Posthumous Reputation and Posthumous Privacy in China: The Dead, the Law, and Social Transition
Year: 2014
Type: article
Abstract: mother. 5 For Chen, the highly erotic and offensive nature of the novel's depiction of K's relationship with Bell has "damaged the reputations of her mother and father and caused her mental anguish."6 The case was first rejected by the Beijing Haidian Basic People's Court on the ground that the defendant and plaintiff are both British citizens, and later rejected by the Beijing Intermediate People's Court for lack of jurisdiction.7 However, it was accepted by the Changchun Intermediate People's Court in Jilin Province after Chen added the Changchun-based magazines, Chinese Writers and Sichuan Youth Daily, as codefendants who published parts of Hong's book.8 The court ruled that the defendants defamed the dead, and ordered that Hong must stop calumny, and that the author should apologize openly and pay emotional damages.9 The court also granted an injunction to prevent the book from being further published, copied, or distributed in any form.10 After the defendant appealed to the High People's Court of Jilin Province, the parties agreed to a pre-trial settlement under the guidance of the High Court that was comprised of lower damages, an apology from the author, and the possibility to publish the novel under other titles after revision.11 The case attracted a lot of attention, not only from Chinese media, but also from the international community.12 Regarded as a landmark case, the decision has considerable impacts on the free speech rights of Chinese writers because it set up a 5.
Author: Bo Zhao
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2270829376
