Work

How social comparison moderates automatic behavior

Year: 2001
Type: dissertation
Abstract: 'This thesis developed a model of Automatic Behavioral Contrast (ABC). The starting point for the theoretical argument were previous findings of automatic behavioral assimilation to stereotypes of social categories. Two prominent examples are the following effects: Activating the stereotype of the elderly leads to assimilation in the walking and reaction speed, i.e. slower behavior (Bargh, Dijksterhuis, Kawakami), and activating the stereotype of professors leads to better performance in a general knowledge task (Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg, 1998). These effects occur outside of conscious awareness. However, these results seem to contradict assumptions from theories on intergroup relations, which in general predict and find contrast from groups of which one is not a member (Turner et al., 1987). Building on the Selective Accessibility Model from Mussweiler and Strack (2000), the ABC model was developed. It argues that in addition to the assimilation effect after stereotype activation, a comparison process can lead to behavioral contrast effects. The comparison is expected to lead to contrast if it tests for dissimilarity. That is, if the comparing person actively thinks about differences between the self and the activated social category, behavior should be automatically contrasted from that category. Furthermore, the ABC model argues that a salient ingroup-outgroup distinction should suffice to start such a dissimilaritytesting comparison. This prediction was tested in 5 studies, before a corollary was tested in a sixth study. Studies 1 and 2 created the necessary ingroup-outgroup distinction by inducing an artificial categorization. As predicted, it was found that the participants automatically contrasted from elderly members of the artificial outgroup by reacting faster in a subsequent reaction time task (Study 1). Study 2 supported the hypothesis that the salient categorization moderates between assimilation and contrast by manipulating it as a second factor. Study 3 instructed the participants to compare directly to elderly persons. The results were not as predicted, since they seemed to suggest assimilation instead of contrast when the participants compared themselves to the elderly. However, additional data indicated that the effect might in fact be interpretable as a contrast, but on a different comparison dimension. Following up on this study, study 4 investigated the role of the comparison process more directly, by manipulating its direction. As predicted from earlier theorizing (Mussweiler, 2001; Tversky, 1977), it was found that a comparison of the self to the elderly lead to contrast, while a comparison of the elderly to the self lead to assimilation. Studies 5 and 6 investigated the effects of social stereotypes on intellectual performance. Study 5 found that only non-students assimilated to the stereotype of professors, while students did not. This finding is in line with the ABC model. Finally, study 6 concentrated on the impact of an ingroup instead of an outgroup categorization. Earlier theoretical models (Dijksterhuis, Spears, et al., 1998) argued that a distinct single exemplar elicits automatic behavioral contrast (e.g., thinking about Albert Einstein leads to worse intellectual performance). Modifying this assumption, it was found that a contrast from Albert Einstein was extinguished when he was categorized as an ingroup member. The present arguments and findings contribute both to the literature on automatic effects of stereotype priming and to the literature on social categorization of self and others. They show that automatic and unconscious behavior is moderated by the structure of the social environment. Behavior is not automatically assimilated to a group if this group is an outgroup.' (extract)
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2211234806
Cites: 171
Cited by: 2
Related to: 9