Year: 1994
Type: article
Abstract: Native Americans and the Appropriation of Cultures JOEL MONTUREJ_)uRiNG THE SPRING of 1991 I was a guest of the Brighton Festival of Literature in England as part of a ten-day Native American residency.My hosts, sensing my homesickness, took me to a Pow-wow in Uckfield, a small town surrounded by rolling fields of yellow mustard, country pubs, and history.It was a scene, however, transported from America-a sprawling brick elementary school, linoleum hallways, a gymnasium for the dancers, traders with booths, a fry bread concession, and the sound of drums reverberating through the corridors.There was beadwork for sale, and the songs were high northern style (Lakota), and women in traditional Plains dresses were making a tremolo as they ringed the host dance drum in the center of the arena.The dancers wore outstanding regalia, including full eagle-feather war bonnets and antique moccasins, and they carried sacred pipebags.In every aspect I might have been in Bismarck or Anadarko or Calgary, but this was England, and beneath the painted faces were sunless complexions and cockney accents.It wasn't real Native America, but rather a foreign "virtual reality" of cultures and lifestyles that continue to survive despite acculturalization, racism, and assimilation.It was also an appropriation of culture -a Halloween farce with little intrinsic value or meaning beyond the surface exploitation.Here were people playing "Indian" in much the same way minstrel shows once portrayed African-Americans for the amusement of themselves and others, with the accompanying stereotypes.Moreover, it is an affront to Native people when sacred objects are in usage outside of their traditional environments-objects such as pipes, fans, rattles and drums, which are being appropriated by "New Age"
Source: Ariel
Author: Joel Monture
Language: English
Subfield: Anthropology
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2137594539
