"Crossing the Sahara without water": A critical analysis of the macro and micro-level dynamics of persistent class inequality in the Back To Education Allowance Welfare to Education Programme.
Year: 2008
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis elaborates a critical empirical and theoretical exposition of the impact of\nthe Irish welfare to education programme, the Back to Education Allowance, on classbased\nexclusion. In doing so, it contributes to a broader understanding of dynamics of\nwelfare to education programmes in the era of the post-welfare state. It adopts a\nstrong ‘structural’ position, which sees the source of social exclusion as lying in the\nstructured inequality of the labour market and the state (Morris 1994, p.80). It rejects\narguments that social exclusion can be addressed by promoting policy that adopts a\nweak ‘cultural’ position (Morris 1994, p.80), ultimately blaming the excluded for their\nown misfortune. The thesis proposes the provision of education, and 3rd level\neducation in particular, as a key means of addressing social exclusion. Education is\ntheoretically situated in terms of its relationship with the economy and broader state\npolicy, which has (ultimately) resulted in the commodification of education\n(Mulderrig, 2003). The education system controls levels of social mobility (Drudy\nand Lynch 1993, p.26) and by extension I argue that education can affect social\nexclusion. However the education system as it stands at present serves as a means to\nreproduce society’s inequalities\nThe thesis situates the Back to Education Allowance (BTEA) in its macro level\n(global) context. It examines the system of welfare provision that exists in Ireland and\nhow that system emerged. It locates the emergence of Neoliberalism as the dominant\npolitical discourse in the 1980s, before focusing on how the construction of status\nbeliefs and the ‘New Right’ ideology of personal responsibility have justified the\nrolling back of the welfare state and the promotion of welfare to work over welfare to\neducation programmes in western societies. In doing so, the thesis argues that welfare\nrecipients have been constructed as the ‘undeserving’ poor. It is held that this\nconstruction, which is part of a Neoliberal project to retract the welfare state, has\noffered a justification for the short-term approach which this thesis finds is being\nadopted in relation to the BTEA. This thesis finds that initiatives to facilitate access to\n3rd level education for welfare recipients (on a macro level) are restricted in scope and\nsubstantially modified in practice (on a micro level) as a result of the dynamics of\ninteractions between welfare recipients and welfare officers, interactions which are\nlent great significance by the administrative nature of the BTEA. It has been found\nthat BTEA participants require certain levels of cultural and / or social capital to\novercome obstacles created by the DSFA and accordingly those who are most distant\nfrom the labour market, and who possess less capital, are considerably less likely to\nbe able to access the BTEA.\nThe thesis concludes by highlighting the positive impact of participation in the BTEA\nupon participants’ class situation, economic capital and levels of cultural capital. The\nlatter is in turn used to acquire more sustainable and secure employment, offering\nwelfare recipients the tools to combat their own social exclusion and potentially that\nof their children. However, I find that the effectiveness of the BTEA in addressing\nmore than individual exclusion is limited by the requirement for cultural and social\ncapital in order to negotiate the system and access the benefits it can offer. This\nfinding informs an evaluation of the state response to the BTEA as minimalist; the\ndocumented lack of will to maximize the BTEA’s potential is held to be reinforced by\ndominant Neoliberal ideologies.
Author: Martin J. Power
Institution: University of Limerick
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2270131673
