College education and job-match quality in South Korea: An application of the Gottschalk-Hansen model
Year: 2015
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: In South Korea, 66% of youth aged between 25 and 34 have attained tertiary education in 2012, which is far above the OECD average of 39% (OECD, 2014). The high supply of college graduates leads to substantial competition. According to the Employment Trend for 2014 by Statistics Korea, the unemployment rate for the youth aged between 15 and 29 recorded 9.0%, which is more than double of the overall unemployment rate, 3.5%. The youth unemployment rate in 2014 recorded the highest level since 1999, when a new method for statistics measurement was introduced (Statistics Korea, 2014a). As well as reducing the high youth unemployment rate, enhancing the job match quality of educated labor force has been an important policy focus of the Korean government. The issue about overly educated labor force and the match quality between education and job has been actively analyzed. However, due to the vague nature of overeducation and job match quality, previous studies rely on the subjective measure of overeducation and job match quality. Gottschalk and Hansen (2003) provide a fresh look on the issue of overeduaction by introducing a simple model. They define college jobs as the ones that pay significantly high return on college education, while the noncollege jobs are defined as the ones that do not pay significantly high return on college education. This definition of college and non-college jobs has an advantage of being based on market signals such as an employer’s willingness to pay a college premium. This paper applies the approach by Gottschalk and Hansen (2003) in the case of South Korea to ask a slightly different question. It asks how 4 year college education affects job-match quality compared to 2-3 year college education. In South Korea, where the proportion of the people who have a college degree is almost double than the OECD average, this question is as interesting and important as comparing college educated workers to non-college educated workers. Making use of the Gottschalk and Hansen model, 4 year college jobs are defined as the ones that pay significantly high return on 4 year college education. A worker is defined to be well matched if she holds a job that fits her qualifications. That is, if a 4 year college graduate is employed in a 4 year college job, her job and education are well matched. In order to focus the analysis on the college graduates, this paper uses the survey data for the college graduates in South Korea, the Graduate Occupational Mobility Survey (GOMS). Using the GOMS, the job match quality of 4 year college graduates is investigated over time. Our result from log monthly wage regression shows that there is a downward trend in 4 year college premium from 2007 to 2011, which indicates that the relative advantage of 4 year college education compared to 2-3 year college education has been decreasing over time. According to the Gottschalk and Hansen model, a decrease in 4 year college premium would result in more 4 year college graduates distributed in 2-3 year college jobs. That is, the match quality between job and education would be aggravated over time. The match quality between job and education is analyzed more thoroughly by estimating the probability of 4 year college graduates working in 2-3 year college job over time using a logit model. The predicted probability of 4 year college graduates hired in 2-3 year college jobs is found to be increasing over time, which is consistent with the Gottschalk and Hansen model. Several robustness checks for our analysis are carried out in terms of aggregating occupations, different thresholds to define 4 year college jobs, subgroup analysis, and using a different earning measure. Our analysis is found to be robust to these sensitivity checks. Further analysis regarding labor market outcome of female college graduates are also discussed and shows that female college graduates are not only paid less than male counterparts regardless of the level of education, but the female 4 year college graduate are more likely to experience the mismatch between job and education than the male counterparts.
Author: Jinha Kim
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2205248787
