Reply to Salkeld et al.: Diversity-disease patterns are robust to study design, selection criteria, and publication bias
Year: 2015
Type: letter
Abstract: Recently, we provided broad evidence for a negative association between community diversity and the abundance of human and wildlife parasites (1), supporting the dilution effect hypothesis (2). Salkeld et al. (3) point out that our meta-analysis reached a different conclusion than their previous meta-analysis on the dilution effect (4), which focused solely on 13 effect sizes from six species of human parasites. Salkeld et al. (3) argue that their smaller sample size is justified because only field studies capture the ecological realism necessary to test the dilution effect hypothesis. However, field studies can have confounding variables that can generate false-positive or false-negative relationships between diversity and disease. Although laboratory studies often more confidently capture cause–effect relationships, they can be contrived. Hence, given these costs and benefits of field and laboratory studies, we included both in our meta-analysis and found that each strongly supported the dilution effect hypothesis. Nevertheless, we reanalyzed the data in our publicly available dataset using the inclusion criteria (i.e., field studies on human parasites at certain scales) of Salkeld et al. (4) and, once again, found a significant negative relationship between biodiversity and the abundance of human parasites (random effects meta-analysis: n = 22 effect sizes and 12 species as a random effect, mean Hedges’ d = −0.75, P = 0.018). Hence, the difference between the marginally nonsignificant finding in the meta-analysis of Salkeld et al. (mean Fisher’s Z = −0.23, 95% confidence interval: −0.470 to 0.008) (4) and our significant finding can be explained by the increased statistical power associated with the inclusion of nine more recent studies on six human parasites. These results further support the robustness of the negative relationship between biodiversity and infectious disease using our dataset.
Authors: David J. Civitello, Jeremy Cohen, Hiba Fatima, Neal T. Halstead, Taegan A. McMahon, C. Nicole Ortega, Erin L. Sauer, Suzanne Young, Jason R. Rohr
Institutions: University of South Florida, Duke University, University of Tampa
Language: English
Subfield: Parasitology
Field: Immunology and Microbiology
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2238010553
