Work

Sugar-Coating Risks: An Analysis of Sweetener Trade Associations‘ Discursive Contributions to Public Negotiations of Risk

Year: 2011
Type: article
Abstract: Trade associations blur the boundaries established between research and education, as well as, advertising and advocacy.Recently, their hybrid roles as commercial and health promoters have been met with mixed reviews.While this hybridization has the potential to serve multiple stakeholder's goals by promoting healthful eating and strong consumer bases for industry groups (Wansink & Peters, 2007), Ludwig and Nestle (2008) argued that "irreconcilable conflict" between private commercial and public health interests would likely keep organizations from adequately promoting health.Given their potential to impact consumer health, it is important to examine how trade associations contribute to public understandings of food risks.Informed by a social construction of risk framework and Beck's (1992) theory of risk society, I analyze the discursive contributions of trade associations representing the sweetener industry.Specifically, I use close-textual analysis to identify and critique reoccurring and forceful rhetorical patterns within and across the online discourses produced by trade associations representing high fructose corn syrup (the Corn Refiners Association), sugar (the Sugar Association), and low-calorie sweeteners (the Calorie Control Council).My findings suggest that these trade associations provided a symbolic repertoire for identifying, making sense of, and managing risks.I argue that the trade associations iv used strategic maneuvering, including fallacious reasoning, defining tactics, ambiguity, and framing, to highlight the health benefits of their products and diminish the risks.A focus on health, specifically the relationship between caloric intake and obesity, reflected healthism (Crawford, 1984) and nutirtionism (Pollan, 2008).However, the trade associations broadened the scope of discussion about sweetener risks by highlighting the importance of the natural, taste, and consumer demand to consumption decisions.I conclude by discussing the theoretical, practical, and ethical contributions of my findings.I argue that while there is much to gain from having trade associations promote public health, their messages were skewed toward corporate interests and served to undermine public health decisions.I advise scholars to keep a close eye on the discursive activities of these trade associations and suggest future analyses of health literacy and descriptions of -best practices‖ for professionals.
Institution: Ohio University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2268823874
FWCI:
Cites: 168
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10