Capitalism: A Horror Story (or the Return of the Commodity Fetish)
Year: 2011
Type: preprint
Abstract: In the opening line of Capital, Marx writes that the wealth of those societies where the capitalist mode of production prevails presents itself as a monstrous [ungeheuer] accumulation of commodities. In the wake of the 2008 financial crisis, the monstrous character of capitalist accumulation is once again a topic of debate, as is Marx's possible relevance for an understanding of contemporary capitalism. This essay is my attempt to contribute to this discussion, by way of a twofold reading of Marx's Capital and its analysis of commodity fetishism, specifically. First, I argue (along with others) that Marx's analysis in Capital presents itself as a historically specific critique of the category of value, which is understood to structure human relations under conditions of capital. To the extent that value remains a central category to this day, therefore – to the extent, in other words, that ours appears as a broadly 'capitalist' society, so it seems that Marx's characterization still applies. As I also argue, however, a close reading of Marx's analysis reveals myriad ways in which the category of value does not in fact exhaust the social relations expressed in Capital, such that Marx's theory of value, as it tends to be known, is in fact exceeded by the analysis of meaning on which it depends. From this it follows that Marx's analysis, if it is to be relevant today, must be read against the grain: not as a denunciation of what we might call the logic of the market, but as an invitation to question the language of commodities [Warensprache] as it is spoken everyday, and to ask, wherever possible, what the commodity might mean.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: Ivan Ascher
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2262399152
