The state, Mapuche communities, and multicultural social policy: a comparative study of three intercultural hospitals in Chile
Year: 2006
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Multicultural social policy in Latin American countries surfaces as a new form of \nsocial policy reform aimed at 1) reforming social sector reform in order to reduce the cost \nand increase the effectiveness of the service; and 2) expanding citizenship of indigenous \npopulations. This new way of delivering social services invites different actors into the \nsocial programs. In this dissertation, I examine how multicultural social policy actually \nworks in the ‘local’ arena, where participants struggle, vie and negotiate with each other. \nI also address the impact of interactions among actors on social policy. \nTo do so, I look at three intercultural hospitals which had different levels of \nparticipation from communities, the state, and NGOs. While Makewe Hospital was run \nby a Mapuche organization, Nueva Imperial Hospital launched a state sponsored \nintercultural health program. Nueva Extremadura Clinic installed an intercultural health \nprogram implemented by NGOs. These different types of interactions among actors \nemerged in the three cases and ultimately shaped each of the programs. \nIn Makewe Hospital, where there was strong participation from communities, the \nprogram had better results in expanding cultural rights as well as in increasing the \neffectiveness of the program. However, the strong participation from communities did \nnot necessarily transcend into sustainability of the program. With strong state \ninvolvement in the program of Nueva Imperial Hospital, there was tension between the \nstate and the communities, which resulted in limited improvement of the quality of the \nservice and the expansion of cultural rights. However, the state sponsorship provided the \nprogram sustainability. In the case of Nueva Extremadura Clinic, the effectiveness and \nflexibility of the program increased significantly but the program did not have any impact \non the expansion of the cultural rights of local Mapuche population. \nThese findings show that the constant negotiation and struggle among these actors \nultimately shape the content of the policy and its outcomes. Multicultural social policy as \na state action is not uniform and has diverse implications for multiculturalism, depending \non the actors involved and their capacity for independent actions.
Author: Yun-Joo Park
Institution: The University of Texas at Austin
Language: English
Subfield: Anthropology
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2164267315
