Work

Foundations of Critical Race Theory in Education

Year: 2012
Type: book-review
Abstract: Does the election of Barack Obama as President of the United States prove that critical race theory is not true, or at least has overstated its contrarian claims that racism is permanent?"This is the question that co-editors Ladson-Billings, Gillborn and Taylor (2009) pose in their foreword to Foundations of Critical Race Theory in Education (p.ix).In a recent New York Times article, Westen (2011) has suggested that Obama failed expectations because he has not told the right story.Westen (a professor of psychology) explained that we come to expect certain stories, usually centered around heroes and villains, and that that the kind of story that Americans were hoping to hear from Obama would have provided a clear alternative to the dominant narrative of the right.With Obama, "there was no story-and there has been none since" (p.SR, 6).Meanwhile, here in Canada, Stephen Harper is said to be systematically spinning a revisionist Canadian story, one that undermines the long-held Liberal narrative of Charter, flag, peacekeeping and multiculturalism and that revolves instead around conservative symbols of: the Arctic, military, national sports and, especially, monarchy (Taber, 2011, p. A3).Foundational to critical race theory (CRT) is stories.The truth about stories, Indigenous writer and scholar Thomas King (2003) says, is that they are all we are.Stories convey what we believe; what we imagine and experience, as well as insulate us from what we don't want to think about.Writing about the Canadian treatment of Indigenous peoples, Thomas King is not a card-carrying critical race theorist, but his method of counter-story telling, by combining critical analysis with personal storytelling, is in keeping with CRT, the foundational tenets of which are addressed in this edited volume.One of its key tenets is storytelling.As the title of Foundations of Critical Race Theory in Education suggests, the volume is intended to serve as an introduction to CRT and how it can be applied to educational theory, policy and practice.Except for Taylor's introduction, all chapters were previously published, most in the 1990s, half in legal journals, the rest in journals devoted to education and qualitative research, saving an article from American Psychologist.Of the twenty chapters, six were published post-2000.As several of the contributors point out, CRT started out as a branch of Critical Legal Studies (CLS) and as such, originated as a critical response to the treatment of race in legal discourse and practice.CLS, which had its inception in the 1970s, has focused on the power relationships embedded within legal decisions.CRT concentrates on race, and arose in response to the stalling of civil rights litigation, especially from watershed cases like Brown v Board of Education.CRT has several main tenets: that racism is a permanent, normative feature of (American) society, that any apparent legal progress has been due more to interest convergence (benefits to Whites) than to genuine social justice, that racism needs to be understood historically and that the narratives of oppressed peoples stand as privileged accounts of lived experiences of racist policy and practice (Taylor, 2009).CRT carries on CLS' interest in the law but extends it to other spheres, notably, education.Like CLS, CRT defines itself as a counter-discourse that explores alternative forms of expression and evidence and is highly critical of claims of positivistic social science to neutrality.
Institution: McGill University
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W2275176086
Cites: 2
Cited by: 176
Related to: 10