Predicting juror decisions : the impact of judicial admonitions and moral reasoning
Year: 1997
Type: article
Abstract: Ninety-five university students and members of the community completed Gibbs' Sociomoral Reflection Measure (SRM), which is designed both to assess moral reasoning levels and to distinguish between autonomous and heteronomous reasoners, then viewed and made judgments about a criminal trial concerning doctor-assisted suicide.Autonomous jurors were more likely than heteronomous jurors to find the defendant not guilty.Autonomous jurors given nullification instructions were more likely than autonomous jurors given standard instructions to advocate acquittal.Heteronomous jurors rarely advocated acquittal, regardless of the type of instructions they received.Higher stage reasoners advocated acquittal more frequently than lower stage reasoners did.The linear combination of autonomy/heteronomy, type of instruction, and moral reasoning level served as the best predictor of juror verdicts.Qualitative data gleaned fiom jury deliberations revealed that autonomous jurors tended to evoke all three types of autonomous judgment--balancing, fundamental valuing, and conscience--to argue for acquittal.These results partially support the hypothesized relationship between moral thought and jury nullification.
Source: Summit (Simon Fraser University)
Author: Philip Laird
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2146533343
