The Effect of Perceived Risks on the Demand for Vaccination: A Discrete Choice Experiment
Year: 2007
Type: preprint
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Perceptions of risks and health outcomes are central to the study of vaccination behaviour. There are two sources of risks to be taken into account - the risk of disease if not vaccinated, and the risks of vaccine side-effects if vaccinated. Perception of being at risk of disease has a positive effect on the demand for vaccination, while the perceived risk of vaccine-associated side effects has a negative affect. In the case of childhood vaccination, parents act as agents for their child by weighing up the benefits and the costs from their decision to vaccinate or not, choosing the option that maximises their expected utility (or minimises their regret). In doing so, parents inevitably make trade-offs between the risks that their child faces. The decision to vaccinate will also be contingent on other variables, such as the cost of obtaining vaccination. The aim of this paper is to investigate the effect of these factors vaccination choices, and the tradeoffs between them. The revealed preference data that are traditionally used to analyse vaccination choices lack information on perceptions. We used a Discrete Choice Experiment (DCE) as a means of investigating stated preferences. The DCE was completed by 369 parents of children under 5 years of age. The sample is representative, in sociodemographic terms, of the relevant sub-group of the UK population. A fractional factorial design with foldover was used, resulting in each participant being presented with 12 choice sets, comprising scenarios of varying levels of the attributes regarding risk, health outcomes and cost. In each case, participants indicated whether they would choose to vaccinate or not. Although the scenarios were hypothetical to participants, the scenarios, attributes and levels were based on three real diseases, selected because of the actual variation in severity and risk associated with each: (a) Rotavirus (b) non-invasive Pneumococcal and (c) invasive Pneumococcal. Additionally, participants were asked to reflect on their anticipated regret with respect to each choice, to value each health state using a visual analogue scale, and to indicate their sources of knowledge on disease and vaccination, yielding a rich and unique data set. Analysis of these data is still underway. However, our initial findings suggest that choice of vaccination is strongly influenced by the perceived severity of the health outcomes (both of contracting the disease, and of side effects from vaccination) but, interestingly, not, as hypothesised, by the risks of experiencing these consequences. These results are placed in the context of the literature on decision theory and violations of expected utility theory. We have also generated preliminary results regarding the monetary valuation of the avoidance of adverse health states associated with disease and vaccine side effects. Results from this research can be used to inform both the design of effective vaccination policy interventions, and the economic evaluations of vaccination programmes.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: risk perception, vaccine side effects, childhood immunization, parental decision-making, rotavirus vaccine, pneumococcal vaccine, disease severity, anticipated regret, expected utility theory, vaccine cost, health state valuation, risk trade-offs, children under five, stated preference, decision theory, regret theory, risk aversion
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2261306479
