False Positives in the Criminal Justice Process - an Analysis of Factors Associated With Wrongful Conviction of the Innocent
Year: 2003
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: During the past several years the issue of wrongful conviction has received increasing attention from state legislators, the legal system, and researchers.Much of this attention has focused on death penalty convictions which have been set aside.As of February, 2003, postconviction DNA testing in the United States had led to the exoneration of 123 wrongfully-convicted individuals.To date, it is unknown how frequently wrongful conviction occurs in the United States.Also unknown is how frequently systemic errors occur which previous research has identified as being associated with the phenomenon wrongful conviction.The present research sought to address this deficiency of knowledge by asking professionals who work in the criminal justice system their perceptions regarding these issues.A 53-item survey questionnaire was administered to four groups of Ohio criminal justice professionals: law enforcement (sheriffs and chiefs of police), prosecutors (chief and assistant), defense attorneys (private and public defenders), and judges (common pleas, appellate, and Supreme Court).The 798 respondents indicate they believe wrongful conviction occurs in 1 to 3 percent of all felony convictions.With more than 2,000,000 individuals incarcerated in the nation's prisons and jails, this error rate would signify that between 20,000 and 60,000 individuals are incarcerated for crimes they did not commit.Significant differences were found in group perceptions.Prosecutors and police perceive the least error (1/2-1%), while defense attorneys perceive the most error (4-5%).Judges perceive the national error rate to be between 1 and 3 percent.When asked their perceptions regarding nine types of system error (police error, prosecutorial error, defense attorney error, judicial error, eyewitness error, forensic error, false confessions, false accusations, and community pressure), respondents, in general, indicate they believed these types of error occur "more than infrequently," but less than "moderately frequent."Again, significant group differences were found.Prosecutors perceive the least system error, while defense attorneys perceive the most error.Police and judges' perceptions generally moderated between the two extremes.
Author: Robert J. Ramsey
Institution: University of Cincinnati
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funder: University of Cincinnati
OpenAlex ID: W2192810831
