Book review - Alain Pottage and Martha Mundy (eds) (2004) - Law, Anthropology and the Constitution of the Social: Making Persons and Things
Year: 2006
Type: book-review
Abstract: The categorical division between persons and things has traditionally been treated by law as something embedded in the world.There has remained a 'methodological commitment to a distinction between construction and reality' (p 3).Western legal cultures have tended to argue or perpetuate the idea that legal institutions should uphold a division between persons and things.Outcries in the past over slavery and ownership of persons, and more recently with regard to appropriation of the intellectual resources of communities or the patenting of human genomes, evidence a strong desire to maintain the divisions of person and thing.However, recent developments indicate a 'transgression' by the legal institutions of such a 'natural order' where pharmaceuticals corporations have (via intellectual property law) a grip on human tissues and 'bio-ethical legislation allows various kinds of therapeutic research on (human) embryos' (p 5).Thus the 'self-evidence' of the 'legal boundary between persons and things' (p 1) can no longer be assumed.As such, Law, Anthropology, and the Constitution of the Social explores and argues about how legal and anthropological institutions construct the categories of person and thing, persona and res.This interesting collection of essays covers a large range of topics, each exploring how legal techniques fabricate or construct the categories of person and thing.Yan Thomas examines the Roman law on tombs and the way in which the law protected the tombs instituted by bodies or remains that were not themselves protected.Bruno Latour compares the 'disinterested and unprejudiced' approaches of both law and science via ethnographic observation of their two 'laboratories': the Ecole de Physique-Chimie and the Conseil d'Etat.Tim Murphy, in his chapter 'Legal Fabrications and the Case of "Cultural Property"' questions what it is that the technologies of law make (via either mass-production or positivisation) and then how the law has played a part in the emergence of the phenomena of 'cultural property'.Martha Mundy examines the development of private property law, particularly the nature of the military 'fief' in the Islamic Ottoman Empire where, in contrast to Western/European traditions, there was not a political ideology of property asserting an absolute division between persons and things until the end of the nineteenth century.Further exploration of Islamic law is undertaken in the chapter by Engin Deniz Akarli, highlighting the way, in relation to a trader's or artisan's gedik, ownership did not entail an absolute right over a thing but a combination of certain entitlements, obligations and responsibilities which could change over time.Marilyn Strathem, as we shall see below, considers the way in which Melanesian concepts of compensation payment in Papua New Guinea reflect different notions of ownership of 'persons'.Susanne Kichler argues for a 're-visualising' of attachment via the understanding of a paradigm of 'non-linearity' that goes beyond or does away with strict notions
Source: Griffith Research Online
Author: Timothy Peters
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2244650702
