated by new theories -from the positivist theories of behavioralism to rational choice theory -that had little impact on British political science. The Institutions of Political ScienceAmerican scholars pioneered the institutions of political science an autonomous discipline.In 1903 they founded the world's first national political science association, the American Political Science Association (APSA), and in 1906 the young association began a journal, the American Political Science Review (APSR).The association had rapid and noteworthy success in attracting members.An initial growth spurt took it from a membership of 204 in 1904 to 1462 just over a decade later in 1915, and membership subsequently doubled during the interwar decades to cross the 3000 mark by the early 1940s (Somit and Tanenhaus 1967: 55, 91).In their home universities and colleges, members of the APSA took the lead in forging departments devoted to political science understood as a field apart from history, philosophy, law, sociology, and economics.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W213410149
FWCI:
Cites: 30
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10