Poverty and government expenditure: an assessment of the impact of government expenditure and interventions on poor groups with a focus on Rwanda
Year: 2004
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In this thesis we undertake a poverty and policy analysis.We argue that it is important to understand the nature, magnitude and context of poverty before one can undertake an informed policy prescription.Existing theories of poverty, welfare regimes and social policies offer a lot of useful lessons for policy, but have limitations in offering a single model for Rwanda.We demonstrate that, not only is Rwandan poverty multifaceted and deep, but it is characterized by a 'poverty conflict trap' that can be traced back to the entire postcolonial period.We argue however that the current policy is not only inefficient in targeting poverty, but it may be unable to meet the challenges of growth, redistribution and conflict mitigation.The thesis, after further analyzing policy options, puts forward a package that is needed to reduce poverty in Rwanda in the long term and to break the 'poverty conflict trap'.The prescribed package is put forward as a comprehensive and institutionalized social policy, which Rwanda so far does not have.The first level of analysis is that of poverty theories and policies.There are several schools of thought on poverty, welfare regimes and poor relief schemes that have evolved over time.We demonstrate that in all these instances, lessons are diverse and the relevance to a Third World setting is most of the time neither clear nor direct.Indeed, using a range of models, in both the First and Third World, we demonstrate that different VII impact on poverty, as is generally assumed by policy.While the Rwanda Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (PRSP) and Vision 2020 are admirable in content and comprehensiveness, we cast serious doubts about their capability to break the 'poverty conflict trap' we identified earlier.Given data and descriptive analyses we identify an appropriate policy package in two categories.Firstly we identify two preconditions needed to take care of the deep and severe poverty.These are safety nets and social sector expenditures on health and education.Specifically we identify critically the present blind spots in administering such policy, especially the fallacy of considering any of them as the sole solution to poverty.Under the same analysis we also demonstrate the importance of considering the possible impact of ethnicity on policy.It is in response to the problem of ethnic cleavages that is analysed under causes of poverty in Rwanda.The latter is related to the need to address conflict in all policy discourses on poverty in Rwanda.Butfinally for an answer to the contextual nature of poverty in Rwanda-the 'poverty-conflict trap', we propose a comprehensive land reform and a long-term universal income grant.This study was originally designed as an academic analysis of poverty within a Development Studies framework.Our findings regarding a linkage between poverty and conflict in Rwanda have shed light on wider analytical issues that may require further multidisciplinary research.While the role of conflict has been acknowledged in a majority of works on Rwanda, none to our knowledge had attempted to undertake a close analysis at the level of poverty and policy.None had addressed specifically the 'povertyconflict trap' that has not stopped with the Genocide that took place in 1994.In our study this Genocide can then be seen as one element of a conflict poverty function in Rwanda.It can be viewed, without underrating its significance, in terms of cause and effect of poverty in Rwanda.We suggest then, that the poverty -conflict cycle did not end in 1994.It is a process that has to be broken in Rwanda, now and in future.By this we are not in any way implying that Genocide was the only cause of or the only effect of poverty in Rwanda.
Author: Herman Musahara
Institution: University of the Western Cape
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2273934878
