Belonging and the Limits of Moral Community
Year: 2011
Type: preprint
Abstract: This essay argues that the key challenge democracies face is building a meaningful sense of belonging between members of a heterogeneous population. Though separating people into categories of us and them is socially inevitable, this essay shows that when citizens seek political power on the grounds of moral categories of righteousness, while excluding others from power on the grounds of sinfulness, citizens end up not only undermining their capacity to build a political unity out of a heterogeneous and dynamic population. Dividing us from them, as a strategy for ambitious citizens seeking political power through creating a moral community (a strategy still prominent in contemporary electoral politics), sorts citizens into coalitions defined by increasingly polarized worldviews. Connecting a case study of the American Puritans with contemporary political debates I show how claims to political power, which center on determining the moral purity of citizens, actually ends up expanding and entrenching an authoritarian politics fundamentally hostile to democratic practices. I argue that rethinking the impulse towards building political unity out of moral standards helps citizens disrupt this polarizing sorting of the population. I propose that, left undeterred, this polarizing of citizens undermines democratic practices of debate essential to forming collective responsibility for public life.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: Jeffrey A. Becker
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2257152065
