Year: 2003
Type: article
Abstract: Many studies of sexual selection have focused on the role of ornaments in mate choice (see Andersson 1994, Espmark et al. 2000). Birds have been a favorite taxon for those studies because of the prevalence of conspicuous ornaments, including brightly colored feathers, skin, and bills, and dramatically elongated feathers or feathers of elaborate structure. The colors of avian ornaments are the result of carotenoids, melanins, tissue structure, or some combination thereof. Carotenoid ornaments (e.g. bright reds, oranges, and yellows) have generated much interest. Those pigments can not be synthesized de novo by animals, but rather must be included in the diet (Brush 1990). That allows for the possibility that they are limited in nature or difficult to obtain (Hill 1994, 1996; Hudon 1994; Linville and Breitwisch 1997). Additionally, carotenoids have been implicated in a variety of critical physiological functions in animals. That recognition has stimulated much recent research on mate choice of carotenoid advertisement and the indicator value of carotenoid ornaments for several important aspects of individual condition. Avian melanin ornaments have also received considerable research attention. In contrast to studies of carotenoid ornaments, however, the primary focus of studies of melanin ornaments has been on the advertisement of melanin “badges” in intrasexual competition. Thus, the associations among expressions of melanin ornaments, mate choice, and individual condition have not been made to the same degree as for carotenoids. There are several possible reasons for that. First, melanins not only color ornaments but are also the basis of most inconspicuous appearances (i.e. camouflage), in contrast to the highly conspicuous carotenoids. Second, melanins are synthesized by animals and thus do not need to be included in the diet. Finally, it is perhaps incorrectly assumed that melanin ornaments are typically black or blackish-brown and thus show both less variation within species and less diversity across species than do carotenoid ornaments. Here, we review a variety of aspects of the biology of avian melanin ornaments. We demonstrate that the color diversity of melanin ornaments is quite broad, including red (e.g. Red Junglefowl and Barn Swallow [Hirundo rustica]), orange (e.g. Red Junglefowl), yellow (e.g. Western Tanager [Piranga ludoviciana]), and green (e.g. Mallard), in addition to black and brown. Color differences in all melanin ornaments are, in part, a function of the ratio of the two types of melanins contained, and we outline the intriguingly different metabolic pathways to the formation of the two different categories of melanins. There are likely to be both significant physiological benefits and costs to melanin production, and those may well differ for the two types of melanins. Finally, we address new avenues of investigation concerning melanin ornaments in the context of sexual selection. All melanin-colored ornaments contain a mixture of the two types of melanin, eumelanin and pheomelanin. The reflectance spectrum of the ornament is, in part, a function of the ratio of the two types of melanin in feathers (Haase et al. 1992, 1995; Prota et al. 1995; Shiojiri et al. 1999). Additionally, the absolute amount of eumelanin is important, because its presence may overwhelm the contribution of pheomelanin to the reflectance spectrum. The two types of melanin have different spectral qualities (Sarna and Swartz 1998). Eumelanin is perceived by humans (and presumably by birds) as black to dark brown, whereas pheomelanin is perceived as light brown, buff, dull red, orange, and yellow (Prota et al. 1995). Some pheomelanin pigments have the potential to produce brighter reds, oranges, and yellows than may typically be thought to be due to melanins (e.g. the bright orange feathers of Red Junglefowl; J. Hudon pers. comm.). A field guide to the birds of any geographic region shows quite clearly that ornaments of such colors are widespread. Despite that diversity, investigators have focused predominantly on black to brown eumelanic ornaments (Table 1). Species in which melanin ornament expressions have been measured and correlated with components of fitness. Species in which melanin ornament expressions have been measured and correlated with components of fitness. The question of the diversity of melanin ornaments is complicated by the findings that both melanins and carotenoids can occur in the same ornament (Hudon 1991, Saino et al. 1999; K. McGraw pers. comm.). Melanins occur in ornaments that were once considered to be pigmented solely by carotenoids, for example, the