Work

Cosmoclimatology: a new theory emerges

Year: 2007
Type: article
Abstract: Data on cloud cover from satellites, compared with counts of galactic cosmic rays from a ground station, suggested that an increase in cosmic rays makes the world cloudier. This empirical finding introduced a novel connection between astronomical and terrestrial events, making weather on Earth subject to the cosmic-ray accelerators of supernova remnants in the Milky Way. The result was announced in 1996 at the COSPAR space science meeting in Birmingham and published as “Variation of cosmic-ray flux and global cloud coverage — a missing link in solar-climate relationships” (Svensmark and Friis-Christensen 1997). The title reflected a topical puzzle, that of how to reconcile abundant indications of the Sun's influence on climate (e.g. Herschel 1801, Eddy 1976, Friis-Christensen and Lassen 1991), with the small 0.1% variations in the solar irradiance over a solar cycle measured by satellites. Clouds exert (on average) a strong cooling effect, and cosmic-ray counts vary with the strength of the solar magnetic field, which repels much of the influx of relativistic particles from the galaxy. The connection offers a mechanism for solar-driven climate change much more powerful than changes in solar irradiance. Cosmic rays (relativistic electrons) stirring in the Cassiopeia A supernova remnant make the wispy blue lines of energetic X-ray emissions seen by NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory. (NASA/CXC/UMass Amherst/M D Stage et al.) Cosmic rays (relativistic electrons) stirring in the Cassiopeia A supernova remnant make the wispy blue lines of energetic X-ray emissions seen by NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory. (NASA/CXC/UMass Amherst/M D Stage et al.) During the past 10 years, considerations of the galactic and solar influence on climate have progressed so far, and have found such widespread applications, that one can begin to speak of a new paradigm of climate change. I call it cosmoclimatology and in this article I suggest that it is already at least as secure, scientifically speaking, as the prevailing paradigm of forcing by variable greenhouse gases. It has withstood many attempts to refute it and now has a grounding in experimental evidence for a mechanism by which cosmic rays can affect cloud cover. Cosmoclimatology already interacts creatively with current issues in solar—terrestrial physics and astrophysics and even with astrobiology, in questions about the origin and survival of life in a high-energy universe. All these themes are pursued in a forthcoming book (Svensmark and Calder 2007). The comparisons of data on clouds and cosmic rays, with which the story began, continued to pay off. They confirmed that cloudiness is more clearly linked with solar-modulated galactic cosmic rays than with other solar phenomena such as sunspots or the emissions of visible light, ultraviolet and X-rays (Svensmark 1998). A big step forward came with the realization that the lowest clouds, below about 3 km in altitude, respond most closely to variations in the cosmic rays (Marsh and Svensmark 2000), a counter-intuitive finding for some critics (e.g. Kristjansson and Kristiansen 2000). Figure 2 compares data from the International Satellite Cloud Climatology Project and the Huancayo cosmic-ray station. There is no correlation at high and middle altitudes, but an excellent match at low altitudes. At different levels in the atmosphere (high >6.5 km, middle 6.5–3.2 km and low <3.2 km) the blue line shows variations in global cloud cover collated by the International Satellite Cloud Climatology Project. The red line is the record of monthly variations in cosmic-ray counts at the Huancayo station. While there is no match at the higher altitudes, a close correspondence between cosmic rays and clouds low in the atmosphere is plain to see. (Marsh and Svensmark 2000) At different levels in the atmosphere (high >6.5 km, middle 6.5–3.2 km and low <3.2 km) the blue line shows variations in global cloud cover collated by the International Satellite Cloud Climatology Project. The red line is the record of monthly variations in cosmic-ray counts at the Huancayo station. While there is no match at the higher altitudes, a close correspondence between cosmic rays and clouds low in the atmosphere is plain to see. (Marsh and Svensmark 2000) In figure 3, the correspondence between low clouds and cosmic rays is seen to persist over a longer timescale. A simple interpretation is that there are always plenty of cosmic rays high in the air, but they and the ions that they liberate are in short supply at low altitudes, so that increases or decreases due to changes in solar magnetism have more noticeable consequences lower down. As in figure 2, the low-cloud comparison extends over a longer period. As in figure 2, the low-cloud comparison extends over a longer period. The involvement of low-level clouds provided an experimental opportunity. The chief objection to the idea that cosmic rays influence cloudiness came from meteorologists who insisted that there was no mechanism by which they could do so. On the other hand, some atmospheric physicists conceded that observation and theory had failed to account satisfactorily for the origin of the aerosol particles without which water vapour is unable to condense to make clouds. A working hypothesis, that the formation of these cloud condensation nuclei might be assisted by ionization of the air by cosmic rays, was open to microphysical investigation by experiment. In 1998 Jasper Kirkby at the CERN particle physics lab in Geneva proposed an experiment called CLOUD to investigate the possible role of cosmic rays in atmospheric chemistry. The idea was to use a beam of accelerated particles to simulate