Recognition of prior learning in and through 'The Field' of academic practice
Year: 2001
Type: article
Abstract: Recent research has questioned whether it is possible to establish 'a match' between formal and informal learning. In this paper I deal with a different although related problematic. I examine the claim put forward by researchers in the area of Recognition of Prior Learning that as long as academics do not challenge the 'conservative epistemological assumptions' underpinning assessment of prior learning, they will continue to exclude the candidates that deserve this recognition most. More specifically, an argument is made that 'correct position' and 'a proper methodological stance', which require candidates to transcend their particular experiences, to rationally and critically reflect on them, are oppressive practices that prevent them from really discovering their own voice. I believe that collapsing correct position' and 'a proper methodical stance' to a version of 'cultural and symbolic capital' in the use of' 'hegemonic power' is a dangerous move. It is a dangerous move because it reduces the complexity of academic practice and disguises its regulatory logic. Only a simplistic reading of the notion 'politics of power and knowledge' and the blunt ways in which 'reason' and 'rational reflection' are accused for the failure, can position academic assessment of' recognition, unfairly I believe, as hegemonic act of manipulation. In response to the charge that 'correct position' and 'a proper methodical stance', are oppressive forms of assessment, this paper examines the logic of the field from which an educator sees/recognises/finds 'workplace learning'. In this sociological analysis I hope to foreground the responsibility qf the educator in the act of recognition, her significant role for the act of recognition and the structural limitations imposed on the act of recognition given the position of the educator in the field of academic practice. In drawing on Bourdieu`s sociological analysis of 'field' I hope to show that the act of recognition is done from 'a place of representation' which regulates the ways an academic recognises another practice or assess the value of elements within it.
Source: Perspectives in Education
Author: Yael Shalem
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $190
OpenAlex ID: W2263332705