yellow feathers of Western Tanagers (Hudon 1991) (see also Stradi 1998). In addition, carotenoids have been found in what are commonly classified as melanin ornaments, for example, the rusty-orange feathers of Barn Swallows (Saino et al. 1999; see also Howell 1952, Nero 1954). Reflectance spectra (and color perception) of such mixed ornaments may well depend on both the carotenoid and melanin pigments contained. There are, however, possible technological problems in verifying that hypothesis, insofar as the carotenoid pigment contribution to the spectrum in some mixed ornaments may overwhelm that due to melanins (J. Hudon pers. comm.), or melanins may overwhelm carotenoids (Theron et al. 2001). The alternative would thus be chemical extraction of pigments from an ornament (see below) and comparison of pigment amounts to reflectance spectra for a sample of individuals. To our knowledge, no one has yet done that. Moreover, no one has evaluated mate choice as a function of pigment composition in mixed ornaments assessed in the process of choice. The examinations of potential costs, controls, and material requirements of melanin production have focused on mammals, with less research on avian melanogenesis. We therefore present findings from studies on both mammals and birds in the following discussion. Melanogenesis involves the conversion of L-tyrosine into the two types of melanin. The biochemical pathway along which L-tyrosine is converted to melanin is complex and may have significant energy costs associated with it (V. Hearing pers. comm., Fig. 1). Both end products, eu- and pheomelanin, are large, negatively charged, insoluble, nitrogenous heteropolymers. Pathways for both eu- and pheomelanogenesis (reproduced from Wakamatsu and Ito [2002] with permission from Blackwell Publishing Ltd.). Melanogenesis takes place in melanocytes, which are derived from neural crest cells (Duval et al. 2002, Han et al. 2002). Melanocytes responsible for skin, hair, and feather pigmentation are found in the basal layer of the epidermis and in hair or feather follicles (Duval et al. 2002). Melanin production occurs in melanosomes, a melanocyte-specific organelle. The two types of melanosomes are rod-shaped eumelanosomes and spherical pheomelanosomes (Wolff 2003). Melanosomes move from the melanocytes into keratinocytes and become incorporated into growing hair or feathers, thus providing pigmentation (Duval et al. 2002). Pigments in skin, fur, or feathers represent a mixture of the two types of melanins that originate from multiple melanocytes. There are at least three enzymes involved in melanogenesis that require metal cofactors. The copper-containing enzyme tyrosinase catalyzes the rate-limiting step in melanogenesis (Wolff 2003). The two enzymes Tyrp-1 and Tyrp-2 are required for eumelanogensis. The latter enzyme requires zinc, and the former is thought to require iron (Furumura et al. 1998). There are adverse health effects on birds when the diet has either too little or too much copper. Copper deficiency affects production of hemoglobin, with anemia as the result, whereas iron deficiency affects both production and maintenance of blood cells and the constituents of eggs (Arnall and Keymer 1975). The functions of zinc are not known with certainty. Whether deficiencies in those metal cofactors affect melanogenesis is also unknown. Melanogenesis begins with the oxidation of L-tyrosine and DOPA to dopaquinone by tyrosinase, the rate-limiting step in melanogenesis (Wolff 2003; Fig. 1). In addition to production of dopaquinone, tyrosinase also oxidizes two other eumelanin intermediates. Eumelanogenesis is stimulated by the binding of α-melanocyte stimulating hormone (α-MSH) to the G protein-coupled receptor MC1R (also called CMC1 in birds) in the melanocyte membrane (Takeuchi et al. 1996a, b; Bowers et al. 1997; Theron et al. 2001; Voisey and Van Daal 2002; Wolff 2003). When α-MSH binds to MC1R, levels of tryosinase, Tyrp1, and Tyrp2 increase, and levels of intracellular cysteine decrease. That favors production of eumelanin. Pheomelanogenesis occurs without α-MSH stimulation. During pheomelanogenesis, following the production of dopaquinone, cysteine combines with dopaquinone to form cysteinyldopas that are oxidized via benzothiazines to pheomelanin (Wolff 2003). During pheomelanogenesis, the enzymes important to eumelanogenesis do not increase in concentration, and intracellular cysteine levels remain high. That favors the formation of pheomelanin. Additionally, pheomelanogenesis is increased when agouti signaling protein (ASP) interacts with MC1R (Hunt and Thody 1995, Wolff 2003). Pheomelanogenesis has been suggested