Human Rights and the Laws of War Under the American Convention on Human Rights
Year: 2010
Type: preprint
Abstract: This article explores questions arising out of the substantial body of jurisprudence developed within the Inter-American system of human rights relating to the application of the American Convention on Human Rights to the many armed conflicts that have occurred in Central and South America since the Convention entered into force. Two separate, but related, issues will be considered in detail. The first concerns the material scope of the Convention and, in particular, the extent to which the Inter-American Court of Human Rights and the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights can apply international humanitarian law in considering the cases or communications which come before them. The second question concerns what role international humanitarian law plays in interpreting the rights contained in the Convention. If the application of Convention rights is not prevented by the existence of lex specialis in the form of international humanitarian law, then how can the rights contained in the American Convention be applied in armed conflict situations to take proper account of the relevant principles of international humanitarian law? In response to these questions the article identifies two ways in which the Court and Commission use international humanitarian law in respect of substantive rights contained in the Convention. The first is as a means of supplementing the jurisprudence that has been established under the Convention in circumstances where doing so provides additional human rights protection for individuals. The second use is concerned with avoiding normative conflict. In this regard the Court uses international humanitarian law in the process of establishing whether a state’s international responsibility is engaged under Article 1(1) of the American Convention. After considering the different ways in which international humanitarian law is used by the supervisory mechanisms of the Inter-American system, the article concludes by highlighting some potential problems with the Court’s approach to these matters. In particular, while international humanitarian law creates reciprocal legal obligations regulating the conduct of both states and non-state actors in an internal armed conflict, converting these obligations into human rights means that they are enforceable against one party to the conflict alone, namely, the state. This discrepancy, it is argued, may give rise to a number of undesirable outcomes.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: Conor McCarthy
Institution: University of Cambridge
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: American Convention on Human Rights, international humanitarian law, armed conflict, Inter-American Court of Human Rights, Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, lex specialis, state responsibility, internal armed conflict, non-state actors, normative conflict, Central and South America
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2227547923
