Year: 2012
Type: review
Study designs: Systematic Review, Meta-Analysis
Abstract: The assessment of physical activity in healthy populations and in those with chronic diseases is challenging. The aim of this systematic review was to identify whether available activity monitors (AM) have been appropriately validated for use in assessing physical activity in these groups. Following a systematic literature search we found 134 papers meeting the inclusion criteria; 40 conducted in a field setting (validation against doubly labelled water), 86 in a laboratory setting (validation against a metabolic cart, metabolic chamber) and 8 in a field and laboratory setting. Correlation coefficients between AM outcomes and energy expenditure (EE) by the criterion method (doubly labelled water and metabolic cart/chamber) and percentage mean differences between EE estimation from the monitor and EE measurement by the criterion method were extracted. Random-effects meta-analyses were performed to pool the results across studies where possible. Types of devices were compared using meta-regression analyses. Most validation studies had been performed in healthy adults (n=118), with few carried out in patients with chronic diseases (n=16). For total EE, correlation coefficients were statistically significantly lower in uniaxial compared to multisensor devices. For active EE, correlations were slightly but not significantly lower in uniaxial compared to triaxial and multisensor devices. Uniaxial devices tended to underestimate TEE (-12.07 (95%CI; -18.28 to -5.85) %) compared to triaxial (-6.85 (95%CI; -18.20 to 4.49) %, p=0.37) and were statistically significantly less accurate than multisensor devices (-3.64 (95%CI; -8.97 to 1.70) %, p<0.001). TEE was underestimated during slow walking speeds in 69% of the lab validation studies compared to 37%, 30% and 37% of the studies during intermediate, fast walking speed and running, respectively. The high level of heterogeneity in the validation studies is only partly explained by the type of activity monitor and the activity monitor outcome. Triaxial and multisensor devices tend to be more valid monitors. Since activity monitors are less accurate at slow walking speeds and information about validated activity monitors in chronic disease populations is lacking, proper validation studies in these populations are needed prior to their inclusion in clinical trials.
Institutions: Universitair Ziekenhuis Leuven, KU Leuven, Centre for Inflammation Research, University of Edinburgh, Royal Brompton & Harefield NHS Foundation Trust, NIHR Royal Brompton Respiratory Biomedical Research Unit, Imperial College London, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Thorax Foundation, Center for Research in Environmental Epidemiology, Novartis (United Kingdom), Johns Hopkins University, University Hospital Zurich
Language: English
Topic: Physical Activity and Health
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,177
Funders: Pfizer, AstraZeneca, Chiesi Farmaceutici, European Respiratory Society, Royal Brompton and Harefield NHS Foundation Trust, European Federation of Pharmaceutical Industries and Associations, National Institute for Health and Care Research, British Lung Foundation, Imperial College London, Fonds Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek, KU Leuven, Universität Zürich, Innovative Medicines Initiative, Vlaamse regering
Award: G8826675077
OpenAlex ID: W2160638979