as the default pathway during pigment production (Wolff 2003). Presence of a default pathway is important. If there are significant differences in production costs of the two melanins, at least one production cost is nontrivial, and a changing ratio of melanin types affects the reflectance spectrum, then the expression of a melanin ornament can serve as an honest indicator of condition. It is thus important that investigators begin to examine production costs more closely, measure pheomelanin and eumelanin content in melanin ornaments, and test whether different ratios of melanins are perceptually distinct to avian vision and affect the behavior of the perceiver. The pathway of melanogenesis is complex, requiring several different enzymes and ions, appropriate amino acid precursors, a favorable pH environment, and the influence of kerotinocytes and hormones. The products of >80 gene loci are involved in melanogenesis (Haase and Schmedemann 1992; Aroca et al. 1993; Haase et al. 1995; Hearing 1999, 2000; Ito et al. 2000; Takeuchi et al. 2000; Duval et al. 2002; Hoogduijn et al. 2003). In addition to complicated controls and requirements, melanogenesis is known to produce cytotoxic byproducts that are lethal to melanocytes (Tomita et al. 1984, Thody et al. 1991, Bowers et al. 1994; R. Bowers pers. comm.). Avian melanocyte cultures can be rescued by addition of antioxidants, suggesting that the cytotoxic byproducts are predominantly oxygen free radicals (Bowers et al. 1994; R. Bowers pers. comm.). It is not known, however, whether cytotoxic chemical production in melanogenesis affects either ornament expression or the body at large. In any case, complicated pigment production may provide information concern the health, genetic quality, or condition of an individual, as has been argued for other complicated types of pigments (Arnold et al. 2002). The majority (58%) of studies on melanin ornaments cited in Table 1 measured only the size (or area) of discrete patches of melanic feathers (44 of 76 studies). Thirty-three of the 76 studies (43%) in some way measured color of melanin ornaments (including four studies that measured both size and color). Sixteen of the 33 studies measuring color recorded only gross color changes (e.g. brown vs. black), six used color chips (either Munsell or Methuen), and seven used color reflectance spectrophotometry (see below). Three studies measured melanin content of feathers. In some species, there is obvious variation in color of melanin ornaments (e.g. a gradation from dark brown to black). In such species, only gross color differences have been measured (e.g. Slagsvold and Lifjeld 1988, 1992; Sætre et al. 1995, 1997 for Pied Flycatchers). Prior to the recent introduction of portable reflectance spectrophotometers, there were few other options for measuring color differences. The newly employed spectrophotometer technology can reveal variation unapparent to human vision (Johnsen and Zuk 1996, Hill 1998, Hill and Brawner 1998, McGraw and Hill 2000, Smiseth et al. 2001, Jawor 2002). Whether that variation is perceived visually by birds must be empirically established, but obviously it is unwise to simply assume that it is not. That line of argument is even more relevant for melanin ornaments other than black, where even human vision can perceive variation. Reflectance spectrophotometry also yields measures of hue, saturation, and brightness of the color being measured (Hill 1998). Unfortunately, the correspondence between reflectance spectra (or measures of hue, saturation, and brightness) and melanin concentration or melanin ratios is unknown. In a study of Northern Cardinals, we found variation in hue, saturation, and brightness of the black face mask of males (Jawor 2002). We also measured hue, saturation, and brightness of melanin ornaments of several other species (four eumelanic ornaments and one pheomelanic ornament) and found both intra- and interspecific variability (Table 2). Those data demonstrate that, in some species, there is substantial variation in melanin color variables, whereas in others, there is essentially none (Table 2, Figs. 2 and 3). Average hue, saturation, and brightness of melanin ornament coloration of bird species. Average hue, saturation, and brightness of melanin ornament coloration of bird species. Hue, saturation, and brightness measures of eumelanic ornament coloration from three different bird species. Left vertical axis represents the possible values of hue, which can occur anywhere along a 0–360° color space. The right axis represents the possible values of saturation and brightness, which are reported as a percentage and may range from 0 to 