the cosmic rays, and to look for aerosols produced in a reaction chamber containing air and trace gases. The temperature and pressure would be adjustable to simulate conditions at different levels in the atmosphere. Kirkby assembled a consortium of 50 atmospheric, solar—terrestrial and particle physicists from 17 institutes to implement it (CLOUD proposal 2000), but regrettably there were long delays in getting the project approved and funded. The go-ahead eventually came in 2006 and the full experiment at CERN should begin taking data in 2010. Meanwhile, in Copenhagen, the discovery that low-level clouds are particularly affected by cosmic-ray variations suggested that a simpler experiment, operating only at sea-level temperature and pressure, might capture some of the essential microphysics. Instead of a particle beam, we used natural cosmic rays, supplemented by gamma rays when we wanted to check the effect of increased ionization of the air. Our team set up the experiment in the basement of the Danish National Space Center, with a large plastic box containing purified air and the trace gases that occur naturally in unpolluted air over the ocean. Ultraviolet lamps mimicked the Sun's rays. During experiments, instruments traced the chemical action of the penetrating cosmic rays in the reaction chamber. We called the experiment SKY, which means “cloud” in Danish. By 2005 we had found a causal mechanism by which cosmic rays can facilitate the production of clouds (Svensmark et al. 2007). The data revealed that electrons released in the air by cosmic rays act as catalysts. They significantly accelerate the formation of stable, ultra-small clusters of sulphuric acid and water molecules which are building blocks for the cloud condensation nuclei. Figure 4 shows a typical run. Vast numbers of such microscopic droplets appeared in the air of the reaction chamber, and their production increased proportionately when we used gamma rays to induce more ionization (figure 4, bottom). The speed and efficiency with which the electrons do their work of stitching molecular clusters together took us by surprise. It is a mechanism previously unknown in meteorology and it brings the cosmos into climate studies in a precise microphysical way. Creation of the building blocks of cloud condensation nuclei (top) under the influence of galactic cosmic rays is seen in a typical run in the SKY experiment in Copenhagen (Svensmark et al. 2007). At time 0 a burst of UV light (simulating solar UV) triggers the formation, from trace gases in the air, of sulphuric acid molecules shown by the blue area and the right-hand scale. Within 10 minutes, great numbers of molecular clusters of sulphuric acid and water molecules larger than 3 nm appear in the reaction chamber (black curve and left-hand scale). The red curve is the fit of a simple model combining rates of production of clusters and their loss on the walls of the chamber. The lower diagram shows the linear relation between ion density and aerosol nucleation. Red stars are the experimental data. In the real atmosphere, in the absence of walls, the clusters would grow in a matter of hours to become cloud condensation nuclei. Creation of the building blocks of cloud condensation nuclei (top) under the influence of galactic cosmic rays is seen in a typical run in the SKY experiment in Copenhagen (Svensmark et al. 2007). At time 0 a burst of UV light (simulating solar UV) triggers the formation, from trace gases in the air, of sulphuric acid molecules shown by the blue area and the right-hand scale. Within 10 minutes, great numbers of molecular clusters of sulphuric acid and water molecules larger than 3 nm appear in the reaction chamber (black curve and left-hand scale). The red curve is the fit of a simple model combining rates of production of clusters and their loss on the walls of the chamber. The lower diagram shows the linear relation between ion density and aerosol nucleation. Red stars are the experimental data. In the real atmosphere, in the absence of walls, the clusters would grow in a matter of hours to become cloud condensation nuclei. Low-level clouds cover more than a quarter of the Earth and exert a strong cooling effect at the surface. (For clouds at higher altitudes there is a complicated trade-off between cooling and warming.) The 2% change in low cloud during a solar cycle, as seen in figure 3, will vary the input of heat to the Earth's surface by an average of about 1.2 W m-2, which is not trivial. It can be compared, for example, with 1.4 W m-2 attributed by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change for the greenhouse effect of all of the additional carbon dioxide in the air since the Industrial Revolution (Houghton et al. 2001). If cosmic-ray counts merely up and with the cycle of solar there would be no in the of influx to the Earth's surface to changes can be seen in the of formation of such as or from the Sun's open magnetic As seen in figure the that there was a in cosmic rays in the such that the the of the were to the seen This was in with the discovery that the Sun's magnetic in strength during the et al. in the flux of galactic cosmic rays since are from 10 and open solar flux and cloud from figure 3, is and to cosmic-ray data from for the to 2005 that are to with The change in the average flux is as large as the one solar The change in forcing by a change in low cloud over this can be to W in the flux of galactic cosmic rays since are from 10 and open solar flux and cloud from figure 3, is and to cosmic-ray data from for the to 2005 that are to with The change in the average flux is as large as the one solar The change in forcing by a change in low cloud over this can be to W is evidence for that much of the of the world during the was due to a in cosmic