Year: 1992
Type: article
Abstract: More than 15 years after the passage of the Education for All Handicapped Children Act (EAHCA), assessment and testing practices with students who have mild handicaps remain essentially unchanged.Testing is characterized by a high reliance on commercially available, published norm-refereficed tests (PNTs) of aptitude, achievement, and specific "abilities" (Reschly, Genshaft, & Binder, 1987).The lack ofchange is disturbing to many educators, as historically these practices have generated considerable controversy and little evidence of efficacy (Bersoff, 1973).Most of the controversy has centered on appropriateness of PNTs to identify students as learning disabled (LD), educably mentally retarded (EMR) or low achieving (Gerber & Semmel, 1984;Heller, Holtzman, & Messick, 1982; Y sseldyke, Algozzine, Shinn, & McGue, 1982;Ysseldyke & Thurlow, 1984).Their accuracy and efficacy to diagnose students differentially among disability categories has been the subject of many research articles and much special education placement litigation (e.g., Reschly, Kicklighter, & McKee, 1988c).The focus on PNTs in identification has obscured a more important question, however.Can the data derived from current testing practices be used to: (a) develop more effective interventions, and (b) evaluate the effectiveness of any specific intervention implemented (Deno, 1986; 1989)?Measurement experts summarizing litigation (e.g., Reschly, Kicklighter, & McKee, 1988a; 1988b; 1988c) concluded that the link to intervention planning and evaluation is what will form the basis for promoting assessment practices as useful.A number of resources detail why information derived from PNTs is difficult to link to intervention planning and intervention evaluation (e.g., Marston, 1989;Shinn, Nolet, & Knutson,• 1990).Stated briefly, to be useful for planning instructional interventions, a test must provide information about what skills, task preskills, or problem-solving algorithms a student does and does not demonstrate that are essential for success in the curriculum the student is expected to learn (Howell & Morehead, 1987).Key features of tests to be used for these purposes include high content validity, enough items to reliably detect error and success patterns, and response formats that rely on production-type responses (e.g., writing answers to math problems).To be useful for evaluating effectiveness of the intervention, a test must be capable of being used to write long-term (i.e., annual) goals and be used on a
Source: Focus on Exceptional Children
Authors: Mark R. Shinn, Dawn D. Hubbard
Institution: University of Oregon
Language: English
Subfield: Developmental and Educational Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: curriculum-based measurement, problem-solving assessment, mild intellectual disability, learning disabilities, special education assessment, intervention planning, intervention evaluation, content validity, Education for All Handicapped Children Act, low-achieving students, student progress monitoring
Open Access status: hybrid
Funders: Vanderbilt University, Peabody College
OpenAlex ID: W2240861189