100% saturation or brightness. Variation in pheomelanic The vertical axis represents the possible values of The right vertical axis represents saturation and brightness of measured A measure of ornament expression involves and of the pigment in the That has been done for carotenoid pigments in feathers (Hudon 1991, Stradi 1998, McGraw et al. 2001). Both eu- and pheomelanin are difficult pigments to and The most is the of the byproducts of eumelanin oxidation and pheomelanin acid (Haase et al. 1995, Ito and Wakamatsu 1998, Ito et al. 2000). That an of the two types of melanin within feathers. to be are the among melanin content and concentration in reflectance and color by and physiological condition can influence melanogenesis and thus may also affect melanin ornament on and of melanin into ornaments and changing condition. is known to affect both gross color changes in and of melanin ornaments in some species and Lifjeld 1992, and 1996, et al. but not in (Hill 2000, McGraw et al. 2002). question is whether a occurs at levels between melanin ornament expression and production of other on A has been suggested between expression of carotenoid ornaments and the need for those pigments in other 1994, et 1999). Both types of melanins are from and cysteine is for the production of pheomelanin et al. 2000). In is considered an amino acid 1996, et al. whereas cysteine is synthesized from amino acid and amino have not been considered but that to be some to birds are known to be protein and in or (Arnall and Keymer 1975). in melanin coloration in birds have been when are in protein (e.g. pers. comm.). It is not known whether levels of amino in during and ornament that amino acid may differ among that potential on melanin ornament production to be more may influence melanin ornaments by the controls of melanogenesis as well as amino acid In mammals, the of melanin by melanocytes is by an between α-MSH and et al. 1994, and Thody 1995, Hearing 1998, et al. 1997). Eumelanogenesis is by the of MC1R by whereas pheomelanogenesis occurs without α-MSH and is by (see Birds do not but rather agouti protein which has been suggested as in a to (Takeuchi et al. 2000). protein is in most in birds and is known to with hormone by and other or to and function both during of and of et al. 1999, Takeuchi et al. 2000). protein by pheomelanin production during may affect the color of melanin ornaments, thus providing information concerning an during example, the color of the black face mask in Northern is correlated with body condition in the (J. Jawor and R. Breitwisch in may health during the when the ornament is In in a study of the effects of diet on melanin coloration in McGraw et al. found that not influence brightness of melanin they not measure ratios of the two melanin types in The between and on ornament and avian to perceive differences in the ratio of the two melanins in ornaments clearly The production of cytotoxic during melanogenesis also that melanin ornaments can serve as of condition and the to physiological of oxygen free radicals in melanogenesis be in species that both melanin and carotenoid ornaments, insofar as carotenoids can as oxygen free et al. 1999). We that in such species, the two types of ornaments have a signaling can demonstrate not only to of but also to carotenoids to other physiological and of the byproducts from melanogenesis. That may the of melanin ornaments on carotenoid ornaments for example, Melanin ornament expression may be by of during during the or Melanocytes are known to for both and the effects of those two on melanogenesis are 1998). are known to affect in the of with species (Haase and Schmedemann 1992, Haase et al. 1995). example, in levels of influence the of with a more (Haase and Schmedemann to affect melanogenesis that feathers that are predominantly eumelanic in become mixed or predominantly pheomelanic in (Haase et al. 1995). In the of the black is by during et al. 1999, et al. 2000, et al. but whether the ratio of the two types of melanins is is not in with levels of a Haase 1975). There is an of in with levels of melanin in the and carotenoid and Those studies that melanin ornaments are and levels of that are important for It has been suggested that melanin coloration is by Hill and Brawner and McGraw and Hill found no of an on melanin coloration in and Additionally, Hill and Brawner found no of of on melanin In those same however, and negatively carotenoid ornament We present two concerning those First, the melanic feathers measured in Hill and Brawner were which the may not have been as an ornament and thus to be by condition. In McGraw and Hill on the other the melanic