rays and in low-cloud cover. between and causal action has always a in climate The for climate change during the on the that of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases increased and so global to that in the record the greenhouse forcing (e.g. et al. have than By the that changes in cloudiness to cosmic rays to climate change a that is in as an that the Cloud have a high and exert their cooling effect by into the cosmos much of the that could the surface. the on the are with a higher than the cloud cloud cover the and cloudiness Satellite the effect of clouds on and meteorologists at it by has an but it is and not so conditions in are to the climate of the is by in the and the air. The cosmic-ray and that temperature changes in should be in to changes in temperature in the of the This is is in a that some have called the but for which climate a (Svensmark 2007). account for evidence many of from in and which many of climate change in on of While they might be possible for climate with of they begin to the of the climate from to as seen in the (figure Cloud forcing is by the most of the on all absence of the would have a cloud forcing — which a of into climate The climate during the past is in this comparison of the surface temperature for the and from the The data have over to the temperature The blue and red lines are to the data. The are by for they would and (Svensmark The climate during the past is in this comparison of the surface temperature for the and from the The data have over to the temperature The blue and red lines are to the data. The are by for they would and (Svensmark Figure the climate record years, rates of production in the atmosphere as for cosmic-ray The high at with the when sunspots were and the solar magnetic was This with the of of climate call the plain is the of the The and the seen in figure between and are a of a between high and low cosmic-ray of a that has in the in the as by on the from and is a of the climate data now of and over the past years, there were many the — to on how the in the density of with of which the most were the and the A comparison with variations in and production excellent between high cosmic rays and and low cosmic rays and the et al. 2001). these was evidence for they called solar many other of astronomical in climate et al. the cosmic rays merely as of the magnetic of the in a and solar irradiance. cosmic rays a the of how small changes in irradiance could exert so big an influence the that the cosmic rays act on the climate more by was set of and of the of and use to solar and variations in the the climate changes of the have the cosmic-ray and were already of a that the cosmic rays were not the et al. 2001). They had evidence from in the when the in have a failed of the the effect of the field, the cosmic-ray influx increased In a the counts of and produced by cosmic rays up by more than no cooling The result was the climate — and — came from the of as the This of the climate to the cosmic-ray variations was was forthcoming traced the origin of the penetrating that are for most of the ionization of the air at low altitudes (Svensmark and Svensmark 2007). a and (figure from the for the and of at higher of the cosmic rays. The most cosmic-ray particles that in in the lower atmosphere the from particles that from the stars with high The magnetic of the and the Earth have effect on The Sun's magnetic the supply of a large of but are to changes in the Earth's magnetic from Svensmark and Calder 2007). of the air by cosmic rays below 2 km is due to penetrating from high-energy cosmic rays, to the (Svensmark and Svensmark 2007). The are only to the that the Earth's magnetic can example, at there is only small influence and the the increase in ionization is only the for about of the The of is subject to large changes from the galactic of the solar and variations in the The most cosmic-ray particles that in in the lower atmosphere the from particles that from the stars with high The magnetic of the and the Earth have effect on The Sun's magnetic the supply of a large of but are to changes in the Earth's magnetic from Svensmark and Calder 2007). of the air by cosmic rays below 2 km is due to penetrating from high-energy cosmic rays, to the (Svensmark and Svensmark 2007). The are only to the that the Earth's magnetic can example, at there is only small influence and the the increase in ionization is only the for about of the The of is subject to large changes from the galactic of the solar and variations in the of the penetrating from of such high that they are even to the solar magnetic of low to be by the account for only of the it is that the of the field, in or full should have effect on climate compared with changes due to solar On the other hand, are produced higher in the atmosphere, by cosmic rays of lower that are more to variations in the they for cosmic-ray changes due to solar as in figure for example, can no longer be as to cosmic when the or the galactic This article so has the evidence for the role of cosmic rays, which of variations of low cloud cover with cosmic-ray evidence for the microphysical mechanism cosmic rays accelerate the production of cloud condensation The climate as a of forcing of climate by climate variations over of that match the variations in production by cosmic that an with this we can the of space and time to the of cosmic rays to climate change since the Earth was The of the Sun's variations on are seen the and more changes in climate become on longer when the galactic of the solar changes and the variations in the cosmic-ray flux are an of than due to the to and between and are in the record of the past into the paradigm to to account for these but the was There were between and conditions during the of atmospheric carbon