A gender analysis of the Land Redistribution for Agricultural Development (LRAD) Programme : a case study in Mpumalanga Province, South Africa.
Year: 2009
Type: dissertation
Abstract: After 1994, the South African government prioritized land reform as a strategy for \ndevelopment in order to redress the legacy of apartheid, while contributing to national \nreconciliation, growth and development. The government with endless persuasion from \ngender activists, non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and interested individuals \nacknowledged the crucial role that women could play in transforming its society. As a \ncommitment to gender equity, it ratified various international conventions and national \ndeclarations, including in 1995, the United Nations on the Elimination of all forms of \nDiscrimination against Women (CEDAW). Subsequently, a variety of institutions and \ngender divisions (units) in the country were established to advise, monitor and implement \ngender mainstreaming programs within government departments, NGOs and parliamentary \nstructures. These include amongst othersthe Office of the Status on Women (OSW), The \nCommission on Gender Equality (CGE) and gender focal points. \nIn 1995, a delegation of South African women led by politicians participated in the Fourth \nWorld Conference on Women in Beijing. In response to this report, the Department of \nLand Affairs (DLA), together with other government departments, committed itself “to \ntake legislative and administrative measures to give men and women equal rights to \neconomic resources, including access to ownership and control over land and other \nproperties, credit facilities, natural resources and appropriate supporting technology” \n(DLA, 1997:18). Despite these commitments, the South African government in general and \nthe land sector in particular was criticised for contradicting its intentions. These were \nevident in policy development processes. An example widely documented was the \ncontroversies and compromises which were made by the ANC led government during the \ndevelopment of the Communal Land Rights Act of 2004 (Walker, 2005; Hassim, 2005; \nClaassens 2003). In addition, the land policies, including the DLA Gender Policy, have \nbeen widely criticised by several researchers (Hall, 1996; Mann, 1999; Walker, 2002; \nClaassens, 2005). The common trend was the scepticism of whether these policies would \nachieve their intended gender equity goals. Amongst others, weaknesses of these polices \nwere the poor conceptualisation of gender and the lack of clarity on the government’s \n2 \ngender equity intentions and outcomes. These would make it difficult to translate policies \ninto practice. This study investigates whether these assertions are valid. \nThe focus of the research is the analysis of the Land Redistribution for Agricultural \nDevelopment (LRAD) Programme which was established in 2001. Using a project located \nin Mpumalanga Province, called the Mathebula Communal Property Association, the study \nevaluates the implementation of this programme. The project is located near Rock’s Drift \nin the Mbombela Municipality about 6 kilometers from White River on the White River- \nNelspruit road (R40). It is amongst the first projects to be administered by the provincial \nDLA, under the new LRAD programme. This property was used for chicken and smallscale \npig farming. The location of the project is of significance because the Mpumalanga \nprovince is amongst the most rural poverty stricken provinces in South Africa with a \npopulation of approximately 3 million. According to May (2000: 22), about 45% of the \nindividuals in this province are living in poverty. The study was undertaken during the presettlement \nstages. The main goal was to investigate the DLA commitment to its gender \npolicy through a case study. In addition, it explores the relationship between the primary \nbeneficiary, a rural woman named Aida and the DLA officials during the research period. \nThis is a means to assess whether Aida was empowered through these processes, as per the \nLRAD policy statements. The study draws its theoretical basis from a Gender Analysis \nApproach. This analysis recognises in every context that it is relevant to determine the \ngender-based division of labour and to understand the forces that constrain this division or \nact to change it. This framework was useful in collecting data tool for this study. The study \nuses a case study methodology. This research strategy has been chosen because of its \nability to offer an “in-depth analysis of a case so as to interpret its unique features and to \nsolicit an understanding of the social arrangements and their existence” (Ragin, 2000:24). \nThe case study approach has shown that without investigating the processes which occur \nwithin these projects, the real impact of land reform on the beneficiaries’ lives is far from \nbeing realised. \nThe major findings of this research revealed that whilst South Africa has put in place \nseveral national legislative frameworks to address gender equity in general, women still \nstruggle to access resources through government systems. Aida, the main driver of this \n3 \nproject, experienced 4 years of insurmountable problems whilst trying to acquire a farm she \nhad identified from a willing seller. The research revealed that Aida’s determination to \nacquire the farm is attributable to her intellectual capabilities, negotiation skills and \nmanipulative tactics, which is contrary to the dominant argument that factors affecting rural \nwomen's access to land are dependent on “educational level, age, social status of the family \nand marital status” (Moser, 1993; Bob, 1994)). In addition, the dynamics within projects \noften not reflected in policies are very crucial in successful implementation of projects. For \ninstance, in this project, the ‘inactive’ strategy of registered members reduced conflict \nwithin the project such that Aida became the sole owner of the project and was able to \nsuccessfully acquire the farm without any interference from the other members. \nOverall, a significant contribution of this case study to the SA women’s empowerment \ntheoretical framework is the identification of the external and internal factors, some of \nwhich were specific to gender empowerment failures. These include the challenges of \ntargeting women, access to information, lack of accountability on gender as well as the \nabsence of strong social movements. Lastly, the study also revealed unintended outcomes \nas a result of the lengthy period of the pre-land transfer stage, issues which are normally \nignored and undocumented. Studies of land reform (and development) projects in \nMpumalanga province and throughout SA have revealed similar findings as outlined \nthrough this document. These findings raise key questions that have broader implications \nfor LRAD, and land reform program in general. \nThe study acknowledges that there are examples of women in Mpumalanga province and \nmaybe in other parts of the country who may have had positive experiences through the \nsame program. However, it also confirms findings by earlier studies done by different \nresearchers and thus raises critical questions with regards to the implementation and \nsustainability of the LRAD projects in South Africa, specifically in the Mpumalanga \nProvince.
Author: Nomvuselelo Cynthia Songelwa
Language: English
Topic: Land Rights and Reforms
Subfield: Soil Science
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2144301647
