Work

Climate change responses: does the nature of risk society prevent science and policy from making a difference?

Year: 2009
Type: dissertation
Abstract: ABSTRACT \nClimate change is a modern global risk and knowledge of it exists mainly in \nscientific projections. Beck’s theory of risk society, as part of the field of social \nconstructivism, implies that in a risk society, responses to risk should result in \nchanges to the fundamental causes of the risks, also known as reflexive change. \nClimate change science and responses to climate related risks should therefore \nresult in improved understanding of the nature of climate risks and of the \nfundamental causes of climate risks. In practice, the application of the theory is \nless clear, and use thereof as an analytical tool difficult, as is shown by a \npreliminary examination of the official response to climate change in South Africa. \nThe research presented here used the risk society theory to conceptualise a \nmodel framework of how responses to risk manifest in modern societies. This \nframework was then used as reference for a review of the content of the South \nAfrican national policy response to climate change and an evaluation of \ncomments obtained from some of the actors directly involved with the response. \nThe results indicate that the nature and extent of reflexive change is determined \nby perceptions or definitions of risk as part of a public, political and academic \ndebate, as well as a reaction to external opportunity costs rather than ‘pure’ \nclimate change threats. Reflexive change is therefore incidental rather than \nintentional. On the other hand, perceptions and definitions of risk impact on \ndecisions relating to strategic response directions, such as debates around \nmitigation and adaptation measures. It also shows that a wider practical \napplication of the risk society is necessary in order to fully understand its \nrelevance in non-European settings.
Authors: van Aj Arjan Weele, Gerard Alexander
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2240025702
Cites: 75
Cited by:
Related to: 10