Work

Developing principles for prudent health care allocation. The continuing Oregon experiment.

Year: 1990
Type: article
Abstract: I have come across several types ofassociations in America ofwhich, I confess, I had not previously the slightest concep- tion, and I have often admired the extreme skill they show in proposing a common object for the exertions of very many and in inducing them voluntarily to pursue it. ALEXIS DE TOCQUEVILLE Democracy in America, 1840A llocating scarce health care resources imposes elemental choices on a democracy.Who makes the immediate choices-patient, clinician, administrator, or politician- varies with circumstances, but in a representative democracy the ultimate choices devolve on the citizens.Directly or indi- rectly, citizens supply both the funding and the moral base for the delivery of health care.The question of how citizens make, or should make, the judgments required for the pru- dent allocation of health care resources merits careful con- sideration by all.'These problems have been faced by the people of Oregon, and we describe the community dialogue process used to uncover public policy principles for setting health care priorities.Process for Consensus Building "Oregon Health Priorities for the 1990s" was a project of Oregon Health Decisions (OHD),2 supported by a grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, to determine which health services citizens considered the most important and therefore of the highest priority for government funding.3'4Oregon Health Decisions is a citizen network dedicated to raising public awareness of bioethical problems.To bring the issues of allocating health care resources to citizens, in 1987 OHD used the following steps:A steering committee, chaired by the president of the state senate, John Kitzhaber, MD, established a specific methodology and agenda of allocation issues to be discussed at local forums.Community meetings were organized throughout the state to stimulate citizens' awareness of these issues and a search for consensus.The consensus from the different community meetings was refined and collated by OHD staff into resolutions focusing on public policy con- gruent with expressed citizen values.These resolutions were presented to a Citizens' Health Care Parliament where they were received and amended by representatives of the com- munity meetings, of government, and of private organiza-tions.The parliament's resolutions were then published by OHD and circulated among public and private policy makers.The civic and humanitarian impact of the project is monitored by an implementation committee that provides testimony to the state legislature.Finally, OHD staff identi- fies related future projects.
Authors: R Crawshaw, M Garland, B Hines, B Anderson
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2243195181
FWCI: 10.92
Cites: 4
Cited by: 27
Related to: 10