Work

Some Common Confusions About Consent in Rape Cases

Year: 2004
Type: article
Abstract: Consent to sex matters because it can transform coitus from being among the most heinous of criminal offenses into sex that is of no concern at all to the criminal law.Unfortunately, the normative task of making the law of rape more just is commonly impaired by conceptual confusion about what "consent" means.Consent is both a single concept in law and a multitude of opposing and crosscutting conceptions of which courts and commentators tend to be only dimly aware.Thus, consent can be a mental state on a woman's part, an expression by her, or both, it can consist of facts about a woman's mental state or expressive conduct that do not necessarily constitute a defense to rape, or only such facts as do constitute a defense to rape; and it can consist offacts about a woman's mental state or expressive conduct, or a legal fiction of such facts.In so far as we are unaware of the ways in which this conceptual framework structures the way we think about consent, we risk confusing ourselves and others in undertaking to make the law of rape more just.Some examples are (1) confusion as to whether the defense of consent ought to be deemed to consist of a mental state on a woman s part or an expression; (2) confusion about the relationship between consent to sexual intercourse and resistance to it; and (3) confusion about the relationship between force and non-consent. I. COMMON CONFUSIONS ABOUT CONSENTConsent arises in various forms in law.It arises in the law of contracts in the form of promises.It arises in property law in the form of assignments of interests.And it arises in torts and criminal law as defenses to wrongdoing.These are all instances of "consent," and, as such, they share things in common.But they also contain differences--differences that can be framed in Hohfeldian terms:.
Author: Peter Westen
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2180550196
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by: 8
Related to: 10