feathers were the black and likely an ornament to sexual selection. Second, melanins are derived from amino and there is no to that which affect carotenoid across the affect the of those melanin of amino is by in whereas carotenoids are by When the is by amino may be to or between carotenoids can no be pers. comm.). melanin ornaments may not be by they may be by and found that the of melanin in but the color of both melanin and carotenoid pigmentation not It has been that different types of ornaments, and different aspects of a may information on different components of condition. ornaments have thus become associated only with those qualities for which they are most and Hill and Brawner 1998, McGraw and Hill 2000). Carotenoid ornaments may thus information concerning and health of the In melanin ornaments may information concerning health, and to and intrasexual We need a of components of condition in to ornament expression to that is the We that birds both carotenoid and melanin ornaments provide more of than birds only one or the other of and and Hill have that of sexual in melanin ornaments in contrast to carotenoid ornament is sexual selection of melanin ornaments. That is on two The is that sexual selection much more on males than on (see and the is that the primary of sexual selection is mate choice. there is to question both of those First, studies on ornaments in birds and that those function both in mate choice and in intrasexual competition. Second, mate choice has been in some species, and that be in birds and If melanin ornaments function in mate choice or intrasexual then the of sexual in those ornaments not function in both of sexual selection et al. 1996, and 1998). Melanin ornaments, in to function more commonly in intrasexual than in mate choice and Hill 2000). If intrasexual occurs in both for or selection ornaments that function in both and of sexual In that the of limited in melanin ornaments is not by sexual selection but of by both from studies of melanin ornaments have suggested that those types of ornaments are of there is of It likely that some of is a result of of behavior and Birds to or do not in with In where either behavior to the new or birds were not to with and and 1998). In any case, need not condition can and on much even We that become several are ornaments are during distinct condition can potential benefits of are and the cost of is for the associated with melanin ornaments represents a cost of signaling by those ornaments. of melanin ornaments between of with melanin ornaments from that with during et al. but whether color changes is not with are to those with et al. between with can be and (J. Jawor pers. We that in addition to physiological costs of melanin production, melanin ornaments may be to in of the and energy (and of from and individuals. Those ornaments thus would the that honest be in several species is that males with melanin ornaments have et al. 1992, and 1998, et al. In some less males are also by et al. 1992, and 1998, et al. Those males are than more in of and et al. but see et al. 2002). Melanin ornaments are by in some species (see as is behavior and In behavior can be negatively by et al. 1992, and The for less presumably less or represent a for and found that is in species with sexual in the size of melanin ornaments. That that melanin ornament which is by can as a of of melanin ornaments in be relevant to mate choice in species to which the of and the in that are to as a of mate choice, need to be considered in studies melanin ornaments that is that investigators study of avian melanin ornaments. for of melanin ornaments, and investigators no simply assume that the color of eumelanin ornaments is perceived by the known of black eumelanic ornaments in intrasexual investigators to focus on the question of the types of information being by of of ornament may information on only limited aspects of and we see no melanin ornaments be as as carotenoid ornaments aspects of condition. Carotenoid ornaments may and health, whereas melanin ornaments may and or mate choice in species of and the of ornaments in those two of sexual selection is that investigators of avian a of both the components of sexual selection and the diversity of ornaments by We K. and Hill for on an of of melanins and from with We also J. J. and K. McGraw for with to the of melanin We and for field All birds were and and and of and all to
Source: The Auk
Authors: Jodie M. Jawor, Randall Breitwisch
Institution: University of Dayton
Language: English
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
Funder: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
OpenAlex ID: W2175329840
