Masooda BANO & Hilary KALMBACH (eds.), Women, Leadership, and Mosques, Leiden-Boston: Brill, 2012, in QSA n.s. 9(2014).
Year: 2014
Type: article
Abstract: © Istituto per l'Oriente C.A. Nallino, Roma RECENSIONI Masooda BANO & Hilary KALMBACH (eds.),Women, Leadership, and Mosques.Changes in contemporary Islamic Authority, Leiden-Boston: Brill, 2012, 581 p. (Women and Gender.The Middle East and the Islamic World).Combining different methodologies and various disciplinary approaches -e.g.Islamic Studies, Women Studies, Development Studies, Political Science, Anthropology, Sociology, Religious Studies -this remarkable volume brings together the contributions of several leading international scholars who participated in the homonymous conference (St Anthony's College, Univ. of Oxford, Oct 2009).It aims to describe, document and discuss the changes that have occurred in the last three decades, in both majority and minority contexts, in the sphere of religious Islamic authorityi.e. the mosque and the madrasa -which, as Kalmbach points out in her Introduction, pp.1-27, embodies the idea of religious authority linked with those activities that require explicitly Islamic knowledge: teaching, preaching, interpreting religious texts, leading worship etc.It is indeed a fact that over the past thirty years many female religious leaders have played a significant role in their communities despite the traditional male primacy, and this increasing ability of Muslim women to exercise Islamic authority deserves scholarly attention.The volume is organized into three sections according to the different sources and dynamics of the phenomenon considered, rather than to mere geographic distribution.Section I, entitled "Space for Female Authority: Male Invitation, State Intervention, and Female Initiative" (pp.31-183), shows how these factors have allowed women to depict religious authority in mosques and madrasas in different contexts and with a variety of typologies; it explores the conscious invitation of the male religious hierarchy in China (Maria Jaschok on the figures of ahong and qingzhen nüsi), the female agency in creating spaces for female leaders in Marocco (Margaret J. Rausch on the muršida), the State sponsorship of female preachers active alongside male colleagues in Turkey (Mona Hassan on the muftiate), gender segregation as an "opportunity" in Saudi Arabia (Amélie Le Renard on prominent female preachers recently recognized and integrated by the Ministry of Islamic Affairs), to the case of two of the most influential ŠīɈa female scholars or muǧtahidas in modern and contemporary Iran, Nuṣrat Amīn, 1886-1983, and Zuhrat Ṣifatī, b. 1948 (Mirjam Künkler & Roja Fazaeli).The last contribution of the first section is devoted to the international revivalist movement of the "Qubaysiyyāt", having several hundred thousand adherents in Syria and widely spread throughout the Middle East, originating under the guidance of Munīra al-Qubaysī, b. 1933 (Sarah Islam).Section II, "Establishing Female Authority: Limitations, Spaces, and Strategies for Theaching and Preaching" (pp.187-362), gives a number of examples of how gendered social norms impact the ability of women; and, on the other hand, how female teachers and preachers take advantage of alternative spaces or new institutions to overcome limitations and contraints.It is shed light on the ustanis in Bijnor district in North India (Patricia Jeffery, Roger Jeffery and Craig Jeffery), and on female leaders in the Netherlands (Nathal M. Dessing), Russia (Nick R. Micinski), Bosnia and Herzegovina (Catharina Raudvere), Switzerland (Petra Bleisch Bouzar), Belgium (Els Vanderwaeren) and Germany (Petra Kuppinger); and finally it examines the continuity of memory connecting Muslim societies to a shared historical past (Matthew Pierce on the authoritative model of Fatima).The third and final section, "The Impact of Authority on Muslim Women, Muslim Societies, and Conceptions of Islamic Authority" (pp.365-506), comprises six valuable essays each of which deals with the rich diversity of consequences of female Islamic activism: in Sweden (Pia Karlsson Minganti), Egypt (Hiroko Minesaki), Indonesia (Pieternella van Doorn-Harder), Germany (Riem Spielhaus), North America (Juliane Hammer) and South Africa (Uta Christina Lehmann).
Author: Ida Zilio Grandi
Language: English
Topic: Islamic Studies and History
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Gender equality
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2276126481
