Work

Steps towards comprehensive Bayesian decision analysis in fisheries and environmental management

Year: 2013
Type: dissertation
Abstract: A typical decision problem in an environmental field includes a complex system with countless uncertain factors of both nature and human behavior. There are many stakeholders with conflicting objectives and a lot of decision alternatives, and results need to be communicated clearly to decision makers and stakeholders. Organized analysis is needed to tackle these challenges. In an ideal situation, we should analyze the objectives of every stakeholder and the responses from different parts of the ecosystem within one framework, which integrates the expertise and efforts of many different disciplines. Bayesian inference, especially the influence diagram, is a perfect tool to be used in such decision problems. The main contribution of this thesis is in developing methods for the modeling of uncertainties in environmental decision problems. The focus is on having more complete decision analyses where more uncertainties are realistically modeled. By including more stochastic variables in the analysis, the decision makers get a more realistic picture of the uncertainties involved and can account for them in the decision making. The thesis consists of five separate research articles, which all contribute to the different parts of the Bayesian decision process presented in this summary. The process is divided into four steps: (1.) building a decision model, (2.) data gathering and processing, (3.) using the model, and (4.) post analysis. The summary presents the research articles and their contributions and critically reviews the tools and methods needed in the process. The articles include a model for oil spill management, a spatial multispecies stock assessment model, a model for the stock assessment of data-poor species, a model to estimate uncertainties in environmental valuation and an influence diagram for value of information analysis. The methods used cover many aspects of the Bayesian decision process, outlining the problem, different ways to define prior distributions, utility functions, and finding maximum utility policies and value of information analysis. Hence, the tools used are diverse, too. In the models, I have used graphical Bayesian networks, numerical MCMC estimation, and Gaussian processes. In conclusion, the results found in this thesis are small but important steps toward better and more comprehensive Bayesian decision analyses in environmental and fisheries management. They show that significant uncertainties exist in many parts of the system. Another important factor was the cooperation of scientists from many different disciplines with a variety of backgrounds, which is needed in the modeling of complex environmental problems.
Language: English
Subfield: Aquatic Science
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2215822980
Cites: 188
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10