War, Welfare, and Unequal Citizenship: Social Rights and Ethnic Divisions after World War II
Year: 2014
Type: preprint
Abstract: This paper compares the institutionalization of ethnically differentiated social citizenship regimes in Northern Ireland and South Africa after World War II. Political sociologists disagree on whether the postwar expansion of social rights was due to changing wartime power relations (Mann 2012) or prior political institutions (Amenta and Skocpol 1988; Amenta 1998). This debate has focused on the variation of welfare state expansion in the core states of Britain and the United States, specifically the contrast between the universal NHS (Marwick 1974) and the grafting of employer-provided health insurance onto racist New Deal welfare institutions (Katznelson 2005; 2013). However, this paper tests the competing theories of welfare expansion against two ethnically divided societies on the Allied side in World War II, an autonomous region, Northern Ireland, and a dominion, South Africa. Each was dominated by ethnically exclusionary groups and experienced rapid economic and social change. Their postwar citizenship regimes and labor market institutions differed. Northern Ireland adopted British welfare legislation but grafted on residency qualifications for benefits and labor migration regulations to exclude Southern Irish migrants. Apartheid codified a cast-bound labor market, residency and citizenship regime, despite Black Africans’ proletarianization and military service. How did these cases construct exclusionary postwar welfare states and citizenship regimes? Three broad families of theoretical approach are compared. First, power-resource theory suggests that the limited social transformation of the war in these peripheral regimes precluded more universal citizenship regimes after the war. Second, historical institutionalism focuses on the majoritarian institutions of local government in Northern Ireland, and the minority franchise in South Africa. Instead, this paper builds on the neo-Weberian theory of nation state-building as a cultural compromise between state elites and their target citizenry (Wimmer 2002; Mann 1993, 1995) and Bourdieu’s theory of political fields in which actors jostle strategically for advantage with imperfect information (Bourdieu and Wacquant 1992; Fligstein 2008; Fligstein and McAdam 2012). The primary finding is that the limited transformations of the World War II deepened the political exchanges between elites and workers in the dominant ethnic groups, thickening social citizenship rights for members of the dominant ethnic groups, but strengthening categorical boundaries around those rights.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: Niall Ó Murchú
Institution: Western Washington University
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: social citizenship, welfare state expansion, ethnic inequality, citizenship regimes, Northern Ireland, South Africa, apartheid, labor market segmentation, ethnic exclusion, power resource theory, historical institutionalism, nation-state building, political field, World War II, Black Africans, labor migration regulation
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2222230241