dioxide and and and A more from which the to with of the Milky blue stars and cosmic rays are more an at the in this interpretation The of the with to the solar the galactic was but found that a fit with the in of found evidence the with high cosmic in a cycle of of the of by with a of the and the of to the a large on as seen in figure and The between and are as from to conditions during the are shown in variations of in They with with of the Milky and the increases in the cosmic-ray flux and from to conditions during the are shown in variations of in They with with of the Milky and the increases in the cosmic-ray flux and to to to to The to is a matter of the to have so when that that was was by of of as The evidence for was published in a story should become as the data is of a the greenhouse theory of climate on the other hand, the was carbon dioxide in the atmosphere were high at the The of the have due to the carbon dioxide et al. or to a of the the and data can to the astronomical of the galaxy. the in were in the water they in effect, cosmic-ray the flux changes as the of the changes by the of the record shows changes in temperature with the Sun's about the galactic and the set on the (Svensmark The or so with a of the cosmic rays are most and it is by The of the affect the Sun's and they are different and the Figure an of the Milky and the Sun's for the past one of numbers the galactic of the to match the climate changes by the during that period. The of the seen in a of from astronomical but from a of The Sun's to the over the past is by changes in the The most and were at and data cooling of the Earth the the galactic cosmic rays are most these the data shown in can be (Svensmark The Sun's to the over the past is by changes in the The most and were at and data cooling of the Earth the the galactic cosmic rays are most these the data shown in can be (Svensmark The discovery of widespread in the during the in the Earth and set a for climate be is not only might have such events, but they when they when the Earth was and of was there a long between with no seen in the past cosmoclimatology a cosmic that to it in the of formation in the Milky with close with the have affected the cosmic-ray flux to the of the increased of — as for example, in As for the in that the Earth with the in the Milky since the Earth was in a In data from et al. formation at the during the by a when the to of it is can the long in the when to the failed to cosmic rays to the data a of the in time for the Earth events, more came from and a as the of formation during the past 2 and on for the Earth years, to when the and Earth were the is the Earth was not The Sun's to the model of solar than of the Earth's surface temperature should have than there is evidence for water and the of are found in from an This of the has for more than solar suggest a of cosmic rays Svensmark a more solar the would have the influx to such a small of the in the the Earth would not have had much cloud cover. would for much of the of the solar and so the from greenhouse gases. A of this line of is a new on the of life over (Svensmark By combining about the of the to cosmic rays with data on the one can the cosmic-ray Figure 10 compares the with data from an different in the of the by the of in The in between and with the cosmic-ray during the when formation was and cosmic rays were the was in This a link more than idea a climate or a climate It be to the of trace in conditions Svensmark life about the cosmic-ray flux was of the of the solar life and to during global which with high cosmic rays linked to high The red curve shows the of variations in the of the which was most when the cosmic-ray flux was (Svensmark and life about the cosmic-ray flux was of the of the solar life and to during global which with high cosmic rays linked to high The red curve shows the of variations in the of the which was most when the cosmic-ray flux was (Svensmark and density of speed 1.4 km of the Milky from in Earth's temperature during the to the solar the Milky it is to by astronomical The is in the seen in other The speed is the of the The past 10 have seen the of a new area of by a small of The of cosmoclimatology is a and an for many lines of The between different of science is no of but at the of from the astrophysics of the of the into which the solar has The that cosmic rays from a supernova the of was by et al. This is of of the of some by and the of The from or not the by et al. was are to the to supernova during the past climate change on that is to be of the and of the should the climate connection over longer of and can be to make a big At the the on Earth to of climate with an to match the and of et al. different in and should and be of great to and The changes in the Earth's and up in the record of at high They for the greenhouse and cosmic-ray of climate change. in temperature the to cosmic-ray do not the to conditions to an from in the or in the account for high rates of with on in atmospheric carbon dioxide 2000) and changes in et al. In Copenhagen we to use simple climate of the to and sea-level account for variable or climate forcing by clouds or greenhouse gases. The physics of the and the the story on all from the Earth to the the be about the of cosmic rays and greenhouse gases in current and climate there is an to solar by of the magnetic at the Sun's There are already strong that taking cosmic rays into account should to the of the The of cosmic rays and climate from more investigation of aerosol by to the for and the for the set by it now that and magnetism are in the origin and of life on are the galactic and The of Earth us that survival was a even
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2135709148
FWCI: 16.95
Cites: 27
Cited by: 276
Related to: 10