Sortition and Democratic Legitimacy
Year: 2009
Type: preprint
Abstract: A number of democratic theorists have argued that representative decision-making bodies should resemble, in certain ways at least, the polity which they are meant to represent. This resemblance is a key component of arguments for selecting decision-making bodies (such as juries) at random - a practice known as sortition. Sortition, and the descriptive representation it ensures, is supposed to give the body a form of legitimacy different from, though not necessarily inferior to, the legitimacy bestowed by elections (which typically produce descriptively unrepresentative bodies). This argument for the legitimacy bestowed by descriptive representation is, however, under-theorized. This paper examines the form of legitimacy descriptive representation might bestow on a decision-making body. In particular, it examines the idea that a randomly-selected representative body allows the “voice of the people” to be heard, and that the revelation of this voice should be understood in procedural terms. This idea, I argue, is untenable so long as it remains purely procedural; that is, it requires some substantive account of the aims at which a randomly-selected decision-making body ought to aim. A satisfactory account of this nature has yet to be specified.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: Peter Stone
Institutions: Trinity College Dublin, Stanford University
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2234